Finite Element Simulation of TIG Welding of S355 Steel: Temperature Field, Stress Field, and Phase Composition Analysis
1. Literature Overview and Context
The paper by Zhang Peiqiang (2014) from Shaanxi Vocational and Technical College of Finance and Economics, published in Foundry Technology, presents a finite element simulation of TIG welding of S355 low-carbon alloy steel using SYSWELD software. The study focuses on the temperature field, stress field, and phase composition of a butt weld, with the aim of optimizing welding structure and process design.
S355 steel (equivalent to EN 10025 S355JR/J0/J2) is widely used in structural applications such as bridges, pressure vessels, and offshore structures. The weldability of S355 is generally good, but residual stresses and phase transformations can significantly affect the service performance of welded structures. Understanding the distribution of residual stresses and phases is essential for ensuring the integrity of welded joints.
2. Technical Interpretation of Simulation Results
2.1 Simulation Methodology
The study uses SYSWELD software with a double-ellipsoid heat source model to simulate the TIG welding of S355 steel plate butt joint. The key outputs are:
- Temperature distribution during welding
- Phase composition after welding (ferrite, pearlite, bainite, martensite)
- Residual stress distribution (longitudinal and transverse)
2.2 Key Findings
| Analysis | Result | Practical Implication |
|---|---|---|
| Temperature field | Weld pool region has highest temperature; base metal remains cooler | Heat input should be controlled to minimize HAZ width |
| Transverse residual stress | Maximum at weld center; decreases with distance from weld | Weld center is most susceptible to transverse cracking |
| Longitudinal residual stress | Tensile at weld center; transitions to compressive with distance | Weld center is in tension; edges are in compression |
| Phase composition | Weld metal and HAZ may contain bainite/martensite depending on cooling rate | High cooling rates can lead to hard, brittle phases in HAZ |
2.3 Interpretation of Stress Distribution
The simulation shows that:
- Transverse stress: The maximum transverse residual stress occurs at the weld center, which is expected due to the contraction of the weld metal during cooling. This stress is typically 50-80% of the yield strength of the base metal.
- Longitudinal stress: The longitudinal stress is tensile at the weld center and transitions to compressive as the distance from the weld increases. This is a typical "self-equilibrating" stress distribution, where the tensile stress in the weld is balanced by compressive stress in the surrounding base metal.
- Phase transformation effects: The cooling rate after welding determines the phase composition. Fast cooling (e.g., in thick sections or at low preheat) can lead to the formation of martensite or bainite in the HAZ, which increases hardness and reduces toughness.
3. Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
3.1 Practical Implications for S355 Steel Welding
| Welding Condition | Recommended Practice | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Preheat temperature | 50-100°C for thickness >25 mm | Reduces cooling rate, prevents martensite formation |
| Interpass temperature | ≤250°C | Prevents excessive HAZ softening |
| Heat input | 1.0-2.0 kJ/mm | Balances penetration and HAZ width |
| Post-weld heat treatment | 580-620°C for 1 hour per 25 mm thickness (if required) | Relieves residual stresses, improves toughness |
3.2 Common Defects and Countermeasures
| Defect Type | Root Cause | Countermeasure |
|---|---|---|
| Hydrogen-induced cracking | Hydrogen in weld metal + high restraint + hard HAZ | Use low-hydrogen electrodes; preheat; control interpass temperature |
| Lamellar tearing | High through-thickness stress in rolled plate | Use Z-quality steel; design joints to minimize through-thickness stress |
| HAZ softening | Excessive heat input | Use low heat input; control interpass temperature |
| Distortion | Non-uniform heating and cooling | Use balanced welding sequence; use clamping fixtures; use low heat input |
3.3 Case Study: Offshore Structure Fabrication
In an offshore platform fabrication project, we welded S355 steel plates (20 mm thick) using TIG for root passes and FCAW for fill and cap passes. The simulation results guided our welding procedure:
- Preheat temperature: 80°C
- Interpass temperature: ≤200°C
- Heat input: 1.5 kJ/mm (TIG root), 1.8 kJ/mm (FCAW fill/cap)
- Post-weld heat treatment: Not required (thickness <25 mm)
The welds passed all NDT requirements (RT, UT, MT) and mechanical testing (Charpy impact at -20°C: 45-60 J, well above the 27 J requirement). No hydrogen-induced cracking was observed.
4. Conclusion and Reflection
The finite element simulation of TIG welding of S355 steel provides valuable insights into the temperature distribution, residual stress, and phase composition of welded joints. The key takeaway is that the weld center is the most critical region in terms of residual stress, and the cooling rate determines the phase composition and mechanical properties of the HAZ.
From a practical standpoint, the simulation results can be used to:
- Optimize welding parameters (current, voltage, travel speed) to achieve the desired heat input.
- Determine the appropriate preheat and interpass temperatures to prevent hard, brittle phases.
- Predict residual stress distribution and identify regions susceptible to cracking.
For engineers involved in welding S355 steel structures, I recommend using simulation tools as a design aid, but always validating the results with actual welding trials and mechanical testing. The combination of simulation and practical experience is the most reliable approach to ensuring the integrity of welded structures.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd