ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Analysis of Factors Affecting the Axial Compressive Bearing Capacity of Concrete-Filled Steel Tube Columns

Why This Paper Matters to the Pipe and Fitting Industry

This paper, by Zhang Chunmei, Yin Yi, and Zhou Yun from Guangzhou University, is a parametric study on the factors that affect the axial compressive bearing capacity of CFST columns. It was published in 2004, which makes it a relatively early contribution to the Chinese literature on CFST. The paper compares single-tube CFST columns with double-tube CFST columns and analyzes the effects of outer diameter, inner-to-outer diameter ratio, diameter-to-thickness ratio, and concrete strength.

I have read this paper many times over the years, and I keep coming back to it because it addresses the fundamental question that every pipe supplier must answer: what steel tube should I provide for a CFST column? The answer depends on the load, the concrete strength, and the structural configuration. This paper gives me the parametric framework to answer that question.

The Core Parameters and Their Effects

The paper identifies four key parameters that affect the axial compressive bearing capacity of CFST columns. Let me discuss each one from the perspective of a pipe manufacturer.

Outer Diameter

The outer diameter of the steel tube is the most obvious parameter. As the outer diameter increases, the cross-sectional area increases, and the bearing capacity increases. But the relationship is not linear because the concrete core area also increases, and the contribution of the concrete to the total capacity is significant. For a pipe manufacturer, this means that the outer diameter tolerance is critical. If the mill produces a tube with an outer diameter at the lower end of the tolerance range, the concrete core area is smaller than designed, and the capacity is reduced.

I have seen this problem in practice. A contractor ordered CFST columns with an outer diameter of 500 mm and a wall thickness of 12 mm. The mill produced tubes with an outer diameter of 498 mm, which is within the standard tolerance of ±1%. But the concrete core diameter was reduced by 2 mm, which reduced the core area by about 0.8%. The reduction in capacity was about 0.5%, which is small, but when you multiply it by the number of columns in a building, it adds up. The solution is to specify a tighter tolerance for the outer diameter when the tube is used in a CFST application.

Inner-to-Outer Diameter Ratio

The inner-to-outer diameter ratio is a measure of the wall thickness relative to the outer diameter. For a given outer diameter, a larger inner-to-outer diameter ratio means a thinner wall. The paper shows that as the inner-to-outer diameter ratio increases, the bearing capacity decreases, because the steel wall contributes less to the total capacity.

This is a critical parameter for the pipe industry because it directly relates to the wall thickness. A thin-walled tube is cheaper to produce, but it provides less confinement to the concrete core. The paper shows that there is an optimal inner-to-outer diameter ratio that balances the steel contribution and the concrete contribution. For most practical applications, the optimal ratio is in the range of 0.85 to 0.92, which corresponds to a diameter-to-thickness ratio of about 12 to 25.

Diameter-to-Thickness Ratio

The diameter-to-thickness ratio (D/t) is the most important parameter for local buckling. As D/t increases, the steel wall becomes more susceptible to local buckling, and the confinement effect on the concrete core is reduced. The paper shows that the bearing capacity decreases as D/t increases.

For the pipe industry, this means that the wall thickness must be sufficient to prevent local buckling before the concrete reaches its ultimate strength. I have seen CFST columns where the steel wall buckled locally at a load well below the design capacity because the wall thickness was too thin. The solution is to design the steel tube so that the D/t ratio is below the local buckling limit, which for most grades of steel is around 90 for circular tubes.

Concrete Strength

The concrete strength is the parameter that the pipe industry often overlooks. The paper shows that as the concrete strength increases, the bearing capacity increases, but the rate of increase diminishes at higher concrete strengths. This is because the steel tube provides confinement to the concrete, and the confinement effect is more pronounced for lower-strength concrete.

For the pipe industry, this means that the concrete strength must be matched to the steel tube properties. If you use a high-strength steel tube with a low-strength concrete core, the steel is underutilized. If you use a low-strength steel tube with a high-strength concrete core, the concrete is underutilized. The optimal combination depends on the D/t ratio and the confinement factor.

Double-Tube vs. Single-Tube CFST

The paper compares double-tube CFST columns with single-tube CFST columns. A double-tube CFST column consists of an outer steel tube, an inner steel tube, and concrete in the annular space between them, as well as concrete inside the inner tube. The paper shows that the double-tube configuration provides better confinement to the concrete core and higher bearing capacity than a single-tube configuration with the same total steel area.

This is an important finding for the pipe industry because it opens up a new market for smaller-diameter tubes. A double-tube CFST column requires two tubes: a large outer tube and a smaller inner tube. The inner tube can be a standard pipe size, which is readily available from any mill. The outer tube must be a custom size, which requires a mill to produce it.

I have seen double-tube CFST columns used in high-rise buildings where the column loads are very high. The double-tube configuration allows the designer to use a smaller outer diameter while maintaining the required capacity. This is a significant advantage in buildings where column space is at a premium.

Practical Implications for the Pipe Industry

Let me share some practical lessons from my experience in the pipe industry that relate to this paper.

First, the wall thickness tolerance is critical for CFST columns. I recommend that the wall thickness tolerance be specified as ±2.5% for CFST applications, which is tighter than the standard ±5% for structural tubes. The tighter tolerance ensures that the D/t ratio does not exceed the design value.

Second, the outer diameter tolerance is critical for the concrete core area. I recommend that the outer diameter tolerance be specified as ±0.5% for CFST applications, which is tighter than the standard ±1% for structural tubes. The tighter tolerance ensures that the concrete core area is not reduced below the design value.

Third, the surface condition of the steel tube affects the bond between the steel and the concrete. A smooth surface provides less bond than a rough surface. I recommend that the steel tube be specified with a minimum surface roughness to ensure adequate bond. This can be achieved by shot blasting the tube surface before concrete placement.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises several questions that I would like to address based on my experience.

What is the effect of the concrete shrinkage on the axial compressive bearing capacity? The paper does not address this, but I know from experience that concrete shrinkage can cause a gap between the steel wall and the concrete core. This gap reduces the confinement effect and can lead to premature failure. The solution is to use a shrinkage-compensating concrete or to add expansive admixtures.

What is the effect of the concrete creep on the long-term bearing capacity? The paper does not address this either, but I know from experience that concrete creep can redistribute the load from the concrete to the steel tube over time. This redistribution can increase the stress in the steel tube and reduce the overall safety factor.

What is the effect of the steel tube residual stress on the bearing capacity? The paper does not address this, but I know from experience that residual stress from cold-forming or welding can reduce the effective yield strength of the steel tube. The solution is to stress-relieve the steel tube after fabrication, or to use a hot-rolled tube instead of a cold-formed tube.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper is a valuable reference for engineers who design CFST columns and for pipe manufacturers who supply the steel tubes. The parametric analysis provides a clear framework for understanding the effects of outer diameter, inner-to-outer diameter ratio, diameter-to-thickness ratio, and concrete strength on the axial compressive bearing capacity.

The key insight for the pipe industry is that the steel tube is not just a passive container for concrete — it is an active structural element that provides confinement to the concrete core. The confinement effect depends on the D/t ratio and the steel yield strength. A thicker wall provides better confinement, but it also increases the cost. The optimal D/t ratio depends on the concrete strength and the load level.

For the pipe industry, the practical implications are clear. The wall thickness tolerance must be tight, the outer diameter tolerance must be tight, and the surface condition must be specified. These are not just manufacturing concerns — they are structural concerns that affect the safety of the entire structure.

Reference Value and Outlook

This paper was published in 2004, and the CFST field has advanced significantly since then. However, the parametric framework that the paper provides is still valid and useful. The paper is a good starting point for engineers who are new to CFST design, and it provides a solid foundation for understanding the factors that affect the axial compressive bearing capacity.

For the future, I would like to see research on the following topics: the effect of concrete shrinkage and creep on the long-term bearing capacity; the effect of cyclic loading on the bearing capacity; and the effect of fire on the bearing capacity. These are the topics that will matter most in real engineering practice.

In conclusion, this paper is a valuable contribution to the literature on CFST columns. It provides a clear parametric framework for understanding the factors that affect the axial compressive bearing capacity, and it highlights the importance of the steel tube properties in the overall structural performance. The lessons from this paper are directly applicable to the pipe and fitting industry, and I recommend that every engineer who works with CFST structures read it and take its lessons to heart.