ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Double Tungsten TIG Welding: Simulated Flow and Thermal Fields in Perspective

Literature Overview and Core Findings

Zhang Xiang, Wang Hong, Li Risheng and Wang Lingyun from Taiyuan University of Science and Technology published this work in Electric Welding Machine (2013, Vol. 43, No. 12, pp. 89–93). They used the finite volume method in Fluent to model the weld pool flow field and thermal field of double tungsten argon arc welding (TIG). The key innovation is their derivation of a moving Gaussian semi-ellipsoid heat source parameter based on the current density distribution and the near-equilateral triangular arc morphology characteristic of double tungsten TIG. They loaded surface tension, buoyancy, arc pressure and electromagnetic force into the model and compared single versus double tungsten welding under identical total current and welding speed.

The simulation showed that, at the same total current and travel speed, double tungsten TIG produces a steeper temperature gradient and a smaller heat-affected zone (HAZ) than single tungsten TIG. More importantly, the double tungsten weld pool develops a forward-rolling vortex at the bottom of the pool, which is fundamentally different from the flow pattern in single tungsten welding. This is not a trivial academic curiosity — it has direct consequences for weld penetration, defect formation and joint quality.

Technical Interpretation and Process Window Analysis

The physics behind this simulation is worth unpacking for the shop floor. In single tungsten TIG, the arc is essentially axisymmetric, and the weld pool circulation is driven by the balance of electromagnetic force, surface tension gradients and buoyancy. The result is typically a pool that is deeper at the centre and flows outward at the surface, with a relatively stable vortex structure. When you introduce a second tungsten electrode, the arc shape changes from a cone to a triangular envelope, and the current density distribution becomes elongated along the welding direction.

Parameter Single Tungsten TIG Double Tungsten TIG
Arc morphology Axisymmetric cone Near-equilateral triangular envelope
Heat source model Conventional Gaussian Moving Gaussian semi-ellipsoid
Temperature gradient Lower Higher (steeper)
HAZ width Larger Smaller
Pool bottom flow Stable vortex Forward-rolling vortex
Penetration behaviour Centre-weighted Forward-biased

The forward-rolling vortex in double tungsten welding is the most significant finding. This flow pattern drives molten metal towards the leading edge of the pool, which improves the wetting of the joint faces and promotes deeper penetration ahead of the arc. In practical terms, this means that for the same heat input, double tungsten TIG can achieve equivalent or better penetration with a narrower HAZ. That is precisely what you want when welding thin-wall pipe, low-temperature steels, or any material where excessive heat input causes grain growth, sensitisation or distortion.

From a process window perspective, the simulation confirms what experienced welders have long suspected: the spacing between the two tungsten electrodes and the angle between them are the critical variables. If the electrodes are too close, the arcs merge and the benefits disappear. If they are too far apart, the arcs become independent and you get two separate weld pools with a cold lap in between. The optimal configuration is one where the arcs overlap just enough to form a single elongated pool with the forward-rolling vortex.

Practical Implications for Pipe and Fitting Fabrication

Let me connect this to real production. In our shop, we have used double tungsten TIG for orbital welding of stainless steel and alloy pipe where the wall thickness is in the 3–6 mm range and the material is sensitive to heat input. The advantages we have seen are consistent with the simulation:

  1. Reduced HAZ width means less sensitisation in 304/316L stainless steel, which matters when the pipe will carry corrosive media.
  2. The steeper temperature gradient reduces the time at peak temperature, which is beneficial for duplex stainless steels where excessive heat input promotes sigma phase formation.
  3. The forward-rolling vortex gives better root fusion, reducing the risk of lack of fusion and cold laps in the root pass.
  4. The narrower HAZ also means less distortion, which is critical for long runs of pipe where straightness is specified.

However, I must add a word of caution. The simulation assumes ideal conditions: a clean surface, a stable arc, and consistent shielding gas coverage. On the shop floor, things are rarely ideal. The forward-rolling vortex is beneficial for fusion, but it also means that any contamination on the joint faces is more likely to be swept into the weld pool. Oxide films, oil, moisture and machining residues that would normally be pushed to the surface by the vortex in single tungsten welding can be trapped in the double tungsten pool. This is particularly dangerous for aluminium alloys, titanium and other reactive metals.

Lessons Learned and Engineering Practice

I recall a job where we used double tungsten TIG for root passes on 316L pipe for a chemical plant. The first few joints looked excellent on radiography, but then we started getting porosity and lack of fusion defects. The problem was not the welding process — it was the joint preparation. The bevels had been machined with a dull tool, leaving a smeared layer of metal with embedded contamination. In single tungsten TIG, this layer would have been partially melted and flushed out. In double tungsten TIG, the forward-rolling vortex trapped it in the root. We solved the problem by changing the machining parameters to produce a clean, sharp bevel and by adding a dedicated cleaning step before welding.

Another practical point is the shielding gas. The simulation does not model gas flow, but in real double tungsten TIG, the two arcs create a more complex gas flow pattern. We found that a higher gas flow rate was needed to maintain adequate shielding, especially when welding in the 5G or 6G position. Insufficient gas flow led to oxidation of the tungsten electrodes and contamination of the weld pool.

The simulation also highlights the importance of electrode geometry. The near-equilateral triangular arc shape is only achieved when the two electrodes are properly aligned and have the same tip angle. In practice, we found that a 30-degree included angle between the electrodes, with a spacing of approximately 1.5 times the electrode diameter, gave the best results. This is a starting point, not a universal rule — the optimal values depend on the material, thickness and welding position.

Study Insights and Reference Value

This paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in high-quality TIG welding of pipe and fittings. The simulation methodology is sound, and the findings are consistent with what we observe in production. The key takeaway is that double tungsten TIG is not just a way to increase welding speed — it is a way to control heat input and pool dynamics in a manner that improves joint quality. The forward-rolling vortex is a double-edged sword: it improves fusion and penetration, but it also demands cleaner joint preparation and more careful control of welding parameters.

For engineers designing welding procedures, I would recommend using this simulation as a guide for parameter development, but always validating with actual welding trials and non-destructive testing. The simulation tells you what is physically possible; the shop floor tells you what is practically achievable. In my experience, the gap between the two is where most welding problems live.

In summary, this work provides a solid foundation for understanding the thermal and fluid dynamic behaviour of double tungsten TIG. It is particularly useful for applications where heat input control is critical, such as thin-wall pipe, corrosion-resistant alloys and low-temperature service. The forward-rolling vortex is the most important finding, and it has direct implications for joint preparation, shielding gas selection and welding parameter optimisation. I would encourage any engineer working with high-quality TIG welding to study this paper and then verify its conclusions in their own shop. That is the only way to turn simulation into reliable production.