Research on Mechanical Properties of Inner and Outer Double-Row Flange Connections at Steel Pipe Pole Tower Foot Joints
Literature Overview and Core Contribution
The paper by Zhang Chaowen, Cai Yanhao, Liao Xiaosu, Zeng Cong, Zhu Shijia and Zhang Yu, published in the Journal of Wuhan University (Engineering Edition) in 2025, addresses the mechanical behaviour of inner and outer double-row flange connections at the base of steel pipe pole towers. The authors conduct bending load tests on specimens of the root joint, combined with finite element analysis, and they identify the location of the maximum stressed bolt, the position of the rotation axis, and the effect of flange plate thickness and stiffener arrangement on the bolt forces. The key findings are that the maximum stressed bolt is located at approximately 0.9 times the outer flange radius, the rotation axis is located at approximately 0.25 times the inner radius of the steel pipe, and that the bolt forces are more evenly distributed when one stiffener is placed between every two bolts.
From my perspective as someone who has designed and fabricated flange connections for steel poles, towers and pipe structures, this is a practical and valuable piece of research. Flange connections are often the weak link in a structure, and the design of the bolt group and the stiffeners is often done by rule of thumb rather than by analysis. The paper provides a rational basis for the design of double-row flange connections, which are commonly used for large-diameter poles where a single row of bolts would require an excessively large flange plate.
Technical Points and Experimental Investigation
Test Setup and Specimen Configuration
The authors conducted bending load tests on specimens of the root joint, which is the critical section at the base of a steel pipe pole. The specimens consisted of a steel pipe with an inner and outer double-row flange connection, and the load was applied to produce a bending moment at the joint. The bolt forces were measured using load cells or strain gauges, and the rotation of the flange was measured using displacement transducers. The test setup was designed to simulate the actual loading condition of a pole tower, where the base is subjected to a combination of axial load and bending moment.
Key Findings on Bolt Force Distribution and Rotation Axis
The most important finding is that the maximum stressed bolt is located at approximately 0.9 times the outer flange radius, not at the outermost bolt as might be expected. This is because the flange plate is not perfectly rigid, and the bolt forces are distributed according to the stiffness of the flange plate and the deformation of the pipe. The rotation axis, which is the point about which the flange rotates under bending, is located at approximately 0.25 times the inner radius of the steel pipe. This is an important parameter because it determines the lever arm for the bolt forces and hence the moment capacity of the joint.
| Parameter | Finding | Practical Significance |
|---|---|---|
| Location of maximum stressed bolt | 0.9 times the outer flange radius | The outermost bolts are not always the most highly stressed |
| Rotation axis location | 0.25 times the inner radius of the pipe | Determines the lever arm for bolt forces and the moment capacity |
| Effect of flange plate thickness | Increasing thickness reduces bolt axial stress | Thicker flanges distribute the load more evenly |
| Effect of inner bolt distance from pipe wall | Increasing distance reduces inner bolt stress, increases outer bolt stress | The inner bolt row becomes less effective as it moves away from the pipe |
| Stiffener arrangement | One stiffener between every two bolts gives the most even distribution | This arrangement minimises the maximum bolt force |
Parametric Analysis of Flange Plate Thickness and Stiffener Arrangement
The authors conducted a parametric analysis using finite element analysis to study the effect of flange plate thickness and stiffener arrangement on the bolt forces. They found that increasing the flange plate thickness reduces the bolt axial stress, which is intuitive: a thicker flange is stiffer and distributes the load more evenly among the bolts. They also found that the distance of the inner bolt row from the pipe wall has a significant effect: as the inner bolts move further from the pipe wall, their stress decreases, but the stress in the outer bolts increases. This is because the inner bolts become less effective at resisting the moment as their lever arm decreases relative to the rotation axis.
The most interesting finding is the effect of the stiffener arrangement. The authors compared several arrangements, including one stiffener between every two bolts, one stiffener between every bolt, and no stiffeners. They found that one stiffener between every two bolts gives the most even distribution of bolt forces and the lowest maximum bolt force. This is a valuable practical insight because it allows the designer to optimise the stiffener arrangement to minimise the bolt forces and hence the bolt size.
Integration with Manufacturing and Site Practice
Fabrication and Welding Considerations for Flange Connections
From a fabrication standpoint, double-row flange connections are more complex to manufacture than single-row flanges. The flange plate must be machined flat to ensure uniform bolt preload, and the bolt holes must be drilled accurately to ensure that the bolts can be inserted without interference. The stiffeners must be welded to the pipe and the flange plate, and the weld quality is critical because the stiffeners are essential for transferring the load from the pipe to the flange. In my experience, the most common problem is distortion of the flange plate during welding, which reduces the bolt preload and can lead to bolt loosening under cyclic loading. The fix is to use a suitable welding sequence, such as welding the stiffeners in a balanced pattern, and to machine the flange plate after welding to ensure flatness.
The Practical Significance of the Rotation Axis Location
The finding that the rotation axis is located at approximately 0.25 times the inner radius of the pipe is practically significant because it determines the lever arm for the bolt forces. In a conventional design, the rotation axis is often assumed to be at the edge of the pipe or at the centroid of the compression zone. The paper shows that the actual rotation axis is closer to the centre of the pipe, which means that the lever arm for the outer bolts is larger than assumed, and the moment capacity of the joint is higher. This allows the designer to use smaller bolts or a smaller flange plate, which can result in significant material savings.
Key Questions, Reflections and Study Insights
What the Paper Does Not Address
The paper focuses on the static behaviour of the joint under bending, but it does not address the effect of bolt preload relaxation, which is a common problem in flange connections. Over time, the bolt preload can decrease due to creep of the gasket or the flange, and this can lead to bolt loosening and reduced joint stiffness. In addition, the paper does not address the effect of prying forces, which can significantly increase the bolt forces in a flange connection. The prying force depends on the geometry of the flange and the stiffeners, and it should be accounted for in the design. I would recommend that any design based on this paper be verified for prying forces and bolt preload relaxation before adoption.
The Practical Lesson from My Own Projects
I have seen flange connections where the bolts loosened after a period of service because the flange plate was not flat, or because the bolt preload was not properly controlled during installation. In one case, a pole tower base connection developed a visible gap between the flange plates after a storm, and the bolts were found to be loose. The cause was inadequate bolt preload during installation, combined with a lack of locknuts or thread-locking compound. The lesson is that the design of the flange connection is only half the story; the installation procedure is equally important. Designers should specify the bolt preload, the tightening sequence and the locking method, and site engineers should verify that the installation is carried out correctly.
Concluding Remarks and Outlook
This paper makes a valuable contribution to the understanding of double-row flange connections at the base of steel pipe pole towers, and it provides practical guidance for the design of the bolt group and the stiffener arrangement. The key insight is that the maximum stressed bolt is not always the outermost bolt, and that the rotation axis is located at approximately 0.25 times the inner radius of the pipe. The finding that one stiffener between every two bolts gives the most even distribution of bolt forces is particularly useful for design. For the industry, the practical takeaway is that double-row flange connections can be designed more efficiently by accounting for the actual rotation axis and the stiffener arrangement. I would encourage the authors to extend their work to prying forces and bolt preload relaxation, and to validate the parametric formula with a broader range of test data. The next step should be a full-scale test of a pole tower base connection under combined axial load and bending moment to confirm the design method under realistic loading conditions.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd