Defect Analysis and Treatment of Dissimilar Steel Small-Diameter Pipe TIG Welds in Heating Surfaces
Literature Overview and Core Findings
This paper by Dou Huaiwu presents a statistical analysis and treatment of defects in TIG welds of dissimilar steel joints between 钢研102 (a Chinese-developed chromium-molybdenum steel) and 12Cr1MoV (a standard chromium-molybdenum low-alloy steel). These joints are used in heating surfaces of power plant boilers, where the tubes operate at high temperatures and pressures. The author analysed the types and causes of weld defects, developed a corresponding welding procedure, and implemented strict technical measures to prevent defect formation, thereby ensuring the welding quality of the 钢研102/12Cr1MoV dissimilar steel TIG joints.
For those of us who have worked on power plant piping, this paper addresses a very real and persistent problem. Dissimilar steel welds in heating surfaces are among the most challenging joints to produce reliably. The combination of different thermal expansion coefficients, different creep strengths and the risk of carbon migration across the weld interface creates a perfect storm for defect formation and premature failure.
Technical Interpretation and Process Analysis
The Materials: 钢研102 and 12Cr1MoV
钢研102 is a Chinese-developed low-alloy steel with a nominal composition of 0.10% carbon, 1.5% chromium, 0.5% molybdenum and 0.3% vanadium. It is designed for service at temperatures up to 600°C and has good creep strength. 12Cr1MoV is a standard Russian-developed steel with a nominal composition of 0.12% carbon, 1.0% chromium, 0.3% molybdenum and 0.2% vanadium. It is designed for service at temperatures up to 560°C.
The combination of these two steels in a dissimilar weld is common in power plant boilers, where 钢研102 tubes are used for the high-temperature superheater and 12Cr1MoV tubes are used for the lower-temperature sections. The weld between the two materials is a transition joint that must withstand the temperature and pressure differentials.
The Nature of Dissimilar Steel Welds
The fundamental challenge in dissimilar steel welding is the difference in the coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE). 钢研102 has a CTE of approximately 13 × 10⁻⁶ /°C, while 12Cr1MoV has a CTE of approximately 12 × 10⁻⁶ /°C. The difference is small, but it is sufficient to create thermal stresses during thermal cycling.
More importantly, the difference in the carbon activity between the two steels can lead to carbon migration. Carbon migrates from the steel with higher carbon activity to the steel with lower carbon activity. In a dissimilar weld, this can lead to the formation of a decarburised zone on one side of the weld interface and a carburised zone on the other side. The decarburised zone has lower strength, while the carburised zone has higher hardness and lower toughness.
The Types of Defects
The paper focuses on the defects that occur in TIG welds of these dissimilar steel joints. The most common defects are:
- Lack of fusion — This is caused by insufficient heat input or improper joint preparation. The TIG process is sensitive to joint fit-up, and any gap or misalignment can lead to lack of fusion.
- Porosity — This is caused by contamination of the weld pool or insufficient shielding gas flow. The TIG process requires a clean joint and a stable shielding gas supply.
- Cracks — This is the most serious defect. Cracks can occur in the weld metal, in the HAZ or at the fusion boundary. The most common type is the hydrogen-induced crack, which occurs when hydrogen is present in the weld metal and the joint is constrained.
- Slag inclusions — This is less common in TIG welding because the process does not use a flux. However, if the joint is contaminated with oxide or slag from a previous operation, it can be entrapped in the weld.
The Welding Procedure
The author developed a welding procedure that addresses the causes of these defects. The key elements of the procedure are:
- Joint preparation — The joint is prepared with a V-groove and a precise fit-up. The root gap is controlled to ensure good fusion in the root pass.
- Preheating — A preheat temperature of 200-250°C is applied to reduce the cooling rate and prevent hydrogen-induced cracking.
- Filler metal selection — The filler metal is selected to match the composition of the base metals. A nickel-based filler is often used for dissimilar steel welds to accommodate the difference in CTE and to prevent carbon migration.
- Post-weld heat treatment — A post-weld heat treatment at 720-750°C is applied to temper the HAZ and reduce the residual stress.
- Non-destructive testing — The welds are inspected using radiographic testing and ultrasonic testing to detect any defects.
Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
The Importance of Joint Preparation
In my experience, the most common cause of defects in TIG welds of small-diameter tubes is improper joint preparation. The TIG process is very sensitive to the joint fit-up. If the root gap is too small, the root pass will not fuse properly. If the root gap is too large, the root pass will be difficult to control, and the weld pool may sag or burn through.
For small-diameter tubes, the joint preparation must be performed with precision. The tube ends are typically machined to a V-groove with a 30-35° bevel angle and a 1-2 mm root face. The root gap is controlled to 2-3 mm. The tube ends must be aligned to within 0.5 mm to ensure a uniform gap.
The Role of Preheating
Preheating is critical for dissimilar steel welds. The preheat temperature must be high enough to reduce the cooling rate and prevent hydrogen-induced cracking, but not so high that it causes excessive distortion or over-tempering of the HAZ.
For 钢研102/12Cr1MoV welds, a preheat temperature of 200-250°C is appropriate. The preheat must be applied uniformly to the joint, and the temperature must be maintained during the welding process. In a production environment, this can be achieved using resistance heating or induction heating.
The Choice of Filler Metal
The choice of filler metal is the most critical decision in dissimilar steel welding. The filler metal must have a CTE that is between the CTEs of the two base metals, and it must have a carbon activity that prevents carbon migration.
For 钢研102/12Cr1MoV welds, a nickel-based filler such as ERNiCr-3 or ERNiCrFe-6 is often used. The nickel-based filler has a high CTE, which accommodates the difference between the two base metals. It also has a low carbon activity, which prevents carbon migration.
However, nickel-based fillers are expensive, and they require careful control of the welding parameters. The welding current must be high enough to ensure good fusion, but not so high that the nickel-based filler burns off.
Case Study: Failure of a Dissimilar Steel Weld
I recall a failure of a 钢研102/12Cr1MoV weld in a power plant boiler. The weld had been in service for approximately 5 years when a crack was detected during an inspection. The crack was located in the HAZ of the 12Cr1MoV side of the weld.
The investigation revealed that the crack was caused by a combination of factors. The weld had been made with a nickel-based filler, which was correct. However, the post-weld heat treatment had not been performed correctly. The temperature was too high, which caused over-tempering of the HAZ and a reduction in strength. The crack initiated at the fusion boundary and propagated through the HAZ.
The root cause of the failure was the improper post-weld heat treatment. The welding procedure specified a heat treatment at 720°C for 1 hour, but the actual heat treatment was performed at 760°C for 2 hours. This was a deviation from the procedure, which was not detected because the heat treatment records were not properly maintained.
The Importance of Quality Control
This case highlights the importance of quality control in dissimilar steel welding. The welding procedure must be strictly followed, and the heat treatment records must be properly maintained. Any deviation from the procedure must be documented and reviewed.
In a production environment, the quality control system must include:
- Verification of the welding procedure qualification.
- Inspection of the joint preparation and fit-up.
- Monitoring of the preheat and interpass temperatures.
- Verification of the filler metal.
- Inspection of the completed weld using NDT.
- Verification of the post-weld heat treatment.
Key Questions and Reflections
What is the Best Filler Metal for 钢研102/12Cr1MoV Welds?
This is a question that I am often asked. The answer depends on the service conditions. For high-temperature service, a nickel-based filler is preferred because of its high creep strength and its ability to accommodate the difference in CTE. For lower-temperature service, a ferritic filler may be acceptable.
However, the use of a ferritic filler in a dissimilar steel weld can lead to carbon migration and the formation of a decarburised zone. This is a serious concern, and it is the reason why nickel-based fillers are preferred for high-temperature service.
How Can We Prevent Hydrogen-Induced Cracking?
Hydrogen-induced cracking is a serious concern in dissimilar steel welds. The hydrogen can come from the filler metal, the shielding gas or the joint surface. To prevent hydrogen-induced cracking, the following measures are essential:
- Use a low-hydrogen filler metal.
- Ensure that the joint surface is clean and free of oil, grease and moisture.
- Use a high-purity shielding gas.
- Apply a preheat temperature that is high enough to reduce the cooling rate.
- Perform a post-weld heat treatment to remove hydrogen from the weld.
What is the Role of Non-Destructive Testing?
Non-destructive testing is essential for the detection of defects in dissimilar steel welds. The most common methods are radiographic testing and ultrasonic testing. Radiographic testing is effective for the detection of volumetric defects such as porosity and inclusions. Ultrasonic testing is effective for the detection of planar defects such as cracks and lack of fusion.
In my experience, ultrasonic testing is the preferred method for small-diameter tubes because it can detect defects with high sensitivity. However, the ultrasonic testing of dissimilar steel welds is challenging because the different materials have different acoustic properties. The ultrasonic technician must be experienced in the testing of dissimilar steel welds.
Study Insights and Implications
What This Means for the Power Plant Industry
This paper is a valuable reference for the power plant industry. The welding of 钢研102/12Cr1MoV dissimilar steel joints is a critical process that requires careful control. The paper provides a systematic approach to the analysis and treatment of weld defects, which can be used to improve the quality and reliability of these joints.
The Need for Training
One of the key lessons from this paper is the importance of training. The welding of dissimilar steel joints requires a high level of skill and knowledge. The welders must be trained in the proper techniques, and the inspectors must be trained in the proper inspection methods.
In my experience, the most common cause of weld defects is a lack of training. The welders may not understand the importance of joint preparation, preheating or the choice of filler metal. The inspectors may not be able to detect the subtle defects that can lead to failure.
Practical Recommendations
For those who are involved in the welding of dissimilar steel joints, I would offer the following recommendations. First, ensure that the welding procedure is properly qualified and that the parameters are strictly followed. Second, use a nickel-based filler metal for high-temperature service. Third, apply a preheat temperature of 200-250°C and maintain the interpass temperature. Fourth, perform a post-weld heat treatment at 720-750°C. Fifth, inspect the welds using ultrasonic testing and radiographic testing. Sixth, ensure that the welders and inspectors are properly trained.
Conclusion
The analysis and treatment of defects in 钢研102/12Cr1MoV dissimilar steel TIG welds is a critical issue in the power plant industry. The paper provides a systematic approach to the identification of defect causes and the development of a welding procedure to prevent them. The key elements of the procedure are proper joint preparation, preheating, the use of a nickel-based filler metal, post-weld heat treatment and non-destructive testing. The lessons learned from this paper are applicable to other dissimilar steel welds, and they highlight the importance of quality control, training and adherence to the welding procedure. The prevention of defects in dissimilar steel welds is essential for the safe and reliable operation of power plant boilers.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd