ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Experimental Study on Colour Difference in TIG Repair Welding of ZL101A Aluminium Alloy

Literature Overview and Core Findings

This paper by Zhang Tengfei, Zhou Dan, Liu Jianli and Li Baiqing from the Hefei University of Technology and Anhui Ruisaike Renewable Resources Technology Co., Ltd., published in Hot Working Technology in 2022, addresses a problem that is often overlooked in the welding industry but is of great importance in certain applications: the colour difference that appears on the surface of an aluminium alloy after TIG repair welding. The authors focus on ZL101A, a cast aluminium-silicon alloy that is widely used in automotive and aerospace components, and they investigate the mechanisms that cause the colour difference, as well as the effects of surface roughness and microstructure on the severity of the colour difference. The key findings are that the colour difference first increases and then decreases as the surface roughness decreases, and that the precipitation of black silicon (Si) phase in the microstructure increases the colour difference, while the precipitation of grey Mg2Si phase produces a relatively small colour difference, but as the Mg2Si phase becomes coarser and more densely distributed, the colour difference increases.

Technical Interpretation of the Colour Difference Mechanism

The colour difference in a welded aluminium alloy surface is a visual phenomenon that is caused by the interaction of light with the surface oxide layer and the underlying microstructure. When a TIG weld is made on an aluminium alloy, the surface oxide layer is disrupted and reformed, and the microstructure of the fusion zone is altered by the thermal cycle. The oxide layer on aluminium is normally a thin, transparent film of alumina (Al2O3), but after welding, the oxide layer can be thicker, more irregular, and can contain inclusions of the alloying elements, which change its optical properties. The colour difference is a measure of the difference in the perceived colour between the weld and the base metal, and it is quantified using the CIELAB colour space, where the difference is expressed as a delta E value. The authors found that the surface roughness has a non-linear effect on the colour difference: as the roughness decreases, the colour difference first increases and then decreases. This is consistent with the physics of light scattering, where a very smooth surface reflects light specularly, producing a strong colour signal, while a very rough surface scatters light diffusely, reducing the colour contrast. The intermediate roughness produces a combination of specular and diffuse reflection, which maximises the colour difference.

The microstructural effect is more complex. The authors found that the precipitation of black Si phase in the fusion zone increases the colour difference, while the precipitation of grey Mg2Si phase produces a smaller colour difference. This is because the Si phase, which appears as black particles under optical microscopy, has a different refractive index and reflectivity than the aluminium matrix, which creates a strong optical contrast. The Mg2Si phase, which appears as grey particles, has a smaller optical contrast with the aluminium matrix, so it produces a smaller colour difference. However, as the Mg2Si phase becomes coarser and more densely distributed, the cumulative effect of the many small grey particles increases the overall colour difference. The practical implication is that the colour difference can be minimised by controlling the welding parameters to produce a fine, uniformly distributed microstructure, and by controlling the surface finish to achieve a roughness that minimises the colour contrast.

Practical Application and Lessons from the Shop Floor

The colour difference in aluminium alloy repair welding is a cosmetic issue, but it is not trivial. In the automotive and aerospace industries, the appearance of the repaired component is often a requirement, and a colour difference that is visible to the customer can result in the rejection of the component. In my experience, the most common cause of colour difference in aluminium alloy repair welding is not the welding process itself, but the post-weld surface treatment. If the weld is ground and polished to a different surface finish than the base metal, the colour difference will be visible, regardless of the microstructure. The authors' finding that the colour difference first increases and then decreases with decreasing surface roughness suggests that there is an optimal surface finish that minimises the colour difference, and this should be determined experimentally for each alloy and each welding process. In a production environment, this means that the post-weld grinding and polishing procedure must be specified and controlled, and that the surface roughness should be measured and verified to be within the specified range.

The microstructural effect is more difficult to control, because it is determined by the welding thermal cycle and the alloy composition. The authors found that the precipitation of Si phase increases the colour difference, which suggests that the welding parameters should be adjusted to minimise the amount of Si phase that precipitates in the fusion zone. This can be achieved by using a lower heat input, which reduces the time that the weld metal spends at the temperature where Si precipitation is favoured, or by using a filler metal that has a lower Si content. However, the Si content of ZL101A is fixed by the alloy specification, so the filler metal must be chosen to match the base metal, and the welding parameters must be optimised to minimise the precipitation. The authors do not provide a detailed welding procedure, but they do provide the key insight that the microstructure is a controllable factor that affects the colour difference.

Key Questions and Reflections

One question that the paper raises but does not fully answer is the relationship between the colour difference and the corrosion resistance of the weld. The colour difference is caused by the surface oxide layer and the microstructure, both of which can affect the corrosion behaviour of the alloy. A thick, irregular oxide layer can be a site for pitting corrosion, and the presence of Si phase particles can create galvanic cells that accelerate corrosion. The authors do not address this, but it is an important consideration for any application where the repaired component will be exposed to a corrosive environment. Another question is the repeatability of the colour difference measurement. The CIELAB colour space is a standard method for quantifying colour difference, but the measurement is sensitive to the lighting conditions, the viewing angle, and the surface finish. In a production environment, the colour difference must be measured under controlled conditions, and the measurement procedure must be documented and verified. The authors do not provide a detailed measurement procedure, but they do use the standard CIELAB method, which is a good starting point.

Study Insights and Implications for Practice

The most valuable takeaway from this study is that the colour difference in aluminium alloy repair welding is a controllable phenomenon that can be minimised by optimising the surface finish and the welding parameters. The authors have identified the two main factors that contribute to the colour difference, and they have provided a clear explanation of the mechanisms. For a welding engineer who is responsible for the repair of aluminium alloy components, this paper provides practical guidance on how to achieve a visually acceptable repair. The key is to control the surface roughness to the optimal value, and to adjust the welding parameters to produce a fine, uniformly distributed microstructure that minimises the optical contrast. In my experience, the most effective way to achieve this is to use a low heat input, a fast travel speed, and a filler metal that is matched to the base metal composition. The post-weld surface treatment should be specified to achieve the optimal roughness, and the surface should be cleaned thoroughly to remove any oxide or contamination that could affect the appearance.

Reference Value and Outlook

This paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in the repair welding of aluminium alloy components, particularly in the automotive and aerospace industries, where the appearance of the repaired component is a requirement. The authors have provided a clear explanation of the colour difference mechanism and have identified the key factors that control it. The practical guidance on surface roughness and microstructure control is directly applicable to production environments. However, the paper does not address the relationship between the colour difference and the mechanical properties or corrosion resistance of the weld, which is an important gap that should be filled by future research. In my judgment, the colour difference should not be treated as a purely cosmetic issue; it is a visual indicator of the surface condition and the microstructure, both of which can affect the performance of the component. A weld that has a significant colour difference may also have a compromised oxide layer or a coarse microstructure, which could reduce its corrosion resistance or its fatigue life. Therefore, the colour difference should be controlled not just for aesthetic reasons, but also as a quality control measure.