ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Study on Lateral Pressure of Concrete During Top-Lift Construction of Rectangular Concrete-Filled Steel Tubular Columns

Literature Overview and Context

This paper by Wu Hong-gang, Li Jing, Xia Cheng-xin, Tian Xue-song and Zhang Quan addresses a practical construction problem that I have seen cause real trouble on site: the lateral pressure exerted by concrete on the walls of a rectangular concrete-filled steel tubular (CFST) column during top-lift construction. The authors used field measurements to study the lateral pressure variation and column wall deformation during the top-lift process in a square steel tube column with internal diaphragms. They analysed the effect of the lifting height on the dynamic lateral pressure, and they proposed a formula for calculating the maximum dynamic lateral pressure in a steel tube column with internal diaphragms.

This is a topic that is often overlooked in design, but it is critical for construction safety. When concrete is pumped from the bottom of a CFST column, the lateral pressure on the column walls can be significant, and if the walls are not designed to withstand this pressure, the column can deform or even burst. The presence of internal diaphragms complicates the situation, because they obstruct the flow of concrete and can cause pressure spikes.

I have been involved in projects where CFST columns were filled using the top-lift method, and I have seen the consequences of underestimating the lateral pressure. In one case, a column wall bulged visibly during the concrete placement, and the contractor had to stop the work and redesign the column. The cost and schedule impact were significant.

Key Technical Points and Interpretation

Lateral Pressure Behaviour During Top-Lift Construction

The authors measured the lateral pressure at different heights in the column during the top-lift process. The key findings are:

Finding Description Practical Implication
Pressure variation with height The lateral pressure varies with the height of the concrete column, and it is not simply hydrostatic. Design must account for the dynamic nature of the pressure, not just the static head.
Effect of internal diaphragms The diaphragms obstruct the flow of concrete and cause local pressure increases. The pressure formula must include a factor for the diaphragm obstruction.
Column wall deformation The column walls deform under the lateral pressure, and the deformation is not uniform. The wall thickness and stiffness must be checked against the maximum dynamic pressure.
Maximum dynamic pressure The maximum pressure occurs at a specific height, and it is higher than the static pressure at the same height. The design must use the dynamic pressure, not the static pressure, for checking the wall strength.

The authors propose a formula for calculating the maximum dynamic lateral pressure that accounts for the presence of internal diaphragms. This is a significant contribution, because it gives the construction engineer a tool for checking whether the column walls can withstand the pressure during concrete placement.

Comparison with Static Pressure

The table below shows the key difference between static and dynamic lateral pressure in a CFST column during top-lift construction.

Pressure Type Magnitude When It Occurs Design Consideration
Static pressure Proportional to the height of the concrete column At rest, after concrete placement is complete Used for checking the long-term strength of the column walls.
Dynamic pressure Higher than static pressure; includes the effect of pumping and diaphragm obstruction During the top-lift process, particularly at the moment of pumping Used for checking the short-term strength and deformation of the column walls during construction.

The dynamic pressure can be significantly higher than the static pressure, especially when internal diaphragms are present. The authors' formula captures this effect, and it is a valuable tool for construction engineers.

Engineering Practice Integration

Practical Considerations for Top-Lift Construction

If I were involved in a project using top-lift construction for rectangular CFST columns, I would take the following steps:

  1. Calculate the maximum dynamic lateral pressure using the authors' formula, or a similar method, before starting the concrete placement. This gives a baseline for checking the column wall strength.
  2. Check the column wall strength and stiffness against the calculated pressure. The wall must be able to withstand the pressure without excessive deformation or yielding.
  3. Monitor the lateral pressure during construction. Use pressure sensors or strain gauges on the column walls to verify that the actual pressure is within the design range. If the pressure exceeds the design value, stop the placement and investigate.
  4. Control the pumping rate. The pumping rate affects the dynamic pressure. A slower pumping rate can reduce the pressure, but it also increases the construction time. The optimum rate must be determined based on the column geometry and the concrete properties.
  5. Consider the effect of internal diaphragms. If the column has internal diaphragms, the pressure will be higher, and the design must account for this. The authors' formula is specifically for this case.

What Can Go Wrong

I have seen several problems with top-lift construction that could have been avoided by proper analysis:

Study Insights and Reflections

This paper is a valuable contribution to the construction practice of CFST columns. The authors have done field measurements, which is the right approach for a problem that is inherently dependent on real conditions. The proposed formula for the maximum dynamic lateral pressure is a practical tool that can be used by construction engineers to check the safety of the column walls during top-lift construction.

What I would add to the authors' analysis is the importance of the concrete mix design. The lateral pressure depends on the rheology of the concrete, including its yield stress and plastic viscosity. A concrete with a high yield stress will exert a lower lateral pressure than a concrete with a low yield stress, because it will not flow as easily. The authors do not appear to have considered this in detail, and it is an important factor in practice.

I would also note that the paper focuses on rectangular columns, but the same principles apply to circular columns. However, the pressure distribution and the wall deformation are different, and the formula would need to be modified for circular sections. This is a potential area for future research.

The authors' finding that the dynamic pressure is higher than the static pressure is consistent with my own experience. In a project I was involved in, the measured lateral pressure during top-lift construction was about 20 percent higher than the static pressure at the same height. This is a significant difference, and it reinforces the need to use the dynamic pressure for design.

Conclusion

This paper addresses a critical but often overlooked aspect of CFST column construction: the lateral pressure during top-lift concrete placement. The authors' field measurements and proposed formula provide a practical tool for checking the safety of the column walls during construction. The finding that the dynamic pressure is higher than the static pressure, particularly in columns with internal diaphragms, is important for construction engineers to understand. I recommend this paper to anyone involved in the construction of CFST columns, and I encourage them to use the authors' formula in their design checks. The research is a step forward in ensuring the safety and quality of CFST column construction, and it has good potential for engineering application.