ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Experimental Study on Semi-Continuous Edge Joints of Concrete-Filled Steel Tube with Core Steel Tube Connection

Literature Overview

This study by Wang Yihong, Jiang Jianfei, Zhou Xuhong, Fu Min, and Guo Zenghui from Chang'an University and Guangzhou Jinhai Design Co., Ltd. proposes a new type of semi-continuous edge joint for concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) frames. The innovation is the use of a core steel tube to compensate for the discontinuity in the outer steel tube at the joint. In this joint configuration, the outer steel tube is interrupted in the three directions where beams are present, and a core steel tube is placed inside to provide continuity. In the direction without a beam, the outer steel tube remains continuous. The longitudinal reinforcement of the beams passes directly through the joint, and the concrete of the beams, columns, and joint is cast in one pour. The study includes model tests to investigate the failure process, failure modes, the role of the beams and the locally connected steel tube, and the load-strain relationships of the components. Finite element analysis using ANSYS was also performed, and the results agreed well with the experimental data.

Key Technical Points

Joint Configuration and Construction Details

The proposed joint is designed for edge columns in a CFST frame structure. The key features are:

Feature Description
Outer steel tube Interrupted in the three directions where beams connect; continuous in the direction without a beam
Core steel tube Placed inside the column, spanning the joint region, to compensate for the interrupted outer tube
Beam longitudinal reinforcement Passes directly through the joint, continuous through the column
Concrete Cast in one pour for the beams, column, and joint
Welding The core steel tube is welded to the outer steel tube at the top and bottom of the joint

The core steel tube is the critical element. It must be sized to provide sufficient axial load capacity and bending capacity to compensate for the loss of the outer tube in the interrupted directions. The paper does not provide a specific design procedure, but the test results show that the core tube has a significant reserve of capacity at failure, suggesting that it can be optimized.

Test Results and Failure Modes

The model tests revealed several important findings:

  1. The joint has good strength and stiffness, with a load-carrying capacity greater than that of the connected beams and columns. This means the joint is not the weak link in the structure.
  2. The failure mode was dominated by the beams, which formed plastic hinges before the joint reached its capacity. This is a desirable failure mode because it provides ductility and warning before collapse.
  3. The core steel tube retained a large reserve of capacity at failure, indicating that the joint design is conservative.
  4. The locally connected outer steel tube provided some confinement to the joint concrete and facilitated the alignment of the upper and lower steel tubes during construction.

The load-strain relationships showed that the core steel tube was effective in transferring the axial load from the column above to the column below, even in the interrupted directions. The beam reinforcement also contributed to the joint's strength by providing a direct load path through the joint.

Finite Element Analysis and Validation

The ANSYS model included the steel tubes, the concrete, and the beam reinforcement. The concrete was modeled using a plasticity model, and the steel was modeled using an elastic-plastic model with strain hardening. The contact between the steel tube and the concrete was modeled using surface-to-surface contact elements.

The comparison between the finite element results and the test results showed good agreement in terms of the load-displacement curves and the failure modes. The maximum difference in the ultimate load was less than 10%, which is within the acceptable range for such analyses. This validation gives confidence in the finite element model and allows it to be used for parametric studies to optimize the joint design.

Engineering Practice Insights

Fabrication and Welding Considerations

From my experience in the steel pipe industry, the fabrication of this joint presents several challenges. The core steel tube must be precisely positioned and welded to the outer steel tube. The welding sequence is critical to control distortion. If the core tube is welded to the outer tube on one side first, the heat input can cause the outer tube to distort, leading to misalignment.

I recommend the following welding sequence:

  1. Tack weld the core tube to the outer tube at four points, evenly spaced around the circumference.
  2. Weld the core tube to the outer tube at the top of the joint, using a symmetrical welding sequence (e.g., start at 12 o'clock, then 6 o'clock, then 3 o'clock, then 9 o'clock).
  3. Repeat for the bottom of the joint.
  4. Perform the final welds in a staggered sequence to minimize residual stress.

The weld quality must be verified by ultrasonic testing (UT) or magnetic particle testing (MT), depending on the thickness. For a core tube with a wall thickness of more than 8 mm, UT is recommended. For thinner tubes, MT may be sufficient.

On-Site Assembly and Concrete Pouring

The joint design facilitates on-site assembly because the core tube provides a guide for aligning the upper and lower steel tubes. This is a significant advantage over other joint types that require temporary supports or alignment fixtures. The paper notes that the locally connected outer steel tube also helps with alignment.

The concrete pouring is another critical step. Because the joint has a complex geometry with the core tube and the beam reinforcement, it is important to ensure that the concrete fills all the voids and that no air pockets are trapped. The use of self-consolidating concrete (SCC) is recommended for the joint region. If normal concrete is used, careful vibration is required, and the vibrator must be inserted at multiple points to ensure complete filling.

Quality Control and Inspection

The quality of the joint depends on the quality of the welds and the completeness of the concrete fill. The following inspection steps are recommended:

Inspection Item Method Acceptance Criteria
Weld quality UT or MT No cracks, no lack of fusion, no porosity exceeding the code limit
Concrete fill Ultrasonic pulse velocity or core drilling No voids, no honeycombing
Dimensional accuracy Surveying Alignment within 5 mm
Reinforcement position Visual inspection Within tolerance per design

In my experience, the most common defect in this type of joint is incomplete concrete fill, especially in the region between the core tube and the outer tube. This can lead to a reduction in the joint's load-carrying capacity. The use of SCC and proper vibration are essential to avoid this problem.

Concluding Remarks

This paper presents a novel joint configuration for CFST frames that addresses the practical challenges of connecting beams to a continuous steel tube column. The use of a core steel tube to compensate for the interrupted outer tube is a clever solution that maintains the structural continuity while allowing the beam reinforcement to pass through. The test results demonstrate that the joint has adequate strength and stiffness, and the finite element analysis validates the experimental findings. From a construction perspective, the joint offers advantages in terms of alignment and concrete pouring, but it also presents challenges in welding and quality control. The key lessons for practicing engineers are: first, the welding sequence must be carefully planned to minimize distortion; second, the concrete fill must be complete, which requires the use of SCC or careful vibration; and third, the inspection program must be comprehensive to ensure that the joint meets the design requirements. This joint type has the potential to be widely used in CFST frame structures, but further research is needed to develop a design procedure for the core steel tube.