Retrofitting a NAXOS Reducer Grinder with SIEMENS 840D
1. The Retrofit Challenge and Its Context
The 2006 paper by Liu Changjie and Wang Yang from Tianrun Crankshaft Co., Ltd. describes the retrofit of a NAXOS reducer grinding machine with the SIEMENS 840D CNC system. This is a classic example of extending the life of an aging machine tool by upgrading its control system. The original machine was a dedicated grinder for grinding the big end and small end of a connecting rod reducer (the transition zone between the big end and the shaft). The old control system was obsolete, spare parts were difficult to obtain, and the machine was not producing consistent quality. The retrofit involved replacing the entire electrical control system with a modern CNC, while keeping the mechanical structure.
2. System Architecture and Integration
The retrofit is not just a simple control swap. It requires careful integration of the new control system with the existing mechanical components. The paper describes the following key elements:
| Component | Original System | Retrofitted System |
|---|---|---|
| CNC controller | Old dedicated CNC | SIEMENS 840D |
| Servo drives | Analog drives | Digital drives with Profibus |
| Spindle drive | Fixed speed | Variable speed with encoder feedback |
| Position feedback | Encoders | High-resolution encoders |
| PLC control | Relay logic | Integrated PLC in the 840D |
| Operator interface | Buttons and switches | CNC screen with soft keys |
| Grinding wheel | Form wheel | Form wheel (same) |
| Dressing system | Manual | Automatic with program control |
The key challenge is the integration of the form grinding wheel. The NAXOS machine uses a form wheel to grind the reducer profile in a single pass. This is a complex profile, and the wheel must be dressed accurately. The retrofit includes an automatic dressing system that is controlled by the CNC program. The dressing cycle is programmed to maintain the wheel profile and compensate for wheel wear.
3. Benefits and Results
The retrofit achieved significant improvements in product quality and process flexibility. The paper reports the following results:
| Metric | Before Retrofit | After Retrofit |
|---|---|---|
| Dimensional consistency | ±0.05 mm | ±0.01 mm |
| Surface finish | Ra 0.8 µm | Ra 0.4 µm |
| Cycle time | 90 seconds | 60 seconds |
| Changeover time | 2 hours | 30 minutes |
| Downtime | Frequent | Minimal |
| Spare parts availability | Difficult | Readily available |
The most significant benefit is the improvement in dimensional consistency. The old control system had poor repeatability, which meant that the grinding wheel had to be dressed frequently and the parts had to be inspected after each cycle. The new system has better repeatability, so the wheel life is longer and the process is more stable.
Another important benefit is the flexibility. The old machine was dedicated to one part profile. The new system can store multiple programs, so the machine can be changed over to a different part profile in a relatively short time. This is valuable for a company that produces multiple types of connecting rods.
4. Lessons Learned from the Retrofit
I have been involved in several machine tool retrofits, and I can offer some practical advice based on my experience.
4.1 Mechanical Condition Assessment
Before you retrofit the control system, you must assess the mechanical condition of the machine. If the spindle has excessive runout or the guideways are worn, a new control system will not fix the problem. The retrofit will only be as good as the mechanical foundation. In this case, the NAXOS machine had a solid mechanical structure, so the retrofit was justified.
4.2 Electrical Design and Safety
The electrical design must comply with current safety standards. The old system may have had outdated safety circuits, and the retrofit must include modern safety relays and emergency stop circuits. This is often overlooked, but it is critical for operator safety.
4.3 Commissioning and Training
The commissioning phase is critical. You need to have a plan for testing the machine, verifying the programs, and training the operators. The paper mentions that the retrofit was successful, but I would emphasize that the training is often the weakest link. Operators who are used to the old system may struggle with the new CNC interface. You should allocate sufficient time for training and allow the operators to practice before full production.
4.4 Documentation and Spare Parts
One of the main reasons for the retrofit was the difficulty in obtaining spare parts for the old system. The new system should have readily available spare parts, but you still need to maintain a stock of critical components. The documentation should be complete and stored in a location that is accessible to the maintenance team.
5. Conclusion and Recommendations
This paper is a valuable case study for anyone considering a machine tool retrofit. The SIEMENS 840D system is a proven, reliable CNC platform, and the retrofit of the NAXOS grinder demonstrates how it can be integrated with an existing mechanical structure to improve quality, flexibility, and maintainability. My advice to engineers is to approach a retrofit systematically: assess the mechanical condition, design the electrical system carefully, plan the commissioning and training, and ensure that documentation and spare parts are in place. The retrofit is a significant investment, but it is often more economical than buying a new machine, especially when the mechanical structure is still sound. The key is to do the job right the first time, and this paper shows how.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd