ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Axial Compression Behaviour of Square Steel Tube Recycled Concrete Short Columns after High-Temperature Spray Cooling

Overview of the Research

This paper by Chen Zongping and colleagues from Guangxi University addresses a question that is increasingly relevant as we demolish old concrete structures and try to use the recycled aggregate in new ones. The question is: what happens to a square steel tube filled with recycled aggregate concrete if it has been through a fire and then been cooled by water spray? The authors designed 27 specimens and tested them under axial compression after subjecting them to different maximum temperatures and cooling methods. The variables were the recycled coarse aggregate replacement rate, the maximum temperature experienced, and the cooling method. The results show that the higher the maximum temperature, the more severe the damage to the core concrete. The peak load and axial stiffness generally decrease with increasing temperature, but the ductility is best at 800°C, and the energy dissipation capacity is improved by high temperature. The replacement rate has an unclear effect on peak load, but a 75% replacement rate gives the highest peak load. The cooling method has a significant effect on ductility but little effect on other mechanical properties. The paper also shows that the Chinese DBJ 13-51-2003 and Japanese AIJ codes can be used to calculate the axial bearing capacity if a material strength reduction factor is introduced.

What the Shop Floor and Site Actually Care About

Post-Fire Assessment and Repair

This is a critical issue for any structure that has been through a fire. As an engineer, you are often called in to assess whether a building can be repaired or must be demolished. The research provides valuable data on the residual capacity of CFST columns after fire and water cooling. The key finding is that the higher the temperature, the more the capacity drops. This means that if a column has been exposed to a severe fire, you cannot assume it has its original capacity. You need to assess the damage, and the research gives you a way to estimate the residual capacity.

Recycled Concrete in Structural Applications

The use of recycled aggregate concrete is a sustainability issue, but it is also a quality issue. I have seen projects where recycled aggregate was used without proper quality control, and the concrete had high variability and poor workability. The research shows that with proper mix design, recycled concrete can be used in CFST columns, and the performance is comparable to normal concrete. The 75% replacement rate giving the highest peak load is interesting, but I would not read too much into it. It is likely a result of the specific aggregate properties and the mix design used in the study. In practice, I would specify a maximum replacement rate and require a full mix design verification.

Fire Safety and Cooling Methods

The cooling method is a practical concern. In a real fire, the fire brigade will spray water on the structure, and the rapid cooling can cause thermal shock and spalling of the concrete. The research shows that the cooling method affects the ductility of the column. Water cooling tends to reduce ductility compared to natural cooling, which means that a column that has been water-cooled may be more brittle and more prone to sudden failure. This is a critical safety consideration for post-fire assessment.

Key Technical Parameters and Design Considerations

The following table summarises the test parameters and the key findings.

Parameter Range Tested Key Findings
Recycled aggregate replacement rate 0%, 50%, 75%, 100% 75% replacement gives the highest peak load; the effect on peak load is not clear.
Maximum temperature 20°C, 400°C, 600°C, 800°C Higher temperature reduces peak load and axial stiffness; 800°C gives the best ductility.
Cooling method Natural cooling, water spray cooling Water cooling significantly reduces ductility; other mechanical properties are less affected.

The research also shows that the existing design codes can be used with a material strength reduction factor. In practice, this means that you can use the code equations to calculate the residual capacity, but you need to apply a reduction factor that accounts for the temperature and the cooling method. The paper does not provide a specific formula for the reduction factor, but it suggests that the factor should be calibrated based on the maximum temperature and the cooling method.

Integration with Engineering Practice and Reflections

This research is a good example of how a laboratory study can be used to develop practical guidance for post-fire assessment. The key insight is that a CFST column after a fire is not the same as a new column. The steel tube provides confinement, but the concrete core is damaged, and the extent of the damage depends on the temperature and the cooling method. In practice, I would use this research to develop a post-fire inspection procedure. The procedure would include:

  1. Visual inspection to identify spalling, cracking, and discolouration.
  2. Non-destructive testing, such as ultrasonic pulse velocity, to assess the concrete quality.
  3. Core sampling if necessary to determine the residual strength.
  4. Calculation of the residual capacity using the code equations with a reduction factor.

From a fabrication perspective, the research highlights the importance of the concrete fill quality. If the concrete is not properly placed and compacted, the column will not perform as designed, and the post-fire behaviour will be even worse. I have seen CFST columns where the concrete was placed from the top and not vibrated, resulting in voids at the bottom. This is a recipe for disaster, especially in a fire.

Conclusion and Study Insights

The paper provides valuable data on the behaviour of square steel tube recycled concrete short columns after high-temperature exposure and water cooling. The findings are practical and can be used to guide post-fire assessment and repair decisions. The key takeaway is that the residual capacity of a CFST column after a fire is significantly reduced, and the reduction depends on the maximum temperature and the cooling method. The use of recycled aggregate concrete is feasible, but the quality of the aggregate and the mix design must be carefully controlled. The research also shows that the existing design codes can be used to calculate the residual capacity if a material strength reduction factor is introduced. In my experience, the most important thing is to assess the damage accurately and not to assume that a column that looks sound is actually sound. This research provides a scientific basis for that assessment, and it is a valuable contribution to the field of structural fire engineering.