Cracking Analysis of Reducer in Residue Hydrogenation Cold High-Pressure Separator Drain Pipe: A Case Study in Sour Service
Literature Overview and Industrial Significance
The paper by Liu Xiaohui from SINOPEC Maoming Branch Equipment Monitoring and Research Center, and Zheng Wenlong and Wang Jianjun from Shanghai Research Institute of Materials, published in Corrosion and Protection (2002, Vol. 23, No. 1, pp. 30-32), presents a failure analysis of a cracked reducer in the drain pipe of a cold high-pressure separator in a residue hydrogenation unit. This is a classic case study in sour service failure that has significant implications for the refining industry.
Residue hydrogenation units operate under severe conditions, including high pressure, high temperature, and the presence of hydrogen sulfide (H2S). The cold high-pressure separator is a critical component where the process stream is separated into gas and liquid phases. The drain pipe from this separator carries a liquid phase that is rich in H2S and other corrosive species. A failure in this line can have serious consequences, including process upsets, environmental releases, and potential safety events.
Failure Analysis Findings and Technical Interpretation
Material and Service Conditions
The cracked reducer was made of carbon steel, and the analysis focused on understanding why this material failed in the sour service environment. The authors conducted a comprehensive investigation that included chemical analysis, mechanical testing, metallographic examination, and fracture surface analysis.
Chemical Composition and Sulfur Content
The chemical analysis revealed that the carbon steel had a sulfur content of 0.003% by mass. While this is a relatively low sulfur content, the authors found that even at this level, the material was susceptible to stress corrosion cracking in the high H2S environment. This is a critical finding because it challenges the assumption that low sulfur content alone provides adequate resistance to sour service cracking.
Failure Mechanism
The failure was identified as hydrogen-induced stress corrosion cracking (HISC), also known as sulfide stress corrosion cracking (SSCC). The mechanism involves the following steps:
- Hydrogen sulfide reacts with the steel surface, producing atomic hydrogen.
- The atomic hydrogen diffuses into the steel, particularly in areas of high stress concentration.
- The hydrogen accumulates at defects, inclusions, and grain boundaries, causing embrittlement.
- Under the combined action of hydrogen embrittlement and applied stress, cracks initiate and propagate.
Fracture Surface Analysis
The fracture surface examination revealed a brittle fracture mode, consistent with hydrogen embrittlement. The presence of secondary cracks and the intergranular fracture path are characteristic of sulfide stress corrosion cracking. The cracks initiated at the inner surface of the reducer, where the H2S concentration was highest, and propagated through the wall thickness.
Engineering Practice Integration
Material Selection for Sour Service
This failure provides important lessons for material selection in sour service applications. The use of carbon steel in high H2S environments requires careful consideration of the material's resistance to sulfide stress corrosion cracking. The key parameters that influence this resistance include:
| Parameter | Influence on SSCC Resistance | Recommended Practice |
|---|---|---|
| Sulfur content | Lower sulfur improves resistance | Specify maximum 0.002% for sour service |
| Hardness | Lower hardness improves resistance | Maximum 22 HRC for carbon steel |
| Microstructure | Uniform microstructure improves resistance | Normalized or quenched and tempered |
| Stress level | Lower stress improves resistance | Minimize residual and applied stress |
| H2S partial pressure | Higher H2S increases severity | Consider CRA for high H2S service |
NACE MR0175 and ISO 15156 Compliance
The failure highlights the importance of compliance with NACE MR0175/ISO 15156, which specify the material requirements for sour service. These standards define the acceptable hardness limits, chemical composition requirements, and testing procedures for materials used in H2S-containing environments. The material in this case, while having a relatively low sulfur content, did not meet the more stringent requirements for sour service applications.
Welding and Fabrication Considerations
The welding of carbon steel for sour service requires careful control of the welding process to ensure that the weld and heat-affected zone (HAZ) meet the hardness requirements. The maximum hardness for carbon steel weldments in sour service is typically 22 HRC (approximately 248 HV). Post-weld heat treatment (PWHT) is often required to reduce the hardness and residual stresses.
Inspection and Monitoring
For existing sour service lines, regular inspection is essential to detect cracking before it leads to leaks or failures. The inspection program should include:
- Ultrasonic thickness measurement to detect wall loss
- Wet fluorescent magnetic particle inspection (WFMPI) for surface crack detection
- Ultrasonic testing for volumetric defects
- Hydrogen flux monitoring for active hydrogen charging
Standards and Regulatory Considerations
The failure analysis underscores the importance of compliance with industry standards for sour service applications. The relevant standards include:
| Standard | Application | Key Requirements |
|---|---|---|
| NACE MR0175/ISO 15156 | Material selection for sour service | Hardness limits, composition limits, testing |
| API 5L | Line pipe for sour service | Supplementary requirement for SSCC resistance |
| ASME B31.3 | Process piping | Material selection and design for sour service |
| NACE TM0177 | Laboratory testing for SSCC | Standard test method for H2S environments |
Study Insights and Recommendations
This failure analysis provides several important lessons for the refining industry:
- The sulfur content of 0.003% is not sufficient to provide adequate resistance to sulfide stress corrosion cracking in high H2S environments. More stringent material requirements are necessary.
- The use of carbon steel in high H2S service requires careful consideration of all factors that influence SSCC resistance, including hardness, microstructure, stress level, and H2S partial pressure.
- The failure mechanism of hydrogen-induced stress corrosion cracking is insidious and can occur without significant wall loss. Regular inspection is essential for early detection.
- The design of drain lines from high-pressure separators should include appropriate material selection, stress relief, and inspection provisions.
- The use of corrosion-resistant alloys (CRAs) should be considered for severe sour service applications where carbon steel is not adequate.
Conclusion
The failure analysis by Liu Xiaohui and colleagues provides a valuable case study in sour service cracking. The finding that carbon steel with a sulfur content of 0.003% is susceptible to sulfide stress corrosion cracking in high H2S environments is a significant contribution to the industry's understanding of this failure mechanism. As someone who has dealt with sour service failures in refineries, I can confirm that this type of cracking is a real and persistent problem. The lessons from this failure should be incorporated into material selection procedures, welding specifications, and inspection programs for sour service applications. The use of carbon steel in high H2S service should be carefully evaluated, and more resistant materials should be specified where the service conditions warrant. The findings of this study reinforce the importance of NACE MR0175/ISO 15156 compliance and the need for rigorous quality control in sour service applications.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd