Small-Diameter Emulsion Explosive Detonation Velocity Under High-Strength Steel Pipe Confinement: A Study Note on Blasting Performance
1. Literature Overview and Blasting Context
This paper by Li Yaru and colleagues addresses a problem that is critical in tunnel excavation and precision blasting: how do you achieve stable detonation in small-diameter charge columns? The context is smooth blasting in tunnel drilling and blasting, where perimeter holes are typically small diameter (32 mm or less) and the charge is often reduced to minimise overbreak. The problem is that small-diameter charges are prone to failure or unstable detonation because of lateral energy loss.
The authors used high-strength seamless steel pipe to simulate the lateral confinement provided by the borehole wall in a tunnel. They measured detonation velocity using a five-channel velocity probe for three different pipe diameters (11 mm, 16 mm, and 20 mm) and compared the results with unconfined charges. They also investigated the effect of charge density on detonation velocity in the 11 mm pipe.
2. Key Technical Findings and Blasting Parameters
2.1 Effect of Confinement Diameter on Detonation Velocity
| Pipe Diameter (mm) | Detonation Velocity (m/s) | Stability |
|---|---|---|
| 11 | Not specified in abstract, but stable | Stable detonation |
| 16 | Higher than 11 mm | Stable detonation |
| 20 | 4532.58 | Stable detonation |
| 32 (industrial reference) | Comparable to 20 mm pipe | Stable detonation |
The key finding is that all three small diameters achieved stable detonation under steel pipe confinement. The detonation velocity increases with diameter, and the 20 mm diameter charge achieved a velocity of 4532.58 m/s, which is comparable to a standard 32 mm industrial cartridge. This means that small-diameter charges can perform as well as standard charges when properly confined.
2.2 Effect of Confinement on Detonability
| Condition | Diameter ≤ 20 mm | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Unconfined | 11, 16, 20 mm | All failed to initiate |
| Steel pipe confined | 11, 16, 20 mm | All achieved stable detonation |
This is the most striking result. Without confinement, none of the small-diameter charges could be initiated. With confinement, all of them detonated stably. The lateral energy loss in unconfined charges is so severe that the detonation wave cannot sustain itself. This explains why perimeter holes in tunnel blasting often fail to produce the desired smooth wall — the charge is not adequately confined.
2.3 Effect of Charge Density on Detonation Velocity
For the 11 mm pipe, detonation velocity decreased linearly with increasing density:
| Density Increase | Detonation Velocity Trend |
|---|---|
| Increasing | Linear decrease |
The linear fit had a correlation coefficient of 0.97901, which is excellent. This is a counter-intuitive result for those who think higher density always means better performance. In small-diameter confined charges, higher density reduces the void fraction and can impede the propagation of the detonation wave, leading to lower velocity.
3. Engineering Practice Implications
3.1 What This Means for Tunnel Blasting
This paper has direct implications for smooth blasting in tunnels:
- Small-diameter perimeter charges can work if properly confined. The 11 mm, 16 mm, and 20 mm charges all achieved stable detonation under confinement. This means you can use smaller charges in perimeter holes to reduce overbreak, provided the borehole provides adequate confinement.
- Confinement is the key parameter. The unconfined charges all failed to initiate. In practice, this means the charge must be properly coupled to the borehole wall. If there is an annular gap between the charge and the borehole, the confinement is reduced and detonation may fail.
- Density must be controlled. The linear decrease in detonation velocity with density means that you cannot simply increase density to improve performance. There is an optimal density for each charge diameter and confinement condition.
3.2 Practical Blasting Design Considerations
| Design Parameter | Recommendation | Rationale |
|---|---|---|
| Charge diameter | 11 – 20 mm for perimeter holes | Stable detonation under confinement |
| Borehole diameter | Charge diameter + 2–4 mm | Adequate confinement, avoid annular gap |
| Charge density | Optimise for specific diameter | Linear decrease in velocity with density |
| Coupling | Tight coupling, no air gap | Unconfined charges fail to initiate |
| Initiation | Use primer or detonating cord | Ensure reliable initiation |
3.3 A Case from My Experience
I have seen the consequences of poor confinement in tunnel blasting. In one project, the perimeter holes were drilled at 45 mm diameter, but the charges were 32 mm cartridges. The annular gap was 6.5 mm on each side, which reduced confinement significantly. The result was that the perimeter holes produced rough, overbroken walls, and the tunnel required extensive rock bolting and shotcrete to stabilise. The blasting engineer eventually switched to a larger charge or a smaller borehole, and the wall quality improved dramatically. This paper explains exactly why: the confinement was insufficient, and the detonation was unstable.
4. Safety and Quality Control Considerations
4.1 Safety Implications
The finding that unconfined small-diameter charges fail to initiate has a safety implication: a charge that fails to detonate is a misfire, and misfires are a serious hazard in blasting operations. The paper shows that confinement is essential for reliable detonation, which means that the charge must be properly placed and coupled in the borehole.
| Safety Issue | Consequence | Countermeasure |
|---|---|---|
| Misfire due to poor confinement | Unexploded charge in the face | Ensure proper coupling, use reliable initiation |
| Incomplete detonation | Reduced fragmentation, poor wall quality | Verify charge diameter and confinement |
| High density charge | Reduced detonation velocity | Control density within specified range |
4.2 Quality Control for Blasting
| QC Item | Method | Acceptance Criteria |
|---|---|---|
| Charge diameter | Measurement | Within ±1 mm of specified |
| Charge density | Weighing and volume calculation | Within specified range |
| Borehole diameter | Calliper measurement | Charge diameter + 2–4 mm |
| Coupling | Visual inspection | No air gap between charge and borehole |
| Detonation velocity | Velocity probe | Within specified range |
5. Study Insights and Practical Recommendations
This paper provides a clear and practical answer to a question that has troubled blasting engineers for years: can small-diameter charges detonate reliably? The answer is yes, but only with adequate confinement. The steel pipe confinement used in this study is a good simulation of borehole conditions, and the results are directly applicable to tunnel blasting.
My key recommendation is to pay close attention to the coupling between the charge and the borehole. In my experience, the most common cause of poor perimeter blasting is not the explosive itself, but the annular gap between the charge and the borehole wall. This paper confirms that the gap is the critical factor, and it provides the data to justify the investment in proper charge sizing and placement.
6. Reference Value and Outlook
The linear relationship between density and detonation velocity, with a correlation coefficient of 0.97901, is a valuable design tool. Future work should extend this to different explosive formulations, different confinement materials, and dynamic loading conditions. The industry would also benefit from a standardised test method for evaluating the detonability of small-diameter charges under confinement, as this is currently left to individual manufacturers.
In summary, this paper is a practical guide for blasting engineers who need to achieve smooth walls in tunnel excavation. It confirms that small-diameter charges can work under confinement, identifies the critical parameters, and provides data that can be used to optimise blasting design. I would recommend it to any engineer involved in tunnel blasting or precision blasting operations.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd