Flexural Bearing Capacity of Flange Connections in Steel Tube Structures: Lessons from the Test Lab and the Shop Floor
Overview of the Study
This paper by Wang Yuanqing, Zong Liang, and Shi Yongjiu from Tsinghua University examines the flexural bearing capacity of flange connections in steel tube structures. Four basic types of flange connections were tested under four-point bending, with strain gauges installed on the bolts to measure the forces in the bolts during the loading process. The yield and ultimate loads were obtained, and the results were compared with finite element analyses. This is a topic that is close to my heart because flange connections are used extensively in steel pipe structures, from transmission towers to industrial pipe racks, and their performance under bending is often not well understood. The paper focuses on the prying force, which is the additional force that develops in the bolts when the flange plate deforms and acts as a lever.
Key Technical Findings and Interpretation
The most important finding is that prying forces are present in the tension zone of the flange connection, and that they are smaller in rigid flange connections than in flexible ones. This is a fundamental result. A rigid flange has a thicker plate or a smaller bolt spacing, which reduces the deformation of the flange and thus the prying effect. A flexible flange, in contrast, deforms more, and the bolts are subjected to a larger prying force. The safety factor of the flange connection was found to be approximately 1.2, meaning that the ultimate load is about 20 percent higher than the yield load. This is a relatively small safety margin, and it suggests that the design should not rely on a large reserve of capacity beyond yield. The authors also found that the finite element results agreed well with the test results, which gives confidence in the numerical model. The prying force is a critical factor in the design of flange connections because it increases the bolt force beyond the applied tension. If the prying force is not accounted for, the bolts may be under-designed, and the connection may fail prematurely.
Manufacturing and Delivery Implications
From a pipe manufacturer's perspective, the flange connection is a key component that must be manufactured with precision. The flange plate is typically forged or rolled from a steel plate, and the bolt holes are drilled or punched. The bolt hole tolerance is critical. If the holes are too large, the bolts will not fit properly, and the prying force will be distributed unevenly. If the holes are too small, the bolts may not fit at all. The standard tolerance for bolt holes is typically 1.5 mm to 2 mm larger than the bolt diameter, but for high-strength bolts, the tolerance is tighter. The flange plate thickness is another critical parameter. The paper shows that a thicker plate reduces the prying force, which means that the bolts are less loaded and the connection is more efficient. However, a thicker plate also increases the cost and the weight. The surface finish of the flange plate is important for the friction between the flange and the tube. If the surface is rough, the friction is higher, and the prying force is reduced. If the surface is smooth, the friction is lower, and the prying force is higher. The welding between the flange and the tube is also critical. The weld must be full penetration to ensure that the flange acts as a continuous member. A partial penetration weld will create a stress concentration at the weld root, which can lead to fatigue failure under cyclic loading.
Common Defects and Countermeasures
The most common defect in flange connections is the misalignment of the bolt holes. This occurs when the flange is welded to the tube and the heat from the welding causes distortion. The flange may warp, and the bolt holes may no longer be aligned. The countermeasure is to use a welding jig that holds the flange in position during welding, and to perform the welding in a sequence that minimizes distortion. Another defect is the lack of full penetration in the weld between the flange and the tube. This can be detected using ultrasonic testing or radiography. The countermeasure is to use a suitable welding procedure with a proper bevel preparation and to ensure that the welder is qualified for the position. A third defect is the corrosion of the flange plate and the bolts. The flange connection is typically exposed to the atmosphere, and if it is not protected, it will corrode. The countermeasure is to apply a coating system, and to use galvanized or stainless steel bolts in aggressive environments.
Engineering Practice Cases
I recall a project in the Middle East where a series of steel tube columns for a pipe rack were connected using flanges. The flanges were welded to the tubes in the shop, and the connections were bolted on site. During the erection, several bolts could not be inserted because the holes were misaligned. The contractor had to ream the holes on site, which weakened the flange plate. The lesson was that the welding distortion must be controlled, and that the bolt holes should be drilled after welding, not before. This is a common practice in the industry: drill the holes after the flange is welded to the tube, using a template or a CNC machine. Another case involved a flange connection that failed during a hydrostatic test. The bolts were not tightened to the specified preload, and the prying force caused the bolts to yield. The connection leaked, and the test had to be aborted. The lesson was that the bolt preload must be carefully controlled, and that the tightening sequence must be specified.
Key Questions and Reflections
The paper does not address the effect of bolt preload on the prying force. In practice, the bolts are tightened to a specified preload, which creates a clamping force between the flanges. This clamping force reduces the prying force because it increases the stiffness of the connection. The authors' tests were performed with a specific preload, but the effect of varying the preload was not studied. The paper also does not address the effect of the gasket. In many applications, a gasket is placed between the flanges to ensure a tight seal. The gasket affects the stiffness of the connection and thus the prying force. The authors' tests were performed without a gasket, which is typical for structural connections but not for piping connections. From a standards perspective, the design of flange connections is covered by various codes, such as ASME B16.5 for piping flanges and AISC 360 for structural connections. However, the prying force is often not explicitly accounted for in the design equations, and the engineer must use a separate method to calculate it.
Study Insights and Implications
The key insight from this study is that the prying force is a significant factor in the design of flange connections, and that it must be accounted for to ensure the safety of the connection. The safety factor of 1.2 is relatively small, which means that the design must be accurate. For the pipe industry, this reinforces the importance of manufacturing flanges with precision and of controlling the welding distortion. The flange plate thickness and the bolt spacing are the two main parameters that determine the prying force, and they must be selected based on the expected load and the stiffness of the connection.
Reference Value and Outlook
This paper is a valuable contribution to the field of steel structure design. It provides experimental data on the prying force in flange connections, and it validates a finite element model that can be used for design. However, the scope of the study is limited to four basic types of flange connections, and the effect of bolt preload, gasket, and cyclic loading is not addressed. For the industry, the outlook is that flange connections will continue to be used extensively in steel tube structures, and we need to develop better design methods that account for the prying force and the stiffness of the connection.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd