Programmed TIG Welding Process for Tube-to-Tubesheet Circumferential Joints
Literature Overview
This paper by Zhao Jingguo, Zhang Menglin, and Fu Liming from the Harbin Air Conditioning Plant addresses a common problem in the manufacture of air cooler tube bundles: the tube-to-tubesheet weld quality. The authors describe the transition from manual arc welding to a programmed TIG welding process, motivated by the poor quality, high labor intensity, low efficiency, and frequent leakage during pressure testing that characterized the manual process.
The paper details the development of a programmed TIG welding process for the tube-to-tubesheet circumferential joint, including the joint design, welding power source, and process parameters. The authors report that the programmed process significantly improves weld quality, reduces rework, and increases productivity.
Joint Design and Process Parameters
The tube-to-tubesheet joint is one of the most critical and difficult weld joints in heat exchanger fabrication. The joint configuration must accommodate the tube expansion, the weld filler metal, and the service conditions of the heat exchanger. The authors describe a joint design that involves a small groove on the tubesheet face, allowing the TIG welding torch to access the joint and deposit the filler metal uniformly.
| Parameter | Manual Arc Welding | Programmed TIG Welding |
|---|---|---|
| Welding Process | SMAW | GTAW (TIG) |
| Joint Type | Fillet or partial penetration | Full penetration with groove |
| Welding Current | 90-120 A | 80-110 A (pulsed) |
| Welding Voltage | 22-26 V | 10-14 V |
| Welding Speed | Manual, inconsistent | 8-12 cm/min, consistent |
| Filler Metal | E308L or similar | ER308L or similar, 1.6 mm diameter |
| Shielding Gas | None or CO2 | Argon, 99.99% purity |
The programmed TIG process uses a welding power source with a programmable controller that can set the welding current, voltage, travel speed, and filler wire feed rate precisely. This eliminates the variability inherent in manual welding, where the welder's skill and fatigue affect the weld quality.
Quality Control and Practical Experience
In my experience, the tube-to-tubesheet weld is the most common source of leakage in air coolers and heat exchangers. The leakage often occurs due to lack of fusion, porosity, or incomplete penetration, all of which are exacerbated by manual welding variability. The programmed TIG process addresses these issues by providing consistent heat input, precise arc control, and uniform filler metal deposition.
The authors report that the programmed process eliminates the leakage problems experienced with manual welding. The key quality control measures include:
- Verification of tube-to-tubesheet fit-up before welding, with a maximum gap of 0.1 mm.
- Pre-weld cleaning of the joint area to remove oil, grease, and oxide films.
- Use of high-purity argon shielding gas with a flow rate of 10-15 L/min.
- Post-weld visual inspection of all welds, followed by hydrostatic testing at 1.5 times the design pressure.
- Radiographic or ultrasonic testing of a percentage of welds as required by the applicable code.
Reflections
The transition from manual arc welding to programmed TIG welding for tube-to-tubesheet joints is a classic example of how process automation can improve quality and productivity. However, I have seen many shops make the mistake of assuming that automation alone solves all problems. The programmed TIG process requires meticulous setup and maintenance, including:
- Proper electrode grinding to maintain a consistent tip geometry.
- Regular calibration of the wire feeder to ensure accurate filler metal deposition.
- Cleanliness of the shielding gas system to prevent contamination.
- Training of operators to understand the process and respond to variations.
In my experience, the most successful implementations of programmed TIG welding for tube-to-tubesheet joints involve a team approach, where the welding engineer, quality control inspector, and operator work together to establish and maintain the process. The benefits are substantial: reduced rework, lower labor costs, and improved product reliability. I would recommend that any shop considering this technology first conduct a thorough cost-benefit analysis, including the cost of the equipment, the training of operators, and the potential savings from reduced rework and improved quality.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd