ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Creep Effects in Super-Large-Span Concrete-Filled Steel Tube Arch Bridges

Overview and Context

This paper addresses one of the most challenging problems in the construction of super-large-span concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) arch bridges: time-dependent creep behavior and the resulting stress redistribution between the steel tube and the concrete core. The authors conducted a 1:2.5 scale model test on the arch rib foot section of a large-span CFST arch bridge, applying a sustained load of 180 t for one year. They also introduced a modified creep coefficient that accounts for the confinement effect of the steel tube, and combined finite element analysis with field measurements from the actual bridge.

From my perspective as a steel pipe professional, CFST arch bridges represent a sophisticated application of steel pipe technology. The steel tube serves as both a structural element and a permanent formwork for the concrete core. The composite action between the steel and concrete is what makes the system efficient, but it also creates complex time-dependent behavior that must be understood for safe and economical design.

Key Findings and Interpretation

The most striking result from the model test is the magnitude of stress redistribution. After one year under sustained load, the load carried by the steel tube increased by 1.2 times, while the load carried by the concrete core decreased by 53%. This is a massive redistribution of internal forces, driven by the creep of the concrete. As the concrete creeps and shortens, it sheds load to the steel tube, which is much stiffer and does not creep.

The study also found that the steel-to-concrete area ratio and the elastic modulus ratio significantly influence the creep coefficient. This is important because it means the creep behavior is not solely a property of the concrete, but depends on the geometric and material properties of the composite section.

Parameter Influence on Creep Coefficient
Steel-to-concrete area ratio Significant, higher ratio reduces creep effect
Elastic modulus ratio (steel/concrete) Significant, higher ratio reduces creep effect
Concrete strength grade Moderate, higher strength reduces creep
Sustained load level Significant, higher load increases creep

The finite element results for steel tube stress showed good agreement with field measurements, both in trend and magnitude. However, the concrete stress predictions from the finite element model did not match the field measurements as well, with the field measurements showing lower stress and even tensile stress in some locations. This discrepancy highlights the difficulty of measuring and predicting stress in confined concrete, which is subjected to a complex triaxial stress state.

Engineering Practice Implications and Lessons Learned

For the steel pipe manufacturer, the implications of this research are clear: the steel tube in a CFST arch bridge is not just a formwork, but a critical load-bearing element that must be designed for the long-term stress state, not just the initial elastic state. The 1.2 times increase in steel tube load after one year means that the tube must have sufficient strength and stability to carry this increased load without yielding or buckling.

In my experience with CFST arch bridge projects, the steel tubes are typically fabricated from high-strength structural steel, often Q345 or Q420, with wall thicknesses ranging from 16 mm to 30 mm for the main arch ribs. The tubes are fabricated in segments, welded together on site, and then filled with concrete using a pumping method from the bottom up. The welding quality is critical, as any defect in the weld could propagate under the high stress levels that develop after creep redistribution.

The finding that concrete stress can become tensile is particularly concerning. Concrete is weak in tension, and if the tensile stress exceeds the tensile strength, cracking may occur. This could compromise the durability and long-term performance of the structure. The authors suggest that the field measurements may be affected by the installation of strain gauges and the complex stress state, but the possibility of tensile stress in the concrete core cannot be ignored.

From a construction perspective, the time-dependent behavior of CFST arches requires careful planning. The sequence of concrete filling, the timing of the removal of temporary supports, and the application of additional dead loads (such as the deck) all affect the final stress state. The creep behavior means that stresses will continue to change for years after construction, and the design must account for this long-term evolution.

Concluding Summary

This study provides valuable insights into the creep behavior of CFST arch bridges, demonstrating that stress redistribution between the steel tube and concrete core is a significant long-term effect that must be considered in design. The steel tube carries substantially more load over time, while the concrete core sheds load, and the concrete may even experience tensile stress. For steel pipe manufacturers, this means the steel tube must be designed for the long-term stress state, not just the initial elastic state, and the welding and fabrication quality must be exceptional to ensure the tube can carry the increased load safely. The discrepancy between finite element predictions and field measurements for concrete stress highlights the need for more research and better instrumentation in real structures.