ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Analysis of Compression Web Member Effective Length in Circular Concrete-Filled Steel Tube Trusses Considering Joint Stiffness

Literature Overview and Core Contribution

The paper by Wang Xinyi and Tong Lewei, published in the Journal of Harbin Engineering University in 2016, addresses a question that has troubled structural engineers for decades: what effective length should be used for the compression web members in a circular concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) truss? The authors recognise that the joint stiffness at the chord-web intersection has a significant influence on the buckling behaviour of the web members, and they develop a numerical study of the flexural stiffness of T/Y-type joints under in-plane bending. They compare the stiffness of hollow steel tube joints with that of concrete-filled joints, establish a parametric formula for the joint stiffness, and then derive the effective length factor for compression web members. The key finding is that the effective length of 0.7l, which is often used in design, may be conservative for CFST trusses, and that the joint stiffness increases significantly when the chord is filled with concrete.

From my perspective as someone who has fabricated and erected both hollow steel tube trusses and CFST trusses, this is a genuinely useful piece of research. The effective length factor is one of those parameters that designers either take from a code without thinking or over-simplify to avoid complexity. The paper shows that the concrete fill changes the joint behaviour in a way that benefits the web member stability, which means that the current design approach may be leaving performance on the table.

Technical Points and Joint Stiffness Analysis

Comparison of Hollow and Concrete-Filled Joint Stiffness

The authors use finite element analysis to determine the flexural stiffness of the joint, defined as the moment per unit rotation at the chord-web intersection. They compare the stiffness for hollow chord tubes and for concrete-filled chord tubes, and they find that the concrete fill increases the joint stiffness substantially. This is intuitive: the concrete core restrains the chord wall against ovalisation, which is the primary deformation mode in a hollow tube joint under in-plane bending. Without the concrete, the chord wall can deform locally at the intersection, allowing the web member to rotate more freely. With the concrete, the chord wall is supported from the inside, and the joint becomes much stiffer.

Parameter Effect on Joint Stiffness Practical Interpretation
Concrete fill Significant increase in joint stiffness The concrete restrains chord wall ovalisation, the dominant deformation mode
β (web-to-chord diameter ratio) Stiffness increases with β Larger web members transfer more moment and activate more of the chord wall
τ (web-to-chord wall thickness ratio) Stiffness increases with τ Thicker web walls distribute the moment over a larger area
γ (chord diameter-to-thickness ratio) Stiffness decreases with γ Slender chord walls are more prone to ovalisation
θ (web-to-chord angle) Stiffness decreases with θ More oblique connections produce higher local bending in the chord wall

The Parametric Formula and Its Limitations

The authors establish a parametric formula for the joint stiffness based on the dimensionless parameters β, τ, γ and θ. This is a valuable contribution because it allows designers to calculate the joint stiffness without running a finite element analysis for every joint. However, I would caution that the formula is based on a limited range of parameters and may not be valid outside that range. In particular, the formula does not account for the effect of the concrete strength, the bond between the concrete and the steel tube, or the presence of internal stiffeners. In practice, I would use the formula for preliminary design and verify the critical joints with a more detailed analysis.

Effective Length of Compression Web Members

The authors then use the joint stiffness to calculate the effective length factor for the compression web members. They find that the effective length can be taken as approximately 0.7l for trusses where both the upper and lower chords are concrete-filled, which is less conservative than the value often used in design. This means that the current design approach may be over-conservative, leading to larger web members than necessary. For a truss with many web members, this can translate into significant material savings.

Integration with Manufacturing and Site Practice

Fabrication and Welding Considerations for CFST Trusses

From a fabrication standpoint, CFST trusses are more complex to build than hollow steel tube trusses. The chord tubes must be filled with concrete after the truss is assembled, which means that the chord must have access holes for concrete placement and vent holes for air release. The web members are typically welded to the chord wall, and the weld quality is critical because the joint stiffness depends on the weld being fully effective. In my experience, the most common problem is lack of fusion at the root of the web-to-chord weld, which reduces the joint stiffness and can lead to premature buckling of the web member. The fix is to use a suitable weld preparation, such as a single-bevel or double-bevel groove, and to ensure complete fusion by using a backing method or by welding from both sides where possible.

The Practical Significance of the Effective Length Factor

The finding that the effective length can be taken as 0.7l is practically significant because it allows the web members to be sized more efficiently. For a truss with a large number of web members, the material savings can be substantial. However, I would caution against applying this factor blindly. The effective length depends on the joint stiffness, which in turn depends on the weld quality, the concrete fill quality and the geometric parameters. If the concrete fill is incomplete or if the welds are defective, the joint stiffness will be lower than assumed, and the web members may buckle prematurely. In practice, I would require a high level of quality control on the concrete fill and the welds before relying on the reduced effective length factor.

Key Questions, Reflections and Study Insights

What the Paper Does Not Address

The paper focuses on in-plane bending of the joint, but in a real truss, the web members are also subjected to out-of-plane bending and to axial forces. The joint stiffness under out-of-plane bending may be different, and this could affect the effective length factor. In addition, the paper does not address the effect of fatigue, which is important for trusses subjected to cyclic loading, such as those in bridges or offshore structures. I would recommend that any design based on this paper be verified for out-of-plane effects and fatigue before adoption.

The Practical Lesson from My Own Projects

I have seen trusses where the web members buckled prematurely because the joint stiffness was lower than assumed in design. In one case, the web-to-chord welds were undersized, and the joint rotated significantly under load, reducing the effective restraint on the web member. The result was a buckling failure at a load well below the design load. The lesson is that the joint stiffness is not just a theoretical parameter; it is a physical property that depends on the quality of the fabrication and the welding. Designers should specify the joint stiffness as a requirement, and fabricators should verify that the welds achieve the required quality.

Concluding Remarks and Outlook

This paper makes a significant contribution to the understanding of joint stiffness in CFST trusses and provides a practical method for determining the effective length of compression web members. The key insight is that the concrete fill significantly increases the joint stiffness, which allows a reduced effective length factor of approximately 0.7l. For the industry, the practical takeaway is that CFST trusses can be designed more efficiently than hollow steel tube trusses, provided that the joint stiffness is properly accounted for and that the fabrication quality is high. I would encourage the authors to extend their work to out-of-plane bending and to fatigue loading, and to validate the parametric formula with a broader range of test data. The next step should be a full-scale test of a CFST truss to confirm the effective length factor under realistic loading conditions.