ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Special-Shaped Multi-Chamber Concrete-Filled Steel Tube Mega-Columns: Eccentric Compression Performance

What This Paper Really Tells Us

This study by Cao Wanlin, Wang Ruwei, Yin Fei, Wang Zhihui and Dong Hongying from Beijing University of Technology reports eccentric compression tests on four large-scale multi-chamber concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) mega-column models, based on the mega-columns of the China Zun Tower in Beijing and the Tianjin 117 Tower. The specimens included one eight-sided thirteen-chamber mega-column model from the China Zun Tower, one eight-sided thirteen-chamber model with round steel tubes in the corner chambers, and two six-sided six-chamber models from the Tianjin 117 Tower. The scale ratios were 1/13 and 1/12, respectively. The authors analysed the damage evolution, bearing capacity, deformation recovery, stiffness and stiffness degradation of the specimens, and then performed theoretical calculations using several national codes and a fibre model method. They also proposed a simplified correction method for calculating the unified compressive strength of multi-chamber CFST columns.

This is the most practical paper of the five, because it deals with real mega-columns from real projects. The China Zun Tower and the Tianjin 117 Tower are two of the tallest buildings in China, and their mega-columns are among the largest structural elements ever fabricated. The multi-chamber design is a response to the need for high axial load capacity and high flexural stiffness in a compact footprint.

From a fabricator's perspective, the multi-chamber mega-column is a fabrication challenge of the highest order. You have a large steel tube with internal partitions that divide it into multiple chambers, and each chamber is filled with concrete. The partitions must be welded to the outer tube with full penetration welds, and the concrete must be placed in each chamber separately. The welding sequence is critical, because the heat input from welding the partitions can distort the outer tube.

What the Shop Floor Cares About

The first thing I would ask a fabricator making a multi-chamber mega-column is how they are welding the internal partitions to the outer tube. In the China Zun Tower, the mega-columns have thirteen chambers, which means twelve internal partitions. Each partition must be welded to the outer tube, and the weld must be full penetration to ensure that the chambers are properly separated.

The problem is that the internal partitions create a closed box, and the welds are not accessible from the inside. The fabricator must use a one-sided welding process, such as gas metal arc welding with a ceramic backing, or a two-sided welding process with access holes. The one-sided welding process is more efficient, but it requires a high level of welder skill and a strict quality control regime.

The paper's finding that the eight-sided thirteen-chamber specimen with round steel tubes in the corner chambers performed better than the specimen without the round tubes is important for fabrication. The round tubes in the corner chambers provide additional confinement to the concrete and improve the ductility of the column. However, the round tubes are difficult to fabricate and to weld in place, and they increase the cost of the column.

I would also note that the paper's tests were conducted on specimens with a scale ratio of 1/13 and 1/12, which means that the wall thickness of the steel tubes in the specimens was much thinner than in the real mega-columns. This is a significant limitation, because the behaviour of a thin-walled steel tube is different from that of a thick-walled steel tube. In particular, local buckling is more likely in a thin-walled tube, and the confinement effect is different.

Practical Lessons and Reflections

The most valuable part of this paper is the simplified correction method for calculating the unified compressive strength of multi-chamber CFST columns. The authors propose a modification to the method in GB 50936, based on the Han Linhai constitutive model, that accounts for the multi-chamber configuration. This is a practical tool that designers can use to size multi-chamber mega-columns quickly.

However, I would caution against using the simplified method for the design of mega-columns in supertall buildings. The method was developed based on tests on small-scale specimens, and the real mega-columns are much larger. The behaviour of a mega-column with a 1.5 m outer tube and a 50 mm wall thickness is different from that of a specimen with a 120 mm outer tube and a 4 mm wall thickness.

The paper's finding that the eccentricity ratio has a significant effect on the bearing capacity is consistent with my experience. For a mega-column in a supertall building, the eccentricity is typically small, because the column is primarily axially loaded. However, under seismic loading, the eccentricity can increase significantly, and the column must be designed for the maximum eccentricity.

I would also note that the paper's tests were conducted under monotonic loading, not under cyclic loading. This is a limitation, because mega-columns in supertall buildings are subjected to cyclic loading during earthquakes. The behaviour of a multi-chamber CFST column under cyclic loading may be different from its behaviour under monotonic loading, and this should be investigated in future research.

Key Questions and Engineering Judgment

The paper raises an important question: what is the optimal configuration for a multi-chamber mega-column? The answer depends on the loading conditions and the architectural requirements. For a column that is primarily axially loaded, a configuration with more chambers may be beneficial because it provides more confinement to the concrete. For a column that is primarily subjected to bending, a configuration with fewer chambers may be better because it provides more flexural stiffness.

From my experience, the configuration of a multi-chamber mega-column should be chosen based on the ratio of the axial load to the bending moment. If the column is primarily axially loaded, a configuration with more chambers is better. If the column is primarily subjected to bending, a configuration with fewer chambers may be acceptable.

The paper's finding that the round steel tubes in the corner chambers improve the performance of the column is important for design. The round tubes provide additional confinement to the concrete in the corners, which is where the concrete is most likely to crush under eccentric loading. However, the round tubes are expensive to fabricate, and the cost-benefit ratio should be evaluated for each project.

Study Insights and Implications for Practice

This paper provides valuable insights into the behaviour of multi-chamber CFST mega-columns, and it fills an important gap in the literature. The simplified correction method proposed by the authors is a practical tool for designers, and it should be adopted in design codes.

However, I would emphasise that the fabrication of multi-chamber mega-columns requires a level of quality control that is higher than for conventional CFST columns. The internal partitions must be welded with full penetration welds, the concrete must be placed in each chamber separately, and the welding sequence must be carefully planned to avoid distortion.

For the practising engineer, the practical takeaway is to use the paper's simplified method as a starting point, but to validate it with a more sophisticated numerical model or with full-scale testing for critical applications. The multi-chamber mega-column is a promising structural form for supertall buildings, but it requires a high level of engineering judgment and quality control.

Reference Value and Outlook

This paper is a valuable contribution to the CFST literature, and it provides useful guidance for both designers and fabricators. The combination of experimental testing and theoretical analysis is the right approach, and the simplified correction method is a significant contribution.

The main limitation of the paper is that the tests were conducted on small-scale specimens, and the results may not extrapolate directly to full-scale mega-columns. Future research should focus on full-scale tests, on the behaviour of multi-chamber CFST columns under cyclic loading, and on the effects of concrete shrinkage and creep.

In my view, the most important practical contribution of this paper is the confirmation that multi-chamber CFST mega-columns are a viable structural form for supertall buildings. The next time I see a project with a supertall building, I will consider the multi-chamber CFST mega-column as a design option, and I will insist that the fabrication is carried out with the highest level of quality control.