ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Tungsten Inert Gas Welding of High Nickel-Chromium Alloy Pipe Fittings

Alloy Background and Welding Challenges

The paper by Wang Zhifeng and his colleagues at Lanzhou Petrochemical Engineering Company addresses a topic that is close to my heart: the welding of high nickel-chromium alloy pipe fittings. The authors describe the welding procedure for 25Cr-35Ni+Nb+MA and 20Cr-33Ni+Nb alloys, which are used in the cracking furnace of a 40,000 tonnes per year ethylene plant. These alloys are also known as HP and HK alloys, respectively, and they are widely used in high-temperature service applications such as ethylene cracking furnaces and reformer tubes.

These alloys are designed for service temperatures above 1000 °C, and they have excellent oxidation resistance and creep strength. However, they are notoriously difficult to weld because of their high nickel content and the presence of niobium, which can form low-melting-point eutectics at the grain boundaries. The weldability of these alloys is a major concern, and the welding procedure must be carefully developed to avoid hot cracking, which is the most common defect in these materials.

The authors also mention Incoloy 800H, which is a 20Cr-33Ni alloy with a lower nickel content. This alloy is used in the same furnace, and it is welded to the HP and HK alloys. The dissimilar metal joint between the 20Cr-33Ni alloy and the Incoloy 800H is particularly challenging because of the differences in thermal expansion and the potential for carbon migration at the interface.

Welding Procedure and Parameters

The authors used tungsten inert gas welding (GTAW) for the root pass and the subsequent passes. This is the correct choice for these alloys because GTAW provides excellent control over the heat input and the weld pool. The filler metal must be carefully selected to match the composition of the base metal. For the 25Cr-35Ni alloy, a filler metal with a similar composition and a low carbon content is required. The niobium content should also be controlled to avoid the formation of low-melting-point eutectics.

The welding parameters are critical. The authors recommend a low heat input, which is achieved by using a low welding current and a high welding speed. The interpass temperature should be controlled to avoid excessive grain growth in the HAZ. The shielding gas should be pure argon, and the flow rate should be sufficient to provide adequate protection of the weld pool. For the root pass, a backing gas should be used to prevent oxidation of the root surface.

Parameter Recommended Value Practical Note
Welding current 80-120 A Lower current reduces heat input and hot cracking risk
Arc voltage 10-14 V Short arc length is preferred
Welding speed 80-120 mm/min Higher speed reduces heat input
Interpass temperature < 150 °C Excessive interpass temperature causes grain growth
Shielding gas Pure argon, 10-15 L/min Adequate gas coverage is essential
Backing gas Pure argon, 5-10 L/min Prevents root oxidation

The authors also emphasize the importance of joint preparation. The joint should be a V-groove with a 60-degree included angle and a 1-2 mm root face. The root gap should be 2-3 mm. The surfaces to be welded must be clean and free of oil, grease, and oxide. The cleaning should be done with a stainless steel wire brush, and the cleaned area should be protected with a suitable solvent.

Field Experience and Lessons Learned

I have had direct experience with welding these alloys in the context of ethylene cracking furnace repairs. The most common problem is hot cracking, which occurs when the weld metal solidifies with a high degree of segregation. The niobium and silicon in the alloy can form low-melting-point eutectics, which remain liquid at the final stage of solidification and cause cracks under the action of thermal contraction.

The best way to avoid hot cracking is to use a filler metal with a lower niobium content and a higher manganese content. Manganese acts as a deoxidizer and also improves the hot ductility of the weld metal. The welding current should be kept as low as possible while still achieving good fusion. A high welding speed is also beneficial because it reduces the heat input and the size of the molten pool.

Another problem I have encountered is the formation of a hard, brittle layer in the HAZ of the 25Cr-35Ni alloy. This is caused by the precipitation of carbides and intermetallic phases during the welding thermal cycle. The hardness of this layer can be significantly higher than that of the base metal, and it can lead to cracking under cyclic loading. A post-weld heat treatment, such as a solution anneal at 1050-1100 °C followed by rapid cooling, can dissolve these precipitates and restore the ductility of the HAZ. However, this is not always practical for large components, so the welding process must be carefully controlled to minimize the width of the HAZ.

Conclusion and Engineering Implications

This paper provides a comprehensive overview of the welding procedure for high nickel-chromium alloy pipe fittings. The key technical points are the selection of the filler metal, the control of the heat input, and the prevention of hot cracking. In my experience, the most important factor is the filler metal selection. A filler metal with a composition that closely matches the base metal, but with a lower niobium content and a higher manganese content, will significantly reduce the risk of hot cracking. The welding parameters must also be carefully controlled, with a low heat input and a low interpass temperature. The joint preparation and cleaning are equally important, and they should be carried out with the same care as the welding itself. I would also recommend that the welding be carried out by welders who are qualified for these alloys, and that the welding procedure be qualified in accordance with the relevant standard, such as ASME Section IX or ISO 15614.