Equivalent Static Method for CFST Arch Bridges Considering Hanger Rupture
1. Background on Hanger Rupture and Structural Robustness
This paper by Chen Kangming et al. from Fuzhou University addresses a critical issue in bridge engineering: the sudden rupture of a hanger in a concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) arch bridge. Hangers are the tension members that connect the deck to the arch. If a hanger breaks, the remaining structure must be able to redistribute the load without collapsing. This is a robustness issue, and it is a topic that I have seen discussed in many engineering meetings. The authors propose a simplified equivalent static method that uses a dynamic coefficient to account for the dynamic effects of the rupture. This is a very practical approach, as it allows engineers to perform a static analysis with a load amplification factor, rather than a complex nonlinear dynamic analysis.
2. Experimental and Numerical Study
The authors designed and fabricated a large-scale (20m span) model of a through-type CFST arch bridge. They developed an electromagnetic trigger device to simulate a sudden hanger rupture within 0.1 seconds. This is a clever experimental setup that accurately simulates the real event. They also developed a finite element model using ANSYS/LS-DYNA to compare with the experimental results. The key findings are summarized below.
| Parameter | Observed Effect |
|---|---|
| Hanger rupture location | Long hangers have a greater effect on the longitudinal beam and arch rib displacement and stress. |
| Second-shortest hanger | Has the greatest effect on the adjacent hanger forces. |
| Effect on longitudinal beam | Much greater than the effect on the arch rib. |
The finding that the longitudinal beam is more affected than the arch rib is intuitive, as the beam is the direct load path. The finding that the second-shortest hanger has a significant effect on adjacent hanger forces is interesting and suggests that this location is critical for the redistribution of load. The authors then used the validated finite element model to analyze 11 different bridge models with varying spans. They determined the dynamic coefficient for each case.
3. Proposed Equivalent Static Method and Its Application
The authors propose a simple method: the static effect of the hanger rupture is multiplied by a dynamic coefficient to obtain the equivalent static effect. The recommended values are shown below.
| Bridge Type | Component | Recommended Dynamic Coefficient |
|---|---|---|
| Mid-supported CFST arch bridge | Longitudinal beam | 1.8 |
| Mid-supported CFST arch bridge | Hangers | 1.8 |
| Through-type CFST arch bridge | Longitudinal beam | 1.8 |
| Through-type CFST arch bridge | Hangers | 1.7 |
This is a very practical result. The dynamic coefficient of 1.8 for the longitudinal beam is consistent across both bridge types, which simplifies the design process. The coefficient for the hangers is slightly lower for the through-type bridge, which is a useful refinement. The equivalent static method allows engineers to perform a simple static analysis with an amplified load, rather than a complex dynamic analysis. This is a significant simplification that will save time and effort in the design office.
4. Design Implications and Practical Guidance
From a design perspective, the use of a dynamic coefficient of 1.8 means that the remaining structure must be designed to resist 1.8 times the static effect of a hanger rupture. This is a significant load increase, and it has implications for the design of the longitudinal beam and the adjacent hangers. The finding that the second-shortest hanger is critical suggests that this location should be given special attention in the design. The paper also highlights the importance of redundancy in the hanger system. If a single hanger can be lost without causing collapse, the structure is robust. However, if the loss of one hanger leads to the failure of adjacent hangers, the structure is vulnerable. This is a classic progressive collapse scenario, and the design must prevent it. The equivalent static method is a valuable tool for checking this.
5. Conclusion
This study provides a practical and efficient method for analyzing the response of CFST arch bridges to hanger rupture. The proposed equivalent static method, with dynamic coefficients of 1.8 for the longitudinal beam and 1.7 to 1.8 for the hangers, is a significant simplification that will be of great value to practicing engineers. The experimental and numerical results provide valuable insights into the dynamic response of these structures, highlighting the critical role of the longitudinal beam and the second-shortest hanger. I recommend this paper to anyone involved in the design or assessment of CFST arch bridges. It is a reminder that the steel pipe industry must consider not just the initial design, but also the accidental and extreme events that can occur during the life of a structure. The robustness of the structure is a key design criterion, and this paper provides a valuable tool for achieving it.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd