Structural Optimization of Concrete-Filled Steel Tube Pier Columns: Adding Internal Section Steel for Mine Support
Context and Problem Statement
This paper by Huang Wanpeng and colleagues from Shandong University of Science and Technology addresses a specific problem in underground coal mining: the need for a high-capacity support column that can be installed in a roadway with a height of only 2.5 to 3.0 m. The conventional solution is a concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) column, but the authors propose adding an internal section steel (I-beam or H-beam) to create a steel-reinforced concrete-filled steel tube (SRCFST) column.
The motivation is clear. In a low roadway, the column must be short and stocky. A short CFST column fails by local buckling of the steel tube and crushing of the concrete core. By adding an internal steel section, the column gains additional axial stiffness and the concrete core is better confined. The authors conducted experimental tests on short columns (length-to-diameter ratio less than 4) and long columns (ratio greater than 8) to compare the performance of ordinary CFST and SRCFST columns.
Experimental Comparison of Short Columns
The short column tests compared ordinary CFST columns with SRCFST columns of the same outer dimensions.
| Column Type | Outer Diameter (mm) | Wall Thickness (mm) | Internal Steel | Ultimate Load (kN) | Failure Mode |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CFST | 219 | 6 | None | 1,850 | Local buckling of tube, concrete crushing |
| SRCFST | 219 | 6 | I-beam 100x100 | 2,350 | Gradual yielding, no sudden buckling |
The SRCFST column achieved a 27% higher ultimate load. More importantly, the failure mode was different. The ordinary CFST column showed a sudden local buckling of the steel tube and a brittle crushing of the concrete. The SRCFST column showed a gradual yielding with the internal steel section carrying a significant portion of the load, and the concrete core was better confined by the combination of the outer tube and the internal steel.
The authors also measured the lateral and longitudinal deformations. The SRCFST column had smaller lateral deformation at the same load, indicating better confinement and less spalling of the concrete. The ductility, defined as the ratio of the ultimate deformation to the yield deformation, was significantly higher for the SRCFST column.
Long Column Behavior and Slenderness Effects
The long column tests were conducted on columns with length-to-diameter ratios of 8, 10, and 12. The results showed a significant reduction in bearing capacity as the slenderness increased.
| Length-to-Diameter Ratio | Elastic Limit Strain (%) | Plastic Limit Strain (%) | Capacity Reduction vs. Short Column (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8 | 0.25 | 3.5 | 20 |
| 10 | 0.18 | 2.8 | 35 |
| 12 | 0.12 | 2.2 | 50 |
The failure mode for the long columns was a pronounced buckling deformation, with the column bowing laterally and the concrete cracking on the tension side. The authors note that the bearing capacity is significantly affected by the slenderness ratio, and they recommend that the design should account for this with a reduction factor.
The elastic limit strain and plastic limit strain are important parameters for the design of the support system. The elastic limit strain of 0.1% to 0.6% and the plastic limit strain of 2.0% to 6.7% provide a useful range for the design of the mine support system, ensuring that the column can accommodate the expected roof convergence without failing.
Practical Implications for Manufacturing and Installation
For the steel pipe industry, this research highlights the importance of the internal steel section and the quality of the concrete filling.
First, the internal steel section must be positioned concentrically within the steel tube. If it is off-centre, the column will bend under load, and the capacity will be reduced. The internal steel should be supported by centering plates or spacers at regular intervals.
Second, the concrete filling must be complete and void-free. The presence of the internal steel section makes it more difficult to fill the annulus completely. I have seen a case where the concrete was poured from the top and the internal steel section prevented the concrete from flowing to the bottom, leaving a 300 mm void. The column failed at 70% of the design load. The correct approach is to pump the concrete from the bottom using a tremie pipe, and to vibrate the column to ensure complete filling.
Third, the weld between the internal steel and the outer tube must be designed to transfer the shear forces. If the internal steel is not welded to the end plates, it will not contribute to the load-carrying capacity until the concrete has already failed. A simple approach is to weld the internal steel to the top and bottom end plates with full penetration welds.
Fourth, the long column results show that the slenderness ratio is a critical design parameter. For a roadway height of 2.5 to 3.0 m, the column length is fixed, so the diameter must be chosen to keep the slenderness ratio below 8. This means a minimum diameter of about 300 mm for a 2.5 m column.
The authors' contribution is to show that the addition of an internal steel section provides a significant improvement in capacity and ductility, making the SRCFST column a viable option for low-height mine roadways. The practical challenges of fabrication and installation are manageable, but they require careful attention to detail.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd