ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Numerical Simulation of Deformation and Failure Effects of Large-Diameter Steel Pipes under External Contact Explosion Loading

Core Findings and Simulation Approach

This study by Ji Chong et al. addresses a critical safety concern that we in the pipeline industry too often treat as an afterthought: what actually happens when a large-diameter gas transmission pipe takes a direct hit from a contact explosion. The authors used LS-DYNA with a Lagrangian-Eulerian coupled formulation to simulate the nonlinear dynamic response of large-diameter steel pipe under condensed explosive contact loading. The model captured the full sequence of deformation, damage progression, and internal stress development, and was validated against field experiments with good agreement.

The key technical parameters that drove the simulation are worth restating for anyone who has to specify blast-resistant pipe design:

Parameter Value / Range Practical Relevance
Pipe diameter Large-diameter (typical X70/X80 line pipe) Large-diameter pipe has lower flexural stiffness per unit mass, making it more vulnerable to localized denting and buckling
Explosive charge mass Small (kg range) vs. large (tens of kg) The failure mechanism changes fundamentally with charge size
Wall thickness Varied to assess effect Thicker wall resists cratering but may not prevent shear plugging
Coupling method Lagrangian-Eulerian Correctly models the interaction between detonation products and the pipe wall
Material model Rate-dependent plasticity with failure criteria Strain-rate effects are critical in explosive loading

Technical Interpretation of Failure Modes

The simulation revealed two distinct failure regimes that have direct implications for pipeline protection design. For small explosive charges, the damage is localized at the contact point: a crater forms on the outer surface, a bulge appears on the inner surface, and spalling can occur on the internal wall due to the reflection of the compressive stress wave as a tensile wave. This is classic spallation behavior, and it is a real threat to the integrity of the pipe even when the wall is not perforated. The spall fragments can become projectiles inside the pipe, potentially damaging downstream equipment or blocking the line.

For larger charges, the failure mode shifts dramatically. The simulation showed that shear failure occurs at the contact site, producing a plug-like fragment with significant kinetic energy that can penetrate the opposite wall of the pipe. This is the most dangerous scenario for a gas pipeline, because the fragment can create a secondary rupture at the far side, effectively turning a localized attack into a double-ended failure. The authors quantified the effect of explosive mass and wall thickness on the extent of damage, confirming that increasing wall thickness does not linearly improve resistance to shear plugging—there is a threshold beyond which the material simply cannot absorb the energy before shear localization occurs.

Engineering Practice Implications and Reflections

This is where the paper earns its keep for those of us who have to live with the consequences. In my experience, pipeline blast protection is often specified with a single "blast resistance" figure, but this research demonstrates that the failure mode is highly charge-size dependent. A small charge produces a dent and spall, which may be repairable by sleeve or replacement. A large charge produces a through-wall shear plug and a secondary rupture on the far side, which is a catastrophic event requiring full line isolation and replacement.

For the shop floor and the delivery site, the practical lessons are clear. First, when specifying pipe for areas with potential explosive threat (e.g., near industrial facilities, transportation corridors, or in conflict zones), the wall thickness must be selected not just for pressure containment but for blast resistance, and the design should consider the maximum credible charge size, not just the average. Second, the material toughness matters enormously—a pipe with good Charpy impact energy at the operating temperature will resist spallation better than a pipe with marginal toughness, because the spallation threshold is governed by the material's ability to absorb energy before fracture. Third, the weld seam is a weak point: a longitudinal weld with poor toughness can become the initiation site for a propagating shear failure. This is why I have always insisted on 100% NDT of the weld seam for pipe destined for high-risk applications, and why the weld impact test requirements in API 5L and ISO 3183 are not just paperwork.

One more practical note: the simulation showed that the internal pressure of the pipe has a significant effect on the failure mode. A pressurized pipe behaves differently from an unpressurized one—the internal pressure provides a stabilizing effect that resists inward deformation but can also accelerate crack propagation once a through-wall defect forms. This is a critical interaction that is often overlooked in simplified design codes. If you are designing a pipeline that may be exposed to blast loading, you must consider the operating pressure as a variable, not a constant.

The study also underscores the value of numerical simulation as a design tool, but with a caveat: the validation against experimental data is essential. I have seen too many simulations that produce beautiful pictures but fail to match reality because the material model or the boundary conditions were wrong. The authors here did the right thing by running parallel experiments and comparing the results. That is the discipline we need in the industry.

In summary, this paper provides a solid foundation for understanding the blast response of large-diameter pipe. The key takeaway is that the failure mode is not a simple function of charge size; it is a function of the interaction between charge size, wall thickness, material properties, and internal pressure. For pipeline designers, the message is to think in terms of failure mechanisms, not just resistance values, and to validate any simulation against physical testing before relying on it for safety-critical decisions. This is a lesson I have learned the hard way, and it is one that every engineer involved in pipeline security should carry with them.