ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Wind Tunnel Study on Shape Coefficients of Steel Pipe Transmission Towers

Literature Overview and Practical Significance

This paper by Deng Hongzhou and colleagues from Tongji University addresses a question that has bothered transmission tower designers for decades: what shape coefficient should be used for steel pipe members in lattice towers. The study used high-frequency force balance wind tunnel tests on a 1:1 scale model of the SZT2 tower from the 1000 kV Huainan–Shanghai UHV transmission line, measuring average wind loads and deriving body shape coefficients for both the tower body and the cross arm sections. For a veteran who has supplied thousands of tonnes of steel pipe for transmission towers, this is not an academic exercise. The shape coefficient directly determines the design wind load, which in turn drives the required wall thickness, the steel grade, and ultimately the tonnage and cost of every tower in a line. If the coefficient is underestimated, towers can fail in high winds; if overestimated, the project pays for steel that is never needed. The practical value of this study is that it replaces conservative assumptions with measured data, allowing designers to optimise steel usage without compromising safety.

Interpretation of Key Technical Points

The most significant finding is that the worst-case wind directions for the steel pipe tower are 15° and 75° relative to the tower face, not the 0° or 90° directions that designers typically assume. This is because at oblique angles, the wind acts on both the front and side faces of the tower simultaneously, creating a resultant force that is greater than the sum of the individual face loads. The second key finding is the recommended shape coefficients: 0.80 for the tower body and 0.85 for the cross arm. These values are notably higher than the 0.70 coefficient often used in earlier designs, which means that many existing towers may have been under-designed for wind loads. The difference between 0.70 and 0.80 is a 14% increase in design wind load, which for a large tower can mean several tonnes of additional steel. The study also confirmed that the shape coefficient is essentially independent of wind speed within the tested range, which simplifies design practice.

Parameter Tower Body Cross Arm
Recommended shape coefficient 0.80 0.85
Worst wind direction 15° 75°
Typical design value before study 0.70 0.70
Design load increase +14.3% +21.4%

Connection to Manufacturing and Delivery Practice

From a pipe supply perspective, this study has direct implications for how we quote and fabricate transmission tower members. When a design office specifies a shape coefficient of 0.80, the calculated wind load increases, and the required section modulus of the pipe member increases accordingly. For a given steel grade, this may mean stepping up from Q345 to Q420, or increasing the wall thickness from 6 mm to 8 mm or 10 mm. In my experience, this can change the pipe manufacturing route: thinner walls can be produced by ERW/HFW welding, while thicker walls may require seamless or even LSAW pipe, which changes lead times and costs. I have seen projects where the designer specified ERW pipe for tower legs, but after a wind load recalculation using measured shape coefficients, the wall thickness increased beyond the ERW range and we had to switch to seamless pipe, adding six weeks to delivery. The lesson for suppliers is to always check the design basis before quoting, and to ask the designer which shape coefficient was used. If they say 0.70, it is worth a phone call to confirm, because the difference can be the difference between a smooth delivery and a costly change order.

Critical Questions and Reflections

One question that this study raises but does not fully answer is whether the shape coefficient should be applied uniformly to all members of a tower, or whether it should vary along the height. The wind profile changes with elevation, and the local turbulence intensity at the top of a tower is different from that at the base. The study used a single model of the entire tower, so the coefficients are representative of the whole structure, but for a 100 m tower the local wind environment at the top may justify a different coefficient. Another question is the effect of surface roughness. The tests were conducted on smooth steel pipe surfaces, but in practice, tower members are often galvanised, painted, or have attachments such as climbing pegs, conductor clamps, and spacer plates. These surface features increase the effective roughness and may change the shape coefficient by 5% to 10%. I have seen towers in coastal areas where salt deposits and corrosion pitting significantly roughen the surface over time, and the question is whether the design coefficient should account for this degradation. The study does not address this, but it is a real concern for towers in service for 30 years or more.

Study Insights and Implications for Engineering Practice

The key insight from this study is that wind loads on steel pipe towers are more complex than simple design codes assume, and that oblique wind directions can be more critical than face-on wind. For designers, this means that a two-directional analysis (0° and 90°) is insufficient; at least four directions should be considered, including 15° and 75°. For fabricators, the implication is that the steel specification may change after a more detailed wind analysis, so the procurement strategy should be flexible enough to accommodate a change in wall thickness or steel grade without delaying the project. For suppliers, the lesson is to understand the design basis and to be prepared for the possibility that a seemingly straightforward tower order may require a different pipe specification than initially assumed. In my own practice, I have learned to ask for the design wind speed and shape coefficient on every transmission tower enquiry, and to check whether the wall thickness is governed by wind load or by minimum structural thickness. In many cases, the minimum thickness governs, and the wind load is not the critical factor, but in exposed locations or for tall towers, wind load can dominate, and the shape coefficient becomes a critical design parameter.

Reference Value and Outlook

This study provides a solid experimental basis for the shape coefficients of steel pipe transmission towers, and its findings have been incorporated into the design practice for UHV transmission lines in China. However, the study is limited to a single tower type and a single wind environment. Future work should extend the measurements to different tower geometries, including tangent towers, tension towers, and angle towers, as well as to different terrain categories. The effect of surface roughness and attachments also deserves further investigation. For the industry, the practical takeaway is clear: steel pipe towers are efficient and economical structures, but their design requires careful attention to wind directionality and shape coefficients. The 0.80 and 0.85 values recommended in this study should be used as the baseline for design, with adjustments for surface condition and local wind environment as needed. As a supplier, I would rather see a design that is slightly conservative than one that is optimised to the point of risk, because the cost of a tower failure is measured not in tonnes of steel but in lives and in the reliability of the power grid. This study is a valuable contribution to that balance between economy and safety.