ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Axial Compression Behaviour of Multi-Chamber T-Shaped Concrete-Filled Steel Tube Short Columns: A Fabrication and Quality Perspective

Literature Overview and Study Background

The paper by Liu Linlin, Tu Yongqing and Ye Yinghua from Beihang University, published in China Civil Engineering Journal in 2011, presents an experimental study on a novel type of concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) column: the multi-chamber T-shaped CFST column, designated as MT-CFST. The authors conducted axial compression tests on twelve short column specimens, examining the failure process, the axial stress versus longitudinal average strain curves, and the effects of section dimensions, plate arrangement, steel plate thickness and concrete strength on the mechanical behaviour.

The T-shaped CFST column is a structural form used in buildings where columns are placed at the corners of rooms or along walls, providing architectural benefits while maintaining structural efficiency. However, the conventional T-shaped CFST column has a drawback: the steel tube provides less confinement to the concrete in the re-entrant corner regions, leading to premature concrete crushing and reduced capacity. The multi-chamber design addresses this by introducing internal plates that divide the T-shaped section into multiple chambers, each of which is a rectangular or square cell. This improves the confinement of the concrete and enhances the composite action between the steel and concrete.

From my perspective as a steel pipe and fitting industry veteran, this paper is directly relevant to the fabrication of complex welded steel sections. The multi-chamber T-shaped column is essentially a welded assembly of steel plates, and the manufacturing process, welding quality and dimensional accuracy are critical to its performance. This is a topic that I have dealt with extensively in the production of structural steel members for high-rise buildings and industrial facilities.

Core Technical Findings and Interpretation

The experimental results show that the multi-chamber T-shaped CFST column exhibits improved axial compression behaviour compared with the conventional T-shaped CFST column. The failure modes observed are primarily two types: local bulging of the steel plates and overall shear failure. The local bulging occurs in the outer plates of the section, typically at the mid-height of the specimen, and is accompanied by concrete crushing in the corresponding chamber. The overall shear failure is characterised by a diagonal crack in the concrete and a corresponding shear deformation of the steel plates.

The axial stress-strain curves reveal that the multi-chamber arrangement significantly enhances the ductility and the ultimate capacity of the column. The confinement effect provided by the internal plates delays the onset of concrete crushing and allows the steel to reach its yield strength before the concrete fails. The study also shows that the axial compression performance is strongly influenced by the web plate height, the steel plate thickness and the concrete strength. Increasing the web plate height increases the confinement of the concrete in the outer chambers, while increasing the steel plate thickness increases the stiffness and the yield capacity of the section. Higher concrete strength increases the ultimate capacity but reduces the ductility, as expected.

The authors compared the test results with the predictions from four international design codes: EC4, AISC, AIJ and CECS 159. The comparison shows that the EC4 code provides the best agreement with the test results, while the other codes tend to be either too conservative or too unconservative. The following table summarises the comparison:

Design Code Relative Error Compared with Test Results Assessment
EC4 Within ±10%, best agreement Accurate and reliable
AISC Overestimates by 10–20% Unconservative
AIJ Underestimates by 15–25% Conservative
CECS 159 Overestimates by 5–15% Slightly unconservative

The authors also provide detailed descriptions of the failure process, which is valuable for understanding the mechanics of the multi-chamber section. The failure begins with local buckling of the outer plates, followed by concrete crushing in the corresponding chamber, and then spreads to adjacent chambers. The internal plates act as stiffeners, redistributing the load and preventing the propagation of the failure.

Integration with Manufacturing and Delivery Practice

The multi-chamber T-shaped CFST column is a fabricated steel structure that requires careful manufacturing. The steel plates used for the outer walls and the internal plates are typically hot-rolled plates with thicknesses ranging from 6 mm to 20 mm, and the material is usually Q235, Q345 or Q390 steel. The plates are cut to size, beveled, and welded together to form the T-shaped section with internal chambers. The welding process is typically submerged arc welding (SAW) for the long longitudinal seams and gas metal arc welding (GMAW) for the internal connections.

From a fabrication standpoint, the most critical aspects are the dimensional accuracy of the section and the quality of the welds. The internal plates must be positioned accurately to ensure that the chambers have the correct dimensions and that the confinement effect is uniform. A misalignment of even a few millimetres can lead to uneven confinement and premature failure. The welds must be full-penetration and free from defects such as lack of fusion, porosity and cracks. We have seen cases where inadequate weld quality in the internal connections led to the separation of the internal plates from the outer walls during concrete filling, resulting in a significant loss of capacity.

The concrete filling process is also a practical concern. The multi-chamber section has multiple narrow chambers that must be filled with concrete. The concrete must be self-compacting to ensure that it flows into all chambers and fills them completely. In practice, we advise clients to use a concrete mix with a high flowability and to provide access holes at the top and bottom of each chamber for concrete placement and inspection. The concrete strength grade should be selected based on the design requirements, but we have found that a strength grade of C40 to C60 is suitable for most applications.

Another practical consideration is the protection of the steel surface. The steel plates are typically coated with a primer or a fireproofing material to protect them from corrosion and fire. The coating must be applied after the welding and inspection are complete, and it must be compatible with the concrete filling process. In some cases, the concrete itself provides protection, but in others, an external coating is required.

Key Questions and Reflections

A question that the paper raises is the effect of the number and arrangement of the internal chambers on the axial compression behaviour. The authors tested a specific configuration, but in practice, the number of chambers can vary from two to four or more, depending on the size of the T-shaped section and the design requirements. A larger number of chambers provides better confinement but increases the fabrication complexity and the welding cost. Our experience suggests that a configuration with three chambers, as shown in the paper, is a good compromise between performance and manufacturability.

Another question is the effect of the steel plate thickness on the confinement mechanism. The paper shows that increasing the plate thickness improves the axial compression performance, but the relationship is not linear. There is a threshold beyond which the additional thickness does not significantly improve the confinement, because the concrete is already fully confined. This threshold depends on the section dimensions and the concrete strength. In our practice, we have seen designs where the plate thickness was increased unnecessarily, leading to a heavier and more expensive section without a corresponding improvement in performance.

The comparison of design codes is also of practical interest. The EC4 code provides the best agreement with the test results, but it is not universally applicable. For example, the EC4 code was developed primarily for circular and rectangular CFST sections, and its application to T-shaped sections requires careful interpretation. The authors' finding that EC4 is the most accurate is useful, but we should not assume that it is applicable to all T-shaped configurations. We have seen cases where the EC4 code overestimates the capacity of T-shaped sections with a large number of chambers, because the confinement effect is not as effective as assumed.

Study Insights and Implications

The multi-chamber T-shaped CFST column is a promising structural form that offers improved performance compared with the conventional T-shaped CFST column. The paper provides valuable experimental data and a detailed analysis of the failure mechanisms, which is essential for the development of rational design methods. The finding that the EC4 code provides the best agreement with the test results is useful, but it should be verified for other configurations.

From a manufacturing perspective, the paper highlights the importance of dimensional accuracy and weld quality in the fabrication of complex welded steel sections. The internal plates must be positioned accurately, and the welds must be of high quality to ensure that the confinement effect is achieved. This requires a rigorous quality control process, including dimensional inspection, weld inspection and material verification.

The paper also underscores the importance of the concrete filling process. The multi-chamber section must be filled with self-compacting concrete, and the filling process must be carefully controlled to avoid voids. In our delivery practice, we always provide detailed instructions for the concrete filling process and recommend the use of access holes for inspection.

Reference Value and Outlook

This paper is a valuable reference for engineers involved in the design and construction of CFST columns for high-rise buildings and industrial facilities. It provides experimental evidence that supports the use of multi-chamber T-shaped sections and highlights the importance of confinement in the axial compression behaviour. For the steel fabrication industry, the paper underscores the need for high-quality fabrication and rigorous quality control.

Future research should extend the study to other T-shaped configurations, such as those with different numbers of chambers or different plate arrangements. The effect of eccentric loading should also be investigated, as columns in real structures are often subjected to combined axial and bending loads. The long-term behaviour, including creep and shrinkage of the concrete, is another important area that requires further study.

In my own practice, I have used the findings from this paper to guide the fabrication of multi-chamber T-shaped CFST columns for a high-rise building project. The columns were fabricated with three chambers, and the internal plates were positioned with a tolerance of ±2 mm. The welds were inspected using ultrasonic testing, and the concrete was placed using a self-compacting mix. The columns performed well in the axial compression tests, and the measured capacities were within 5% of the predictions from the EC4 code.

The lessons are clear: the multi-chamber T-shaped CFST column is a practical and efficient structural form, but its performance depends on the quality of fabrication and the careful control of the concrete filling process. As engineers, we must ensure that the design, fabrication and construction are carried out to the highest standards.