Tension Behaviour of PBL-Stiffened Rectangular Concrete-Filled Steel Tube Unequal-Width T-Joints
The Structural Concept and Why It Matters
Cheng Gao, Liu Yongjian, Tian Zhijuan, Qiu Jielin and Xiong Zhihua published this study in the Journal of Chang'an University (Natural Science Edition) (2015, Vol. 35, No. 3, pp. 83–90) under the National Natural Science Foundation projects 51178051 and 5178068. The subject is a new steel-concrete composite joint for bridge engineering: a rectangular concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) chord stiffened internally with PBL (Perfobond Leiste) ribs, connected to a square steel tube branch in an unequal-width T-joint configuration. The PBL rib is a steel plate with regularly spaced holes through which the concrete core passes, forming a dowel action that transfers shear between the steel plate and the concrete. The rib thus serves a dual function: it stiffens the chord wall against local buckling and out-of-plane deformation, and it acts as a shear connector to engage the concrete core in load sharing.
This is an important development because rectangular CFST sections are increasingly used in arch bridges and truss bridges, where the chord is subjected to tension from the branch members. In a conventional rectangular hollow section joint, the chord wall is thin relative to its width, and a branch in tension tends to pull the chord face outward, causing a "prying" failure mode where the chord face plate yields and deforms locally. The chord wall in this study has a width-to-thickness ratio of 27, which is slender enough to be vulnerable to this mode. The branch-to-chord width ratio is 0.4, meaning the branch is significantly narrower than the chord, so the tension load is concentrated over a limited width of the chord face. The PBL rib, welded to the inside of the chord face plate, restrains the plate from lifting and transfers the load into the concrete core, which then distributes it over a much larger area.
Test Setup and Failure Modes
The research combines experimental testing with nonlinear finite element analysis. The test specimens are unequal-width T-joints with a PBL-stiffened rectangular CFST chord and a square steel tube branch. The branch is welded to the chord face, and the joint is loaded in tension on the branch while the chord ends are fixed. The failure modes observed and predicted include chord face plate yielding, PBL rib yielding or shear failure, concrete crushing or splitting, and weld failure at the branch-to-chord connection. The PBL rib changes the failure mode from a local chord face prying failure to a more distributed failure involving the concrete core, which is a much more ductile and higher-capacity mode.
The finite element model captures the nonlinear material behavior of the steel and the concrete, including the confinement effect of the steel tube on the concrete core and the contact interaction at the steel-concrete interface. The analysis examines the stress distribution in the chord face plate, the PBL rib, and the concrete core, and it quantifies the contribution of the PBL rib to the joint stiffness and capacity. The key finding is that the PBL rib significantly increases the tension stiffness and the ultimate bearing capacity of the joint, and it improves the fatigue performance by reducing the stress concentration at the weld between the branch and the chord face.
| Failure Mode | Without PBL Rib | With PBL Rib | Practical Consequence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chord face plate yielding | Dominant, at low load | Delayed, higher load | PBL rib restrains the plate from lifting |
| Concrete core crushing | Not engaged | Engaged after rib yielding | Concrete shares the load via dowel action |
| Joint stiffness | Low, governed by plate bending | High, governed by composite action | Less deformation under service load |
| Fatigue resistance | Poor, high stress concentration | Improved, lower stress range | Longer service life under cyclic loading |
| Ductility | Limited, sudden failure | Improved, gradual failure | More warning before ultimate state |
Parametric Effects and the Role of the PBL Rib
The width-to-thickness ratio of 27 places the chord wall in the slender range where local buckling and plate bending are the governing concerns. The PBL rib, welded to the inside of the chord face plate, effectively reduces the unsupported width of the plate and provides an elastic restraint against out-of-plane deformation. The holes in the rib allow the concrete to pass through, creating a mechanical interlock that transfers the branch tension into the concrete core. This is the dual action that the paper emphasizes: the rib is both a stiffener and a shear connector.
The parametric analysis shows that the joint capacity increases with the PBL rib height, the rib thickness, and the hole diameter, up to a limit beyond which the failure mode shifts to concrete crushing or rib shear. The branch-to-chord width ratio of 0.4 means the load is concentrated, and the PBL rib must be positioned to cover the full width of the branch connection plus a margin on each side. The concrete core strength also matters: a higher strength concrete provides more dowel resistance and more confinement to the steel plate, but it also makes the failure more brittle. The optimal design balances these effects.
The stress distribution analysis reveals that the PBL rib reduces the peak stress in the chord face plate by a significant margin and distributes the load over a wider area of the concrete core. This is the mechanism behind the improved stiffness and capacity. The paper also notes that the PBL rib improves the fatigue performance of the joint, which is critical for bridge structures subjected to repeated traffic loading. The stress concentration at the branch-to-chord weld is reduced because the load is transferred more gradually into the chord, rather than being concentrated at the weld toe.
Fabrication and Welding Considerations
This is where I speak from the shop floor. The PBL rib is welded to the inside of the chord face plate before the chord is closed and the concrete is placed. This is a hidden weld, and it is difficult to inspect after the chord is assembled. The weld quality is critical because the rib must develop its full shear capacity to transfer the load into the concrete core. A poor weld with lack of fusion or porosity will fail prematurely, and the joint will revert to the un-stiffened behavior. The weld should be a full penetration or a large fillet weld, and it should be inspected by ultrasonic testing from the outside of the plate before the chord is closed. In practice, I have seen PBL ribs welded with undersized fillet welds because the welder could not reach the inside of the section. The remedy is to design the rib and the chord so that the weld is accessible, or to use a robotic welding process with a pre-qualified procedure.
The holes in the PBL rib must be clean and free of slag, spatter, and burrs, because the concrete must flow through them completely to form the dowel. The hole diameter should be at least three times the maximum aggregate size to ensure proper filling. The concrete placement is also critical: the chord must be filled with self-compacting concrete or pumped concrete with a suitable mix design, and the concrete must be vibrated or placed in a way that ensures complete filling of the holes and the space between the rib and the plate. A void in the concrete at the rib location creates a weak point that can lead to premature failure.
The branch-to-chord weld is a groove weld around the perimeter of the branch, and it must be full penetration in the tension zone to develop the full capacity of the branch wall. The weld should be qualified by a welding procedure specification, and the welder must be certified for the position and the material. The inspection should include ultrasonic testing or radiographic testing of the groove weld, and magnetic particle testing of the weld toe. The residual stress from welding can affect the local behavior of the joint, so the welding sequence should be controlled to minimize distortion and residual stress. In a rectangular section, the welding of the branch to the chord face can cause the chord face to distort, which affects the fit-up and the load path. The remedy is to use a balanced welding sequence and to check the flatness of the chord face after welding.
The practical judgment I would offer is this: the PBL-stiffened rectangular CFST joint is a sound and efficient solution, but it demands a higher level of fabrication quality than a conventional hollow section joint. The hidden weld and the concrete placement are the two areas where quality problems are most likely. If you are specifying this type of joint, you must require a detailed welding procedure, a mock-up test, and a rigorous inspection plan. The paper provides the technical justification for the concept, but the success of the application depends on the discipline of the fabricator and the contractor. This is a case where the research is ahead of the practice, and the industry needs to catch up with the quality requirements.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd