Microstructure Comparison of AZ71 and AZ71E Magnesium Alloy TIG Welds
Overview of the Study
This paper from Chongqing University compares the weld zone microstructure of two magnesium alloys, AZ71 and AZ71E, after TIG welding without filler metal. The key difference between the alloys is the addition of a cerium-rich mischmetal to AZ71E. The authors observe that the AZ71E weld zone exhibits cellular dendritic grains, but the grain structure is not refined. They attribute this to the reaction between rare earth elements and aluminium, which forms a new phase, Al11RE3, consuming aluminium that would otherwise refine the alpha-magnesium grains. The result is coarser grains in the AZ71E weld than expected.
Technical Interpretation
Magnesium alloys are notoriously difficult to weld because of their low melting point, high thermal conductivity, and tendency to form oxide inclusions. The addition of rare earth elements to AZ71E is intended to improve high-temperature strength and creep resistance, but the study shows that it also affects weldability. The formation of Al11RE3 removes aluminium from solid solution, reducing the constitutional supercooling that normally drives grain refinement in magnesium welds. The result is a coarser, cellular dendritic structure that may have inferior mechanical properties compared to the base alloy.
| Parameter | AZ71 | AZ71E |
|---|---|---|
| Alloy composition | Mg-Al-Zn | Mg-Al-Zn + Ce-rich mischmetal |
| Weld zone structure | Fine dendritic | Cellular dendritic, coarser |
| Grain refinement mechanism | Al-based constitutional supercooling | Weakened by Al11RE3 formation |
| Rare earth phase | None | Al11RE3 |
| Expected weld strength | Baseline | Potentially reduced |
Engineering Practice Implications
For the pipe and fitting industry, magnesium alloys are primarily relevant to lightweight structural applications, such as aerospace components and portable equipment housings. The study's finding that rare earth additions can degrade weldability is a cautionary tale for alloy designers. When you add elements to improve base metal properties, you must also consider their effect on weldability. In this case, the cerium-rich mischmetal reacts preferentially with aluminium, depleting the grain refiner and coarsening the weld structure. This is a classic example of an unintended consequence in alloy design.
Lessons and Reflections
The practical lesson here is that you cannot assume that a good casting alloy will also be a good welding alloy. The metallurgical reactions that occur during solidification of a casting are different from those that occur during rapid solidification of a weld pool. In my experience, this is a common mistake in the industry. Engineers specify a material based on its mechanical properties and corrosion resistance, but they do not always consider how the welding process will alter the microstructure. The result is a weld that meets the tensile strength requirement but fails in fatigue or impact testing because the grain structure is coarse and brittle.
Summary
This study highlights the complex interplay between alloy composition and weldability in magnesium alloys. The addition of cerium-rich mischmetal to AZ71E, intended to improve high-temperature properties, actually coarsens the weld grain structure because the rare earth elements react with aluminium to form Al11RE3, depleting the grain refiner. For engineers, the lesson is clear: alloy design must consider the full processing route, including welding. A material that performs well in the cast condition may not perform well when welded, and the microstructure of the weld zone is the key to understanding the difference. This principle applies not only to magnesium alloys but to any alloy system where grain refinement depends on constitutional supercooling.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd