ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Crack Formation Mechanisms in Centrifugal SHS Ceramic Composite Steel Pipes

Research Background and SHS Process Overview

This study from the Beijing General Research Institute for Nonferrous Metals, Baoshan Iron and Steel, and the University of Science and Technology Beijing addresses a manufacturing problem that has plagued the ceramic-lined steel pipe industry for decades: cracking of the ceramic lining during cooling. The ceramic lining is produced by self-propagating high-temperature synthesis (SHS), a process in which a reactive mixture is ignited and the combustion front propagates through the material, producing a ceramic layer that is bonded to the inner surface of the steel pipe. The process is fast and cost-effective, but the ceramic layer is prone to cracking because of the thermal expansion mismatch between the ceramic and the steel.

The authors use numerical simulation of the temperature field during cooling to analyze the stress distribution in the ceramic layer and the steel pipe. They calculate the temperature, dimensions, and stress in each layer as a function of time, and they identify the types of cracks that form at different temperature stages.

Numerical Simulation and Crack Mechanism Analysis

The simulation reveals a complex picture of stress development during cooling. At high temperatures, the ceramic is in a plastic state and can accommodate the thermal strains without cracking. As the temperature decreases, the ceramic becomes elastic and the thermal expansion mismatch between the ceramic and the steel generates stresses. The steel pipe contracts more than the ceramic, which puts the ceramic layer in compression. However, the stress distribution is not uniform — the edges and the interfaces between layers are stress concentrations.

The authors identify three types of cracks based on the mechanical cause:

Crack Type Mechanical Cause Formation Stage
Tensile cracks Tensile stress exceeds ceramic strength Early cooling, high temperature
Compressive cracks Compressive stress exceeds ceramic strength Intermediate cooling
Quasi-compressive cracks Combined compressive and shear stress Late cooling, low temperature

The authors also introduce the concept of a "quasi-compressive crack" to describe cracks that form under a combination of compressive and shear stress, which is a more complex failure mode than simple compression or tension. They consolidate all the findings into a "cooling hologram" — a comprehensive diagram that shows the crack formation mechanisms at different temperatures and times. This diagram is a valuable tool for understanding the cracking process and for developing control measures.

Manufacturing Implications and Control Measures

The two main causes of cracking are thermal stress and the compressive force exerted by the steel pipe on the ceramic layer. The thermal stress is driven by the temperature difference between the ceramic and the steel, which is in turn driven by the cooling rate. The compressive force is driven by the differential thermal contraction between the steel and the ceramic.

To reduce cracking, the authors recommend controlling both the cooling rate of the ceramic layer and the cooling rate of the steel pipe. The ceramic layer should be cooled slowly to reduce thermal stress, but the steel pipe should be cooled at a rate that matches the ceramic to minimize the differential contraction. This is a delicate balance — if the steel cools too fast, it contracts more than the ceramic and compresses it excessively; if the steel cools too slowly, the ceramic is left in tension.

Control Measure Effect on Cracking
Slow cooling of ceramic layer Reduces thermal stress, reduces tensile cracking
Matching cooling rate of steel pipe Reduces differential contraction, reduces compressive cracking
Optimizing ceramic layer thickness Reduces stress concentration at edges
Improving bond between ceramic and steel Reduces interface stress, reduces delamination

From a manufacturing perspective, the control of the cooling process is critical. The pipe must be cooled in a controlled manner, either by using an insulating blanket or by placing the pipe in a cooling chamber with controlled temperature. The cooling rate must be monitored and adjusted based on the pipe diameter and the ceramic layer thickness. I have seen ceramic-lined pipes crack in service because the cooling process was not properly controlled — the pipe was allowed to cool in ambient air, and the thermal stress caused the ceramic to crack.

Practical Lessons and Recommendations

The ceramic-lined steel pipe is an excellent product for abrasive and corrosive service — the ceramic lining provides outstanding wear resistance, and the steel pipe provides structural strength. However, the cracking of the ceramic lining is a persistent quality issue. The cooling hologram from this study provides a clear framework for understanding the cracking process and for developing control measures.

My recommendation is to implement strict cooling control in the manufacturing process. The cooling rate should be monitored and recorded for every pipe, and the process parameters should be adjusted based on the pipe diameter and the ceramic layer thickness. The quality control should include visual inspection of the ceramic lining for cracks, and the acceptance criteria should be defined based on the service conditions. For pipes in severe service — high temperature, high pressure, or abrasive media — the acceptance criteria should be stricter.

The most important lesson from this study is that the cracking of the ceramic lining is not an inevitable consequence of the SHS process. It is a controllable process parameter, and the key is to understand the stress development during cooling and to control the cooling rate accordingly. This is a lesson that I have applied in my own manufacturing operations, and it has significantly reduced the rejection rate for ceramic-lined pipes.