Basic Shear Performance of Rectangular Concrete-Filled Steel Tube Members Without End Plates
Why Shear Matters in CFST Members
This paper from Lanzhou University and Chongqing University addresses a fundamental issue in the design of concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) members: how do they behave in shear. Most of the research on CFST members has focused on axial compression and bending, because those are the dominant load cases in columns and beams. But shear is also important, especially in short members, in connections, and in members that are subjected to combined axial and lateral loads.
The authors conducted eight tests on rectangular CFST members without end plates, with a shear span ratio ranging from 0.3 to 0.8. The key finding is that at a shear span ratio of 0.3, the member fails in shear, and as the shear span ratio increases, the failure mode transitions from shear to bending. This is consistent with the behavior of reinforced concrete members, but the transition point is different because the steel tube provides significant shear reinforcement.
Another important finding is that the shear capacity decreases as the shear span ratio increases, and the slip between the steel tube and the core concrete also decreases. This is because at a low shear span ratio, the load is transferred directly through the steel tube, and the concrete core is not fully engaged. At a higher shear span ratio, the concrete core is more engaged, and the slip is smaller.
Interface Friction and Bond Behavior
The authors used finite element analysis to investigate the effect of the friction coefficient between the steel tube and the concrete core. They found that a friction coefficient of 0.25 gives good agreement with the test results. This is a useful finding, because it gives designers a rational basis for modeling the interface behavior.
In practice, the interface friction depends on the surface condition of the steel tube. A clean, rust-free tube has a friction coefficient of about 0.3 to 0.4, while a tube with oil or paint on the inside has a much lower friction coefficient. I have seen CFST members where the tube was painted on the inside, and the concrete just slid inside the tube with almost no bond. That is a serious defect, because it means the steel and concrete do not work together, and the member behaves like a steel tube with a loose concrete core.
The paper also investigated the effect of end plates. The authors found that the end plates have little effect on the yield load, but they do affect the post-yield behavior. This is because the end plates provide confinement to the concrete core, which improves the ductility and the post-yield stiffness. Without end plates, the concrete core is free to expand at the ends, and the member is less ductile.
Manufacturing and Site Considerations
From a manufacturing perspective, the key issue is the surface condition of the tube. The tube must be clean and free of oil, grease, and loose rust before concrete placement. I have seen tubes that were stored outside for months, with a layer of rust on the inside, and the concrete was placed without cleaning. The result was a poor bond and a member that did not behave as designed.
The concrete mix is also important. For a rectangular CFST member, the concrete must be flowable enough to fill the corners of the tube, but not so flowable that it segregates. I would specify a self-compacting concrete with a maximum aggregate size of 10 mm and a slump flow of 600 to 700 mm. The concrete must be placed in layers of no more than 500 mm, with vibration to ensure full compaction.
On site, the most common problem is the connection between the CFST member and the adjacent structure. If the member has no end plates, the connection must be made by welding the tube to the adjacent steel member, or by using a mechanical connection. I have seen connections where the tube was welded to a steel plate, but the weld was not full penetration, and the connection failed in a minor earthquake. The lesson is that the connection must be designed and fabricated with the same care as the member itself.
Design Implications and Code Gaps
The paper highlights a gap in the current design codes. Most codes, including the Chinese code for CFST structures, provide formulas for axial compression and bending, but they do not provide a clear formula for shear. This means that designers have to rely on simplified models or on finite element analysis, which is not always practical.
The paper proposes a formula for the shear capacity of rectangular CFST members without end plates, based on the test results and the finite element analysis. The formula accounts for the shear span ratio, the dimensions of the member, and the material properties. This is a useful contribution, but it needs to be validated with more test data before it can be used in design.
Closing Thoughts
This is a well-conducted study that fills an important gap in the understanding of CFST members. The key findings are that the shear span ratio controls the failure mode, that the interface friction coefficient is about 0.25, and that end plates improve the post-yield behavior. The practical implications are that the tube must be clean before concrete placement, the concrete must be flowable, and the connections must be designed with care. If you are designing a CFST member in shear, this paper gives you the data you need. If you are building one, this paper tells you what to watch for.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd