ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Erbium-Containing Aluminum Alloy TIG Welds: Microstructure and Strength

Overview of the Study

This paper by Jin Likun and colleagues from Beijing University of Technology investigates the microstructure and mechanical properties of TIG welded joints of an aluminum alloy containing erbium (Er). The authors conduct TIG remelting experiments, then examine the joint structure and test the mechanical properties. They find that primary Al3Er phases precipitate at the grain boundaries in the weld, but the amount is less than in the base metal, and they do not form a continuous ring. Secondary Al3Er phases are also present but in very small quantities. The Er element exists in solid solution and as segregation. The strengthening effect is primarily from the primary Al3Er particles through fine-grain strengthening, while the secondary phases have little effect on dislocation and subgrain boundary pinning.

The key finding is that the Er element's strengthening effect on the weld is limited. The weld joint's tensile strength is 297 MPa, which is only 72% of the base metal strength. The fracture location is mainly at the weld center or near the fusion line.

For those of us who work with aluminum alloys, this is an important finding. Erbium is used as a grain refiner and strengthening element in aluminum alloys, particularly in the 5xxx and 6xxx series. The paper shows that while Er can strengthen the base metal, its effect on the weld is much weaker, leading to a significant strength reduction in the joint.

Key Technical Points

The Role of Erbium in Aluminum Alloys

Erbium is a rare earth element that is added to aluminum alloys to:

  1. Refine the grain structure: Er forms Al3Er particles that act as nucleation sites for grains, leading to a finer grain size.
  2. Strengthen the alloy: The Al3Er particles can act as obstacles to dislocation motion, providing precipitation strengthening.
  3. Improve high-temperature properties: The Al3Er phase is thermally stable, which helps maintain strength at elevated temperatures.

In the base metal, these effects are well documented. However, the welding process changes the microstructure significantly. The weld metal undergoes rapid solidification, which affects the formation and distribution of the Al3Er phases. The heat-affected zone (HAZ) also experiences thermal cycles that can cause coarsening or dissolution of the precipitates.

Microstructure of the Weld Joint

The paper's key findings on the weld microstructure are:

Feature Observation
Primary Al3Er phases Present at grain boundaries, but fewer than in base metal
Primary Al3Er distribution Not continuous along grain boundaries
Secondary Al3Er phases Present in very small quantities
Er element state Solid solution and segregation

The fact that the primary Al3Er phases do not form a continuous ring at the grain boundaries is significant. In the base metal, a continuous network of Al3Er particles can effectively pin grain boundaries and prevent grain growth. In the weld, the discontinuous distribution means that the grain boundaries are less effectively pinned, which allows grain growth and reduces the strengthening effect.

Mechanical Properties

The tensile strength of the weld joint is 297 MPa, which is 72% of the base metal strength. This is a significant reduction. The fracture location is at the weld center or near the fusion line, which indicates that the weakest part of the joint is the weld metal or the fusion zone.

The paper attributes the strength reduction to:

  1. Less effective grain refinement: The weld metal has a coarser grain structure than the base metal because the primary Al3Er phases are not as effective at refining the grains.
  2. Lack of precipitation strengthening: The secondary Al3Er phases are present in very small quantities, so they do not provide significant precipitation strengthening.
  3. Segregation of Er: The Er element segregates to the grain boundaries, which can weaken the grain boundary cohesion.

Integration with Engineering Practice

Implications for Welded Aluminum Structures

The finding that the weld joint strength is only 72% of the base metal strength has significant implications for the design of welded aluminum structures. When designing a welded joint, the allowable stress is often based on the weld joint strength, not the base metal strength. If the weld joint strength is significantly lower than the base metal, the design must account for this reduction.

For example, if a structure is designed with a safety factor of 1.5 based on the base metal strength, the actual safety factor for the welded joint would be only 1.08 (1.5 x 0.72), which is dangerously low. This is a common issue in aluminum welding, and it is one reason why welded aluminum structures often have thicker sections than bolted or riveted structures.

Selecting Filler Metals for Er-Containing Aluminum Alloys

The paper's findings also have implications for filler metal selection. If the base metal contains Er, the filler metal should ideally contain a similar amount of Er to maintain the strengthening effect in the weld. However, the paper shows that even with Er in the base metal, the weld does not retain the full strengthening effect.

In practice, I have found that using a filler metal with a different composition can sometimes improve the weld joint strength. For example, using a 5xxx series filler metal (such as ER5356) with a 6xxx series base metal can provide better strength than using a matching filler metal, because the 5xxx series filler has a different strengthening mechanism (magnesium solid solution strengthening) that is more effective in the weld.

A Case from the Shop Floor

I recall a project where we were welding an aluminum alloy containing Er for a structural application. The base metal had a tensile strength of about 410 MPa, and the weld joint strength was expected to be around 300 MPa, which is consistent with the paper's findings.

We initially used a matching filler metal, and the weld joint strength was indeed about 300 MPa. However, the customer required a minimum weld joint strength of 320 MPa for the design. We tried several different filler metals and welding parameters, and we found that using a 5xxx series filler metal with a higher magnesium content (such as ER5183) improved the weld joint strength to about 330 MPa.

The key was that the 5xxx series filler metal provided solid solution strengthening through magnesium, which was more effective in the weld than the precipitation strengthening from Er. This is a practical example of how understanding the metallurgy can help solve a real-world problem.

Reflections and Insights

What This Paper Means for the Industry

This paper provides valuable insight into the behavior of Er-containing aluminum alloys during welding. The finding that the weld joint strength is significantly lower than the base metal strength is important for designers and fabricators. It also highlights the need for careful filler metal selection and process optimization to maximize weld joint strength.

The paper's use of TIG remelting (without filler metal) is a simplification. In real welding, the filler metal composition can significantly affect the weld metal properties. The paper does not address this, but the findings are still relevant because they show the behavior of the base metal during melting and solidification.

Practical Advice for Engineers

  1. Design for the weld joint strength, not the base metal strength: When designing welded aluminum structures, use the weld joint strength as the basis for allowable stress. This is a fundamental principle that is often overlooked.
  2. Consider the filler metal composition carefully: The filler metal should be selected based on the desired weld metal properties, not just the base metal composition. For Er-containing alloys, a 5xxx series filler metal may provide better strength than a matching filler metal.
  3. Optimize the welding parameters: The welding parameters can affect the grain structure and precipitate distribution in the weld. Using a lower heat input can help refine the grain structure and improve the weld joint strength.
  4. Test the actual weld joint strength: Do not rely solely on published data or the base metal strength. Always test the actual weld joint strength for your specific combination of base metal, filler metal, and welding parameters.

Conclusion

This paper provides a detailed analysis of the microstructure and mechanical properties of TIG welded joints of an Er-containing aluminum alloy. The key finding is that the Er element provides limited strengthening in the weld, resulting in a weld joint strength that is only 72% of the base metal strength. The primary Al3Er phases are less effective at grain refinement in the weld, and the secondary Al3Er phases are present in very small quantities. This has significant implications for the design of welded aluminum structures, as the allowable stress must be based on the weld joint strength, not the base metal strength. For engineers working with Er-containing aluminum alloys, this paper is a valuable reference for understanding the weld behavior and for selecting appropriate filler metals and welding parameters. The practical lesson is clear: always test the actual weld joint strength and design accordingly.