ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Seismic Performance of Concrete-Filled Steel Tube Diagonal Grid Tube Structures

1. Introduction and Structural Concept

This paper by Shi Qingxuan and colleagues from Xi'an University of Architecture and Technology examines the seismic performance of a CFST diagonal grid tube structure, which is a type of structural system used in high-rise buildings. The diagonal grid tube consists of a series of diagonal members arranged in a grid pattern around the perimeter of the building, with the vertical and diagonal members being CFST columns.

The paper uses PERFORM-3D, a nonlinear analysis software, to perform both static pushover analysis and dynamic time-history analysis. The authors investigate the yield path, lateral displacement, inter-story drift ratio, shear lag effect, and damage distribution of the diagonal members.

From my perspective as a pipe engineer, this paper is particularly interesting because it addresses the performance of the steel tube under seismic loading. The diagonal members are subjected to a combination of axial compression, bending, and shear, and they must be designed to withstand these loads without buckling or fracturing.

2. Key Findings and Their Implications

2.1 Load Transfer Path and Stiffness

The paper reports that the CFST diagonal grid tube structure has a clear load transfer path and a large lateral stiffness. The diagonal members act as the primary lateral load-resisting system, and they transfer the load to the foundation through the vertical members.

The paper also reports that the main and secondary nodes effectively balance the internal forces in the diagonal members, so that the deformation of the node layers is smaller than that of the non-node layers. This is an important finding, because it means that the nodes are not the weak link in the structure. In my experience, the nodes are often the most critical part of a diagonal grid structure, and they must be designed to withstand the concentrated forces from the diagonal members.

2.2 Shear Lag Effect

The paper reports that the shear lag ratio in the diagonal grid tube structure changes from positive to negative as the height of the structure increases. This is a significant finding, because it means that the distribution of stress across the width of the tube is not uniform. In a conventional tube structure, the shear lag effect is always positive, meaning that the stress is highest at the corners and lowest in the middle. In a diagonal grid tube, the shear lag effect can become negative, meaning that the stress is highest in the middle and lowest at the corners.

This has implications for the design of the diagonal members. The members in the middle of the tube may be more highly stressed than those at the corners, and they may need to be larger or made of a higher strength material.

The paper also reports that the location of the first negative shear lag moves downward as the structure develops plastic deformation. This means that the distribution of stress changes as the structure is loaded, and the design must account for this.

2.3 Damage Distribution

The paper reports that the damage to the diagonal members is influenced by the type of earthquake and the acceleration amplitude, but the damage distribution pattern is relatively insensitive to these parameters. This means that the structure has a consistent failure mode, which is important for design.

The damage is concentrated in the lower stories of the structure, which is consistent with the expected behavior of a high-rise building. The diagonal members in the lower stories are subjected to the highest axial forces and the largest bending moments, and they are the first to yield.

3. Manufacturing and Welding Considerations for Diagonal Grid Tube Structures

3.1 The Challenge of Welding Diagonal Members

The diagonal members in a grid tube structure are typically welded to the vertical members at the nodes. The welding is complex, because the diagonal members are at an angle to the vertical members, and the weld geometry is not a simple butt joint.

From my experience, the most common problem with welding diagonal members is the fit-up. The angle of the diagonal member must be precisely cut, and the gap between the diagonal and the vertical member must be within tolerance. If the fit-up is poor, the weld will be either underfilled or overfilled, and the stress concentration may lead to premature failure.

The solution is to use a CNC cutting machine to prepare the ends of the diagonal members, and to use a jig to hold the members in position during welding. I have seen this done successfully on several projects, and the key is to invest in the jigs and fixtures.

3.2 The Importance of Node Design

The nodes in a diagonal grid tube structure are the most critical part of the structure. They must transfer the forces from the diagonal members to the vertical members, and they must be designed to withstand the concentrated stresses at the junction.

The paper reports that the main and secondary nodes effectively balance the internal forces in the diagonal members, but this depends on the design of the node. In my experience, the most common node design is a welded connection with a gusset plate or a stiffener. The gusset plate is welded to the vertical member, and the diagonal member is welded to the gusset plate.

The welding of the gusset plate to the vertical member is critical. The weld must be a full-penetration weld, and it must be inspected with ultrasonic testing. The weld between the diagonal member and the gusset plate is also critical, and it must be designed to withstand the axial force and the bending moment in the diagonal member.

3.3 The Effect of Welding Residual Stresses

The welding of the diagonal members to the vertical members creates residual stresses in the tube wall. These residual stresses can reduce the buckling capacity of the diagonal members, and they can also lead to premature fatigue cracking under cyclic loading.

From my experience, the most effective way to reduce the residual stresses is to use a welding sequence that minimizes the distortion. The diagonal members should be welded in a balanced sequence, and the heat input should be controlled.

I also recommend stress relief heat treatment for the nodes, if the tube wall is thick enough. This is not always practical, but it can be effective in reducing the residual stresses.

3.4 Non-Destructive Testing of the Nodes

The nodes in a diagonal grid tube structure must be inspected with non-destructive testing. I recommend 100% ultrasonic testing of the welds, and I also recommend magnetic particle testing of the weld toes to detect surface cracks.

The inspection must be performed by qualified personnel, and the results must be documented. I have seen projects where the inspection was not performed properly, and the defects were not detected until the structure was loaded. This is a serious problem, and it can lead to a catastrophic failure.

4. Engineering Practice Insights

4.1 The Importance of the Construction Sequence

The construction sequence of a diagonal grid tube structure is critical. The diagonal members must be erected in a specific order, and the welding must be performed in a sequence that minimizes the distortion.

From my experience, the most common problem is that the diagonal members are erected before the vertical members are fully welded. This can lead to a misalignment, and the weld may not be able to accommodate the gap.

The solution is to erect the vertical members first, and to weld them completely before the diagonal members are erected. The diagonal members should then be erected and welded in a balanced sequence.

4.2 The Delivery and Logistics of Diagonal Members

The diagonal members are often long and heavy, and they are difficult to transport. They must be delivered to site in sections, and the sections must be welded together on site.

The welding of the diagonal members on site is a challenge, because the members are at an angle, and the weld is in a difficult position. I recommend using a welding procedure that is qualified for the specific position, and I recommend using a skilled welder who has experience with this type of weld.

4.3 The Cost of the Structure

The diagonal grid tube structure is more expensive than a conventional tube structure, because the diagonal members require more material and more welding. The cost of the structure must be weighed against the benefits, which include a larger lateral stiffness and a better seismic performance.

From my experience, the diagonal grid tube structure is most cost-effective for tall buildings with a height of more than 200 m. For shorter buildings, the cost may not be justified.

5. Concluding Remarks and Recommendations

This paper provides a valuable contribution to the understanding of the seismic performance of CFST diagonal grid tube structures. The authors have used advanced analysis tools to investigate the behavior of the structure, and they have identified the key factors that govern the performance.

The findings are consistent with my experience. The diagonal grid tube structure has a clear load transfer path and a large lateral stiffness, and the nodes effectively balance the internal forces in the diagonal members. The shear lag effect is complex, and it changes from positive to negative as the height of the structure increases.

My recommendation to fellow engineers is to consider this structural system for tall buildings, but to be aware of the manufacturing and welding challenges. The nodes are the most critical part of the structure, and they must be designed and fabricated with great care.

The practical lessons from this paper are clear. The welding of the diagonal members must be performed with a qualified procedure, and the fit-up must be within tolerance. The nodes must be designed to withstand the concentrated forces, and they must be inspected with non-destructive testing.

In summary, this paper provides a solid basis for the design of CFST diagonal grid tube structures, and it highlights the key issues that must be addressed. I would recommend it to any engineer involved in the design or construction of high-rise buildings, but I would also recommend that they keep in mind the practical considerations that I have outlined above.