ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Creep Behaviour of Concrete-Filled Steel Tubes: Expansion Agent and Stress Ratio Effects

Literature Overview and Why It Matters on the Floor

This paper from Lanzhou Jiaotong University, published in the Journal of Central South University in 2014, is one of those pieces of research that quietly answers a question every one of us has wrestled with on a job site: what actually happens to the concrete inside a steel tube over time, and how much of the shrinkage and creep do we have to design for? The authors, Zhang Rongling and colleagues, ran a systematic set of creep tests on concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) specimens with expansion agent dosages of 4%, 8% and 12%, and stress ratios from 0.15 up to 0.74. They measured the longitudinal deformation of the composite section over time, and then went into the SEM and energy-dispersive spectroscopy to explain the mechanism at the micro level. For a pipe man, this is not academic decoration. It is the difference between a column that holds its line and one that sheds load to the steel shell sooner than the designer assumed.

Key Technical Findings and Their Interpretation

Effect of Expansion Agent Dosage

The most striking result is that the creep strain does not decrease in proportion to the expansion agent dosage. The order of effectiveness, from smallest to largest creep strain, was 12%, 8% and 4%. In other words, the 12% dosage gave the best creep resistance, but the relationship is not linear. The authors explain this through the formation of ettringite, which is the product of the expansion agent reacting with the cement matrix. The ettringite crystals fill the pores in the cement paste, making the structure denser and reducing the amount of creep deformation available to the system. However, the paper is careful to note that more is not always better beyond a certain point, because excessive expansion can generate internal stress that actually damages the paste structure.

Expansion Agent Dosage Relative Creep Strain Dominant Mechanism
4% Highest Insufficient ettringite to fill pores; shrinkage dominates
8% Intermediate Moderate ettringite formation; partial pore filling
12% Lowest Dense ettringite network; effective shrinkage compensation

Effect of Stress Ratio

The stress ratio tests were conducted at 0.15, 0.31, 0.33, 0.37 and 0.74. The clear trend is that creep strain increases with stress ratio. This is intuitive to anyone who has watched a loaded column for a year, but the paper adds an important nuance: as the wall thickness of the steel tube increases, the lateral confinement provided by the steel shell increases, and this confinement restricts the transverse expansion of the concrete, thereby limiting the creep deformation. This is a critical interaction between the steel pipe geometry and the concrete behaviour. A thin-walled tube will allow more lateral expansion, and therefore more creep, than a thick-walled tube of the same diameter.

Practical Implications for Pipe and Fitting Engineers

This is where the paper earns its keep for us. When we are supplying steel pipe for CFST columns, we are not just delivering a cylinder. We are delivering a confining vessel whose wall thickness, diameter and steel grade directly control the long-term behaviour of the composite member. The following points are the ones I would flag to a young engineer before they sign off on a CFST pipe order:

  1. Wall thickness is a design parameter, not just a strength parameter. A thicker wall gives more confinement and reduces creep. If the structural designer has assumed a certain creep coefficient, they need to know what wall thickness was used in the test that produced that coefficient.
  2. The expansion agent dosage must be specified in the concrete mix design, and it must be communicated to the pipe supplier. The pipe manufacturer cannot control the concrete, but they can control the geometry. If the concrete mix is changed on site, the creep behaviour changes, and the pipe may be over- or under-designed.
  3. The stress ratio matters. In a real building, the column may be loaded to 0.3 of its capacity in service, but during construction, it may be loaded to 0.5 or more before the concrete has fully cured. The paper's data at 0.74 stress ratio is a warning: if you load a CFST column hard before the concrete has matured, you will get significant creep, and the steel shell will take a larger share of the load than the design intended.

Study Insights and Reflection

What I take away from this paper is that CFST is not a simple "steel tube with concrete inside" system. It is a composite where the steel and the concrete are in a continuous, mutual interaction. The steel tube is not just a formwork; it is a confining device that changes the constitutive behaviour of the concrete. The creep of the concrete, in turn, changes the stress distribution in the steel. This coupling is often ignored in simplified design methods, and it is the source of many of the problems we see in the field.

The paper also reminds me of a lesson from the shop floor: when we weld a CFST column, we must be careful about the heat input. The welding of the steel tube generates residual stresses and can cause local distortion, which changes the confinement geometry. A small distortion in the tube wall can reduce the effective confinement and increase creep. I have seen this in practice where a column that was welded with high heat input showed more deformation over time than an identical column welded with controlled heat input.

Conclusion and Outlook

This paper is a solid contribution to the understanding of CFST creep, but it is a laboratory study. The real question for us is how the results scale to full-scale columns with real construction tolerances, real weld defects, and real environmental conditions. The authors have given us a mechanism, and the mechanism is sound. The next step is to correlate the laboratory creep coefficients with field measurements from actual buildings. Until that is done, I would recommend using the paper's results as a guide for the direction of the effect, but not as a substitute for full-scale testing on a project-by-project basis. For the pipe supplier, the message is clear: know your wall thickness, know your steel grade, and never assume that the concrete inside the tube is behaving the way the textbook says it will.