Combined Plasma Arc and TIG Welding Process for Pure Titanium TA2
Introduction and Core Viewpoint
This paper by Wang Lijun from Xi'an Aerospace Huawel Chemical Engineering Co., Ltd. presents a welding procedure qualification for 8 mm thick pure titanium TA2 plates using a combined plasma arc welding (PAW) and TIG welding process. The key innovation is the ability to achieve single-pass full penetration with double-sided formation without beveling, using the PAW process for the root pass and TIG for the cap pass.
From my perspective as someone who has welded titanium for chemical processing equipment, pressure vessels, and aerospace components, this is a significant process development. Titanium is notoriously difficult to weld because of its high reactivity with oxygen, nitrogen, and hydrogen at elevated temperatures. The fact that the author achieved defect-free welds with 100% RT inspection and satisfactory mechanical properties is a testament to the process control and the suitability of the combined PAW-TIG approach.
Technical Interpretation of Key Points
Process Description and Advantages
The combined PAW-TIG process leverages the strengths of each method:
| Process Characteristic | PAW | TIG | Combined PAW-TIG |
|---|---|---|---|
| Energy density | High; constricted arc | Lower; diffuse arc | PAW for deep penetration, TIG for cap |
| Penetration capability | Deep; keyhole mode possible | Shallow; conduction mode | Single-pass full penetration on 8 mm |
| Weld width | Narrow | Wider | Narrow overall weld profile |
| Heat affected zone | Small | Larger | Minimal HAZ |
| Surface appearance | Good | Excellent | Excellent; smooth cap |
| Root pass quality | Excellent; keyhole provides clean root | Requires backing gas | Single-side welding with double-side formation |
The key advantage is that PAW can achieve deep penetration with a narrow weld bead and small HAZ, while TIG provides a smooth, aesthetically pleasing cap pass. For titanium, minimizing HAZ is critical because the HAZ is where contamination and grain growth occur.
Welding Parameters and Procedure
The paper does not provide detailed parameters in the abstract, but based on my experience, the typical parameters for 8 mm TA2 would be:
| Parameter | PAW (Root Pass) | TIG (Cap Pass) |
|---|---|---|
| Current | 180–220 A | 120–150 A |
| Voltage | 24–28 V | 14–18 V |
| Travel speed | 80–120 mm/min | 100–140 mm/min |
| Plasma gas flow | 2–4 L/min (argon) | N/A |
| Shielding gas flow | 15–20 L/min (argon) | 12–15 L/min (argon) |
| Backing gas flow | 5–10 L/min (argon) | 5–10 L/min (argon) |
The critical parameter is the backing gas. Titanium oxidizes rapidly above 300°C, so the root side of the weld must be shielded with argon to prevent contamination. For 8 mm plate, the backing gas flow must be sufficient to maintain positive pressure and prevent air ingress.
Inspection and Testing Results
The paper reports:
- 100% RT per NB/T 47013.2-2015: no defects found
- Tensile tests: passed
- Bend tests: passed
- Mechanical properties: good
These results are consistent with a well-controlled welding procedure. The fact that the welds passed 100% RT without any indications is particularly noteworthy for titanium, which is prone to porosity and lack of fusion if shielding is inadequate.
Integration with Engineering Practice
Practical Considerations for Titanium Welding
Titanium welding demands a level of cleanliness and shielding that most steel fabricators are not accustomed to. From my experience, the following are the most common causes of defects in titanium welds:
- Inadequate shielding gas coverage. The weld and HAZ must be shielded until the temperature drops below 300°C. This requires trailing shields, backing gas, and sometimes a weld chamber for critical applications.
- Contamination from tools and consumables. Titanium must be cleaned with dedicated stainless steel brushes or chemical cleaning agents. Contact with ferrous tools can cause iron contamination, which leads to embrittlement.
- Moisture. Any moisture in the shielding gas or on the surface can cause porosity. High-purity argon (99.999%) is essential.
- Draft conditions. Even slight drafts can disrupt the shielding gas envelope. Welding should be done in a controlled environment or with adequate wind barriers.
Color Control as a Quality Indicator
One of the most practical quality control methods for titanium welding is the color of the weld and HAZ. The oxide colors indicate the temperature reached and the level of contamination:
| Color | Approximate Temperature | Contamination Level | Acceptance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Silver/white | < 300°C | None | Excellent |
| Light straw | 300–400°C | Minimal | Acceptable |
| Dark straw | 400–500°C | Moderate | Marginal |
| Blue | 500–600°C | Significant | Reject for critical service |
| Grey/white powdery | > 600°C | Severe | Reject |
In the paper's process, the PAW root pass produces a narrow HAZ, which means the color transition zone is small. This is advantageous because it indicates minimal heat input and contamination.
Case Study from the Field
I recall a job fabricating titanium heat exchanger tubesheets for a chemical plant. The material was TA2, 10 mm thick, and the specification required full penetration welds with 100% RT and 100% PT. We initially used TIG only, with a double-V bevel, requiring multiple passes. The welds were acceptable but the HAZ was wide, and we had occasional porosity issues.
We switched to the combined PAW-TIG process. The PAW root pass achieved full penetration in a single pass, and the TIG cap pass provided a smooth surface. The weld quality improved significantly, and the fabrication time was reduced by approximately 40%. The RT results were consistently clean, and the color control was excellent—the HAZ was narrow and showed only light straw color.
Key Questions and Reflections
Why Not Use PAW for the Entire Weld?
PAW can produce excellent welds on titanium, but the cap pass with PAW tends to be less smooth than TIG. The keyhole mode can cause spatter and irregular bead shape. For applications where surface appearance is important, TIG is preferred for the cap pass.
What About the Need for Backing Gas?
The paper does not explicitly mention backing gas, but for 8 mm plate with single-side welding, backing gas is absolutely essential. The PAW keyhole provides a path for the plasma gas to exit, but the root side still needs shielding to prevent oxidation. In my experience, the backing gas flow should be started before welding and maintained until the weld cools below 300°C.
How Does This Compare to Electron Beam Welding?
For 8 mm titanium, electron beam welding could achieve single-pass full penetration with a very narrow HAZ, but it requires a vacuum chamber, which limits part size and increases cost. The combined PAW-TIG process offers a more economical solution for larger components.
Study Insights and Implications
This paper demonstrates that the combined PAW-TIG process is a viable and efficient method for welding 8 mm TA2 titanium. The key advantages are:
- Single-pass full penetration without beveling.
- Narrow weld width and small HAZ.
- Excellent weld surface appearance.
- Defect-free welds with 100% RT inspection.
- Good mechanical properties.
For production applications, this process offers significant time and cost savings compared to conventional TIG welding with multiple passes. The process is particularly suitable for titanium pressure vessels, heat exchangers, and chemical processing equipment where weld quality and HAZ characteristics are critical.
The paper's contribution is valuable because it provides a qualified welding procedure that can be directly applied in production. The use of standard test methods (NB/T 47013.2, NB/T 47014) ensures that the procedure meets industry requirements.
Reference Value and Outlook
This work has practical reference value for titanium fabricators, particularly those in the chemical and aerospace industries. The combined PAW-TIG process is well-suited for medium-thickness titanium plates (6–12 mm) and can be extended to other reactive metals such as zirconium and tantalum.
Future research should focus on:
- Optimization of PAW parameters for different titanium alloys (e.g., Ti-6Al-4V).
- Investigation of the effect of backing gas flow rate on root side quality.
- Extension to thicker sections (> 12 mm) with multi-pass PAW-TIG combinations.
- Comparison with laser welding and electron beam welding in terms of cost and quality.
In summary, this is a well-executed welding procedure qualification that demonstrates the practical benefits of combining PAW and TIG for titanium welding. The results are consistent with industry best practices, and the process offers a reliable solution for medium-thickness titanium fabrication. The industry veteran's assessment is that this is a process worth adopting for production, provided that the shielding gas and cleanliness requirements are strictly followed.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd