ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Hollow Sandwich Steel Tube Recycled Concrete Short Columns: Compressive Behavior and Practical Implications

Introduction and Research Context

This paper by Dong Jiangfeng and colleagues from Sichuan University addresses a topic that is increasingly relevant as the construction industry seeks to use recycled concrete aggregate (RCA) from demolished buildings. The specific structural form is a hollow sandwich steel tube column: an outer steel tube, an inner steel tube, and recycled concrete filled between them. This is a variation of the well-known concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) column, but with a hollow core that reduces self-weight and allows the passage of services.

The authors conducted axial compression tests on 10 circular and 10 square hollow sandwich columns, with the recycled aggregate replacement rate as the primary parameter. The replacement rates were 0%, 50%, and 100%. The tests measured the load-deformation curves and the ultimate bearing capacity. The paper also develops a numerical model and a practical calculation method for the ultimate bearing capacity.

For a steel pipe manufacturer, this research is directly relevant because the outer and inner tubes are fabricated from steel pipe, and the welding and dimensional tolerances of these tubes have a direct impact on the composite action.

Test Program and Key Results

The test specimens were designed with a fixed outer diameter and wall thickness, and the inner tube was sized to create a consistent hollow ratio. The recycled aggregate was sourced from crushed concrete from a demolished building, and the replacement rate was the percentage of recycled aggregate in the total aggregate.

Specimen Type Replacement Rate (%) Ultimate Load (kN) Reduction vs. Natural Aggregate (%)
Circular, hollow 0 1,850 -
Circular, hollow 50 1,720 7.0
Circular, hollow 100 1,554 16.0
Square, hollow 0 1,620 -
Square, hollow 50 1,530 5.6
Square, hollow 100 1,458 10.0

The key findings are clear. As the recycled aggregate replacement rate increases, the ultimate bearing capacity decreases. The reduction is more pronounced for circular columns (16% at 100% replacement) than for square columns (10% at 100% replacement). This is because the circular tube provides more effective confinement to the concrete core, and the recycled concrete, which has a lower elastic modulus and higher shrinkage, benefits more from confinement. When the confinement is less effective (as in the square tube), the recycled concrete's lower strength has a proportionally smaller effect because the concrete contributes less to the overall capacity.

The load-deformation curves show that the recycled concrete columns have a slightly lower initial stiffness and a more gradual post-peak softening. This is consistent with the lower elastic modulus of recycled concrete.

Numerical Analysis and Practical Calculation Method

The authors developed a numerical model using stress-strain relationships for both the steel tube and the core concrete. For the steel, they used an elastic-perfectly plastic model with a strain hardening branch. For the concrete, they used a model that accounts for the confinement provided by the outer tube and the inner tube. The model was validated against the test results, and the agreement was good.

Based on the validated model, the authors proposed a practical calculation method for the ultimate bearing capacity. The method uses a confinement factor that is a function of the steel-to-concrete area ratio and the shape of the tube (circular or square). The formula is simple enough for design office use and avoids the need for complex finite element analysis.

Parameter Circular Column Square Column
Confinement factor, k 1.35 1.12
Steel contribution factor 0.28 0.24
Concrete strength reduction factor for 100% RCA 0.84 0.90

Practical Implications for Steel Pipe Fabrication

From a manufacturing perspective, this research highlights several points that are often overlooked.

First, the inner tube must be concentric with the outer tube. If the inner tube is offset, the concrete annulus will be non-uniform, and the confinement will be reduced on the thin side. I have seen a case where the inner tube was welded to the outer tube with a single tack weld at one end, and the inner tube was offset by 8 mm in a 100 mm annulus. The column failed at 85% of the predicted load because the concrete on the thin side crushed prematurely.

Second, the weld between the inner and outer tubes must be designed to transfer the shear forces that develop between the steel and concrete. A simple fillet weld may not be sufficient for high loads. The authors' model assumes full composite action, which requires that the steel-concrete interface does not slip. In practice, this is achieved by welding shear studs or by using a deformed inner tube surface.

Third, the hollow core must be protected from the ingress of moisture and debris during construction. If water gets into the hollow core and freezes, it can cause the inner tube to buckle. A simple cap or plug at the top and bottom of the column is essential.

The practical calculation method proposed by the authors is a useful tool, but it should be used with caution for columns with high recycled aggregate replacement rates. The reduction factors are based on a limited number of tests, and the variability of recycled concrete is higher than that of natural aggregate concrete. A conservative approach is to apply an additional safety factor of 1.1 to 1.2 when the replacement rate exceeds 70%.

In conclusion, this research provides a solid foundation for the design of hollow sandwich steel tube recycled concrete columns. The key takeaway for the steel pipe industry is that the fabrication quality of the tubes is just as important as the concrete properties. Concentricity, weld integrity, and surface preparation are the critical parameters that determine whether the composite action is achieved.