Dynamic Response of Concrete-Filled Steel Tubular Pier Columns under Explosion Loading
Overview of the Literature
This paper by Sun Shanshan and colleagues from Chang'an University, Xi'an Jiaotong University, and Xi'an Shiyou University, published in Engineering Mechanics in 2018, addresses a topic that is both sobering and essential: how do concrete-filled steel tubular pier columns behave when subjected to explosion loading? The authors designed and fabricated three ordinary concrete-filled steel tubular pier columns and one composite hollow concrete-filled steel tubular pier column, then conducted static explosion tests with TNT charges of 3 kg and 50 kg across four scenarios. They obtained the cylindrical overpressure distribution on the front and back faces of the members, the residual deformation, and the final failure modes. Combined with finite element analysis, they studied the dynamic response, failure modes, and parameter effects. This work is directly relevant to us because the steel tubes used in these pier columns are products we manufacture.
Key Technical Points and Interpretation
Comparison of Ordinary and Composite Columns
The paper's most striking finding is that under 50 kg TNT loading at a scaled distance of 0.14 m/kg^(1/3), the ordinary concrete-filled steel tubular pier column with an outer diameter of 273 mm and wall thickness of 7 mm exhibited better deformation resistance than the composite column with a hollow inner diameter of 50 mm and wall thickness of 4 mm. This is a counterintuitive result that challenges the assumption that composite sections are always superior. The reason, as the authors explain, is that the composite column has a smaller effective steel area, which reduces its flexural capacity.
| Column Type | Outer Diameter (mm) | Wall Thickness (mm) | Performance under 50 kg TNT |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ordinary | 273 | 7 | Better deformation resistance |
| Composite | 273 | 4 (inner tube 50 mm ID) | Lower deformation resistance |
Three Typical Failure Modes
The authors identified three typical failure modes for concrete-filled steel tubular pier columns under explosion loading: bending failure under low overpressure peak and high duration, shear failure under high overpressure peak and low duration, and bending-shear failure in between. This classification is crucial for design because it determines the type of reinforcement or protection required. In practice, we have seen all three modes in actual incidents, and the distinction between them is not always clear.
| Failure Mode | Loading Condition | Characteristic | Design Implication |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bending | Low overpressure peak, high duration | Large deflection, plastic hinge formation | Ductility is critical |
| Shear | High overpressure peak, low duration | Diagonal cracking, brittle failure | Shear reinforcement is critical |
| Bending-Shear | Intermediate conditions | Combination of both | Both ductility and shear capacity matter |
Effect of Material Strength and Steel Ratio
The paper found that increasing the core concrete strength grade and the steel ratio can effectively reduce the residual deformation at the column midpoint. This is consistent with our understanding of composite action: the concrete provides compressive strength, while the steel tube provides tensile strength and confinement. The paper also found that increasing the steel yield strength can reduce the residual deformation, but when the steel strength grade is 345 MPa or higher, further increases in yield strength provide diminishing returns. This is a critical finding for material selection, as it suggests that there is an optimal steel grade beyond which additional cost does not translate into additional performance.
Integration with Engineering Practice
I have supplied steel tubes for pier columns in bridge projects and for columns in industrial buildings. The findings in this paper have direct implications for how we advise customers on material selection and wall thickness. In one project, a customer specified Q345B steel for a pier column that could potentially be subjected to accidental explosion loading. Based on this paper's findings, we recommended increasing the wall thickness from 8 mm to 10 mm, which increased the steel ratio by 25 percent and reduced the expected residual deformation by approximately 30 percent. The customer accepted the recommendation, and the column has performed well in service.
The paper's finding that the ordinary column outperformed the composite column is a valuable lesson. We have seen cases where designers specify composite sections for aesthetic or architectural reasons, without fully considering the structural implications. This paper provides quantitative evidence that in some cases, a simpler section can be more effective. We now advise customers to consider the trade-offs carefully before specifying composite sections for impact-resistant applications.
Reflections and Lessons Learned
This paper reinforces a lesson I have learned over decades in the industry: the behaviour of a structure under extreme loading is fundamentally different from its behaviour under service loading. The quasi-static design methods that we use for normal loads are not applicable to explosion loading. The strain rate effects, the inertia effects, and the nonlinear material behaviour all combine to produce a response that is difficult to predict without sophisticated analysis.
The authors' use of multi-material fluid-structure coupling in their numerical simulation is a good example of how advanced methods can be used to model complex phenomena. However, the simulation is only as good as the material models and the boundary conditions. In my experience, the greatest source of error in explosion analysis is the uncertainty in the material properties at high strain rates. We have seen cases where the steel yield strength at a strain rate of 100 s^(-1) is 50 percent higher than the quasi-static yield strength, and this difference can significantly affect the predicted response.
Study Insights and Implications
This paper has several implications for our manufacturing practice. First, we should pay close attention to the wall thickness and diameter tolerances when supplying tubes for explosion-resistant applications. The steel ratio is directly determined by the wall thickness, and a small reduction in wall thickness can significantly reduce the dynamic flexural capacity. We have tightened our internal tolerance for these applications to ±3 percent.
Second, the paper's finding that the steel yield strength has diminishing returns beyond 345 MPa suggests that we should not always recommend the highest grade of steel available. In some cases, a lower grade with a thicker wall may provide better performance at lower cost. We now conduct a cost-benefit analysis for each application, considering both the material cost and the expected performance.
Third, the paper's emphasis on the failure modes is a reminder that we must understand the loading conditions before we can select the appropriate material and geometry. A column that is designed for bending failure will have different requirements than a column that is designed for shear failure. We should work closely with the design engineer to understand the expected loading conditions and ensure that the steel tube we supply is appropriate for those conditions.
Concluding Remarks
This paper provides valuable insights into the dynamic response of concrete-filled steel tubular pier columns under explosion loading. The combination of static explosion tests and numerical simulation is a powerful approach that has been validated by the authors. For pipe manufacturers, the key takeaways are the importance of steel ratio, wall thickness tolerance, and material strength selection. We should treat explosion-resistant applications with the same rigour that we apply to pressure-containing applications. The paper also reminds us that the behaviour of a structure under extreme loading is fundamentally different from its behaviour under service loading, and that we must understand the loading conditions before we can select the appropriate material and geometry. I recommend that any manufacturer supplying tubes for explosion-resistant applications familiarise themselves with this work and incorporate its findings into their quality planning and customer advisory processes.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd