Fine Microstructure Characterization of Ship Titanium Alloy Welded Joints
Literature Overview and Core Findings
This paper by Gao Fuyang, Liao Zhiqian, Xiong Jinhui, and Li Shikai from the 725th Research Institute of China Shipbuilding Industry Corporation, published in the Journal of Welding (2016, Vol. 37, No. 4), presents a detailed microstructural characterisation of TIG welded joints in 12 mm thick Ti6321 titanium alloy. The study employs optical microscopy (OM) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM) to analyse the welded joint microstructure, dividing the joint into distinct zones and discussing the fine microstructural evolution in each zone.
The key findings are:
- The weld metal exhibits a transition from columnar grains at the surface to equiaxed grains toward the centre, with the α phase within grains showing a tendency toward coarsening and equiaxed morphology as the high-temperature residence time increases and the temperature gradient decreases. Dislocation density increases in this region.
- The heat-affected zone (HAZ) is divided into three subzones based on the maximum temperature reached during the welding thermal cycle: the transition zone, the fine-grained zone, and the coarse-grained zone. The transition zone consists of equiaxed α, rod-shaped α, and residual β. The fine-grained zone contains rod-shaped α and residual β. The coarse-grained zone exhibits acicular α and residual β. As the high-temperature residence time decreases, the intragranular α becomes finer and the dislocation density decreases.
Technical Interpretation and Metallurgical Analysis
Weld Metal Microstructural Evolution
The columnar-to-equiaxed transition in the weld metal is a classic solidification phenomenon. Near the fusion boundary, the temperature gradient is steep and the solidification rate is low, favouring columnar growth. Toward the weld centre, the temperature gradient decreases and the solidification rate increases, promoting equiaxed grain formation.
The coarsening of intragranular α with increasing high-temperature residence time is a diffusion-controlled process. In titanium alloys, the α phase morphology and size significantly influence mechanical properties. Coarser α generally provides lower strength but higher ductility, while finer α provides higher strength but lower ductility.
The increasing dislocation density in the weld metal is attributed to the thermal stresses generated during cooling. As the weld metal solidifies and cools, the differential contraction between the weld metal and the base metal creates residual stresses, which are accommodated by dislocation generation and movement.
HAZ Subzone Classification
The classification of the HAZ into three subzones based on peak temperature is consistent with the standard understanding of HAZ microstructural evolution in α+β titanium alloys:
| HAZ Subzone | Peak Temperature Range | Microstructure | Mechanical Implications |
|---|---|---|---|
| Transition zone | Just above β transus | Equiaxed α, rod-shaped α, residual β | Slight property degradation |
| Fine-grained zone | Well above β transus | Rod-shaped α, residual β | Fine grain size, good balance of strength and ductility |
| Coarse-grained zone | Far above β transus | Acicular α, residual β | Coarse grains, reduced ductility, potential embrittlement |
The acicular α in the coarse-grained zone is a concern for mechanical properties. Acicular α, also known as Widmanstätten α, forms during rapid cooling from the β phase field. It has a needle-like morphology that can act as a stress concentrator and reduce fracture toughness.
Engineering Practice and Delivery Considerations
Application in Naval Shipbuilding
Titanium alloys are increasingly used in naval shipbuilding for applications requiring high strength-to-weight ratio, excellent corrosion resistance, and good fatigue performance. Ti6321 is a medium-strength titanium alloy used for ship structures, pressure hulls, and seawater piping systems.
The TIG welding process is the primary joining method for titanium alloys in shipbuilding due to its ability to produce high-quality welds with proper shielding. However, titanium is highly reactive at elevated temperatures, and contamination by oxygen, nitrogen, or hydrogen can severely degrade weld quality.
Welding Procedure Qualification for Titanium
For shipbuilding applications, the welding procedure qualification must address:
- Shielding gas purity: Titanium welding requires high-purity argon (99.999% minimum) for both primary and trailing shielding. The trailing shield is essential to protect the cooling weld metal and HAZ from atmospheric contamination.
- Joint cleanliness: Titanium surfaces must be thoroughly cleaned before welding. Any contamination from oil, grease, or oxide films can lead to porosity or lack of fusion.
- Heat input control: The heat input must be carefully controlled to achieve the desired HAZ microstructure. Excessive heat input leads to coarse-grained HAZ with acicular α, while insufficient heat input may cause lack of fusion.
- Interpass temperature: For multi-pass welds, the interpass temperature must be controlled to prevent excessive grain growth in the HAZ.
Quality Control and Non-Destructive Testing
For ship titanium alloy welded joints, the following quality control measures are critical:
- Visual inspection: The weld surface should be silver or light straw coloured, indicating adequate shielding. Blue or grey discoloration indicates oxidation and requires investigation.
- Radiographic testing: For detecting internal defects such as porosity, lack of fusion, and inclusions.
- Ultrasonic testing: For detecting subsurface defects and assessing joint quality.
- Mechanical testing: Tensile, bend, and impact tests on representative coupons to verify joint properties.
- Microstructural examination: Metallographic examination to verify the HAZ microstructure and ensure no unacceptable acicular α or grain coarsening.
Reflections and Lessons Learned
This paper provides valuable insight into the microstructural evolution of titanium alloy welded joints, which is directly relevant to the quality control of ship structures. The classification of HAZ subzones and the identification of acicular α in the coarse-grained zone are particularly important for understanding the mechanical properties of welded joints.
However, I would offer several practical observations from my experience with titanium welding:
- The colour of the weld is the first indicator of quality. In titanium welding, the weld surface colour is a reliable indicator of shielding effectiveness. Silver indicates excellent shielding, light straw indicates acceptable, blue indicates marginal, and grey or white indicates severe oxidation. Any weld showing blue or grey discoloration should be rejected or repaired.
- The HAZ is often the weakest link. The coarse-grained zone with acicular α is susceptible to reduced ductility and fracture toughness. This is particularly important for pressure hull applications where the joint is subjected to high stresses.
- Post-weld heat treatment considerations. For thick sections or highly restrained joints, stress relief may be necessary. However, PWHT temperature and time must be carefully controlled to avoid excessive α coarsening or β phase transformation.
- The transition from columnar to equiaxed grains in the weld metal has practical implications. The columnar grains near the fusion boundary are more susceptible to hot cracking, while the equiaxed grains in the centre provide better mechanical properties. The weld metal microstructure can be controlled by adjusting welding parameters, particularly the heat input and travel speed.
- Non-destructive testing of titanium welds requires special attention. Due to the high acoustic impedance of titanium, ultrasonic testing requires careful calibration and the use of appropriate transducers. Radiographic testing is effective for detecting volumetric defects but may miss planar defects such as lack of fusion.
In conclusion, this study provides a comprehensive microstructural characterisation of TIG welded Ti6321 titanium alloy, which is essential for understanding the mechanical properties and ensuring the quality of ship structures. The classification of HAZ subzones and the identification of microstructural features that influence properties are directly applicable to welding procedure qualification and quality control in naval shipbuilding. The key lesson is that the microstructure of titanium alloy welded joints is highly sensitive to welding thermal cycles, and process parameters must be carefully controlled to achieve the desired properties.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd