ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Lateral Impact Resistance of Hollow Concrete-Filled Steel Tube Members: Experimental and Numerical Study

Introduction and Literature Context

Wang Hongxin, Zha Xiaoxiong, and Ye Fuxiang from Harbin Institute of Technology Shenzhen Graduate School published this study in the Journal of Huazhong University of Science and Technology (Natural Science Edition) (2010, Vol. 38, No. 8, pp. 107-110), funded by the Shenzhen Science and Technology Plan. The paper investigates the lateral impact resistance of hollow concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) members, where "hollow" refers to a member with a central void (i.e., a pipe-in-pipe configuration with concrete filling the annular space). This is a relatively novel structural form that offers advantages in terms of weight reduction and thermal insulation, but its behaviour under impact loading is not well understood. The authors conducted drop-hammer impact tests and complementary finite element analyses to study the effects of impact velocity, hollow ratio (the ratio of the inner void diameter to the outer diameter), material strength, and boundary conditions on the impact resistance of these members.

Key Technical Findings and Interpretation

Effect of Impact Velocity

The experimental results showed that for a given hollow ratio, an increase in impact velocity leads to an increase in the deformation of the member. This is an intuitive result: a higher impact velocity imparts more kinetic energy to the member, which must be dissipated through plastic deformation. The practical implication is that the design of hollow CFST members for impact resistance must consider the potential impact velocity, which depends on the application. For a bridge pier, for example, the impact velocity of a vehicle or vessel is determined by the approach speed, which can be estimated from traffic conditions. For an offshore platform, the impact velocity of a boat or debris is typically lower but the mass is higher, leading to a different energy regime.

Effect of Hollow Ratio

The paper found that when the hammer weight and impact velocity are held constant, an increase in the hollow ratio leads to an increase in member deformation and a decrease in the impact force. This is a critical finding. A higher hollow ratio means less concrete in the annular space, which reduces the member's flexural stiffness and energy absorption capacity. The impact force is lower because the member is more compliant, but the deformation is larger. This is a classic trade-off: a stiffer member will develop higher forces but lower deformation, while a more flexible member will develop lower forces but higher deformation. The design engineer must decide which parameter is more critical for the specific application. In general, for members subjected to impact, a moderate hollow ratio (e.g., 0.4-0.6) is a reasonable compromise, providing adequate stiffness while maintaining sufficient energy absorption.

Parametric Study Results

The finite element parametric study revealed several additional insights:

These findings are consistent with the general principles of impact engineering and provide a useful basis for the design of hollow CFST members.

Engineering Practice Implications and Reflections

Design Considerations for Impact Loading

From a design perspective, the key takeaway is that hollow CFST members must be designed for the specific impact scenario they are likely to face. The paper's finding that the hollow ratio is a critical parameter suggests that the selection of the inner void diameter should be based on the required energy absorption capacity, not just on the structural stiffness. In practice, this means that the designer should calculate the expected impact energy (based on the mass and velocity of the impacting object) and then select a hollow ratio that allows the member to absorb that energy without excessive deformation or fracture. The finite element method is an essential tool for this design process, as it allows the designer to model the impact event and evaluate the member's response.

Manufacturing and Fabrication Considerations

For the steel pipe manufacturer, the hollow CFST member presents some interesting challenges. The outer pipe and the inner pipe must be concentric, which requires careful control of the pipe dimensions and the fabrication process. The concrete is placed in the annular space between the two pipes, which can be a difficult operation if the annulus is narrow. The ends of the member must be closed to contain the concrete, typically using steel plates or end caps. In my experience, the most critical fabrication issue is ensuring that the inner pipe does not buckle during concrete placement, particularly if the concrete is pumped under pressure. The inner pipe should be supported at regular intervals, or the concrete should be placed using a method that minimizes the lateral pressure on the inner pipe.

Comparison with Solid CFST Members

The hollow CFST member offers several advantages over solid CFST members for impact applications:

Parameter Solid CFST Hollow CFST
Weight per unit length Higher Lower (by 20-40% depending on hollow ratio)
Flexural stiffness Higher Lower (but can be designed to match)
Energy absorption capacity Higher for the same outer diameter Lower, but weight-normalized performance can be comparable
Thermal insulation Poor Better (the void provides insulation)
Construction complexity Simpler More complex (two pipes, annular concrete placement)

This comparison highlights the trade-offs involved. For applications where weight is critical (e.g., offshore structures, long-span bridges), the hollow CFST member may be advantageous despite its lower absolute energy absorption. For applications where impact resistance is paramount (e.g., bridge piers in navigable waterways), a solid CFST member may be preferred.

Concluding Remarks and Personal Reflection

This paper by Wang Hongxin and colleagues is a valuable contribution to the understanding of hollow CFST members under lateral impact. The experimental results and finite element analyses provide clear guidance on the effects of impact velocity, hollow ratio, material strength, and boundary conditions on impact resistance. The finding that the hollow ratio is a critical parameter is particularly important, as it highlights the need for careful design optimization. From a practical standpoint, the hollow CFST member is an interesting structural form that offers weight savings and improved thermal performance, but its impact behaviour must be carefully evaluated. The finite element method is an essential tool for this evaluation, and the paper provides a validated approach that can be used for design purposes. In my experience, the most common application for hollow CFST members is in offshore structures, where weight reduction is critical and impact loads from vessels and debris must be considered. The paper's findings provide a solid basis for the design of such members, and I would recommend it to any engineer involved in the design or fabrication of hollow CFST structures. The next step would be to conduct full-scale impact tests on representative members to validate the model test results and to develop design guidelines that can be incorporated into standards such as API RP 2A or DNV-ST-F101.