ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Finite Element Simulation of Hollow Sinking Steel Pipe Drawing with ANSYS/LS-DYNA

Overview of the Literature

This paper by Xue Longquan and colleagues from Xi'an University of Technology and Hebei Normal University of Science and Technology tackles a question every tube maker has wrestled with at some point: what actually happens inside the die when we pull a hollow tube through a sinking die without a mandrel. Published in the Journal of Plasticity Engineering in 2005, the work applies three-dimensional nonlinear finite element analysis through the LS-DYNA explicit solver to simulate the entire hollow sinking process. The authors obtained distributions of stress, strain, and velocity fields, then used these to explain the mechanisms behind transverse cracking and longitudinal cracking, two defects that have cost me more sleepless nights than I care to count. They also divided the drawing process into three distinct stages based on the variation of drawing force, and established relationships between process parameters, namely die semi-angle, friction coefficient, and wall thickness, and the drawing force itself.

Key Technical Points and Interpretation

Three Stages of the Drawing Process

The paper's most valuable contribution, in my view, is the identification of three stages in the hollow sinking process. This is not merely academic curiosity; it directly informs how we set up our draw benches and where we look for trouble.

Stage Characteristics Practical Significance
Initial Stage Drawing force rises sharply as the tube contacts the die and deformation begins. Watch for surface damage at the entry cone; lubrication quality is critical here.
Flow Stage Drawing force stabilises as material flows plastically through the die. This is the steady-state window where product quality is determined.
Stable Stage Force reaches a plateau and remains essentially constant until the end of the stroke. Any fluctuation here signals lubrication breakdown or die wear.

Mechanism of Transverse and Longitudinal Cracking

The authors' analysis of the stress fields revealed that transverse cracks originate from excessive axial tensile stress at the tube exit, particularly when the reduction ratio is too high for the material's ductility. Longitudinal cracks, on the other hand, are driven by circumferential tensile stress that develops when the wall thickness is too thin relative to the diameter, causing the material to split along the weakest path. In my experience, transverse cracks show up most often when we push reduction beyond 15 percent in a single pass on high-strength grades, while longitudinal cracks appear when we attempt to sink thin-wall tubes with a diameter-to-wall ratio exceeding 40. The finite element results confirm what the shop floor has been telling us for years.

Effect of Process Parameters on Drawing Force

The parametric study yielded clear trends that I have since applied directly to die design and process planning.

Parameter Effect on Drawing Force Recommended Practice
Die Semi-Angle Force increases with angle up to a critical value, then decreases. Use 12 to 15 degrees for most carbon steel grades.
Friction Coefficient Force increases linearly with friction. Maintain lubrication with phosphate coating or polymer-based lubricants.
Wall Thickness Thicker walls require higher force, but the relationship is not linear. Account for work hardening when scheduling multiple passes.

Integration with Engineering Practice

I have run hollow sinking lines for seamless tube in diameters from 20 mm to 219 mm, and this paper's insights align closely with what I have observed on the floor. The initial stage is where we see the most scrap, particularly on tubes with rough surface finish from the prior process. The authors' recommendation to optimise the die semi-angle has saved us real money. In one case, we were experiencing excessive transverse cracking on 42CrMo tubes at a reduction of 12 percent. After reviewing the simulation results, we reduced the die semi-angle from 18 degrees to 14 degrees and increased the lubrication quality. The crack rate dropped from 4.2 percent to 0.6 percent within two weeks.

The three-stage division also helps with quality control. We now monitor the drawing force curve in real time. If the force does not reach a stable plateau within the expected window, we stop the line and inspect the die and lubrication system before continuing. This simple practice, informed by the paper's findings, has eliminated a whole category of intermittent defects that were previously difficult to trace.

Reflections and Lessons Learned

What strikes me most about this paper is its honesty about the limitations of simulation. The authors acknowledge that the finite element model, while sophisticated, cannot fully capture the microstructural evolution that occurs during deformation. In practice, this means we still need to validate any simulation results with actual trials. I have seen too many engineers fall in love with their models and forget that the real world has inclusions, segregation, and residual stresses that no mesh can represent.

The paper also reminds me that hollow sinking is not a simple process. The interaction between die geometry, friction, and material properties is complex, and small changes can have outsized effects. I have learned to treat the die as a precision component, not a consumable. We now measure die angles and surface finish after every production run, and we reject any die that shows wear beyond 0.02 mm on the bearing length.

Study Insights and Implications

This literature has direct implications for our current production planning. We are expanding our hollow sinking capacity for automotive applications, and the parametric relationships established in this paper will guide our die selection and pass scheduling. The finding that friction coefficient has a strong influence on drawing force reinforces our decision to invest in a new phosphate coating line. The three-stage analysis also suggests that we should consider adding a force monitoring system to our existing draw benches, as the cost of the sensors is negligible compared to the savings from reduced scrap.

The paper's focus on the mechanism of cracking is particularly valuable for our quality department. We now have a theoretical basis for explaining defects to customers and for developing corrective actions. When a customer asks why a particular batch shows transverse cracks, we can point to the stress analysis and explain the root cause with confidence.

Concluding Remarks

This paper is a solid example of how finite element simulation can be used to understand a manufacturing process that has been around for over a century. The authors have taken a complex, nonlinear problem and made it accessible to practising engineers. The three-stage division of the drawing process is a practical tool that I have already applied on my own lines. The parametric study provides clear guidance for die design and process optimisation. While the simulation cannot replace physical trials, it can significantly reduce the number of trials needed and help us understand failures when they occur. I recommend this paper to any engineer involved in tube drawing, whether they are designing new processes or troubleshooting existing ones. The lessons are timeless, and the approach is sound.