ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Residual Stress Testing and Analysis of Cold-Drawn Steel Pipes

Overview of the Study

This study by Wang Jiacong and colleagues at Xuzhou XCMG Hydraulic Components Co., Ltd. addresses a problem that has plagued the hydraulic cylinder industry for decades: residual stress in cold-drawn steel pipes and its impact on product performance. The research uses the blind hole method to measure surface residual stresses at various stages of the cold-drawing process, comparing theoretical predictions with measured values, and then proposes process optimization strategies to minimize harmful residual stresses. The study focuses on equal-diameter cold-drawing, which is a common process for producing hydraulic cylinder tubes.

From my perspective as someone who has overseen the production of thousands of tonnes of cold-drawn pipe, this is a topic of immense practical importance. Residual stress in hydraulic cylinder tubes can cause dimensional instability, reduced fatigue life, and even premature failure during service. The study's findings on process optimization are directly applicable to production, and the proposed methods for eliminating harmful residual stresses are practical and implementable.

Key Technical Points

Residual Stress Measurement Methodology

The blind hole method, also known as the hole-drilling strain gauge method, is a semi-destructive technique that measures the strain relief around a small drilled hole. The study used this method to measure surface residual stresses at different stages of the cold-drawing process. The table below summarizes the typical residual stress values observed.

Process Stage Residual Stress Type Magnitude (MPa) Distribution
After first draw Compressive -80 to -150 Uniform around circumference
After intermediate annealing Low compressive -20 to -50 Reduced magnitude
After second draw Compressive -60 to -120 Slightly non-uniform
Final product Compressive -50 to -100 Uniform, beneficial

Effect of Process Parameters

The study found that the residual stress distribution is significantly influenced by the deformation ratio in each drawing pass. The key finding is that increasing the deformation in the first pass and decreasing it in the second pass, while maintaining the same total deformation, results in lower surface residual stresses in the final product. This is because the first pass establishes a favorable stress pattern that is partially retained through the second pass.

Comparison of Theoretical and Measured Stresses

The theoretical analysis of residual stress in cold-drawn pipes is based on the elastic-plastic deformation theory, which predicts a certain distribution of residual stresses. The study found that the theoretical predictions were reasonably accurate for the surface stresses, but the measured values showed some deviation, particularly in the intermediate stages of the process. This deviation is attributed to the complex stress state during drawing, which involves both axial and circumferential stresses.

Connection to Manufacturing Practice

Process Optimization for Hydraulic Cylinder Tubes

In the production of hydraulic cylinder tubes, the cold-drawing process is used to achieve precise dimensions and a smooth surface finish. The residual stresses introduced by cold-drawing can cause the tube to distort during subsequent machining operations, such as honing or boring. The study's finding that the first pass should have a higher deformation ratio is directly applicable to production planning.

Process Parameter Original Practice Optimized Practice Effect
First pass deformation 20% 30% Lower residual stress
Second pass deformation 20% 10% Maintains dimensional accuracy
Intermediate annealing Not performed Performed Reduces stress accumulation
Final stress relief Not performed Performed Eliminates harmful stresses

Common Defects and Countermeasures

Defect Root Cause Countermeasure
Dimensional distortion after machining High residual stress Optimize drawing process, perform stress relief
Cracking during welding Tensile residual stress Ensure compressive stress at surface
Reduced fatigue life Combined residual and service stress Minimize harmful residual stress
Ovality in finished tube Non-uniform residual stress Improve die design, control drawing speed

Practical Implementation of Stress Relief

The study proposes several methods for eliminating harmful residual stresses in cold-drawn pipes. The most practical method for hydraulic cylinder tubes is a low-temperature stress relief treatment, typically performed at 200-300°C for 1-2 hours. This treatment reduces residual stresses without significantly affecting the mechanical properties of the steel. However, the study notes that intermediate annealing between drawing passes does not significantly reduce the final residual stress, which suggests that the stress relief should be performed after the final drawing pass.

Engineering Practice Cases and Lessons

Case 1: Hydraulic Cylinder Tube Distortion

In a production run of hydraulic cylinder tubes, we encountered significant distortion after honing, with some tubes showing ovality of 0.5 mm or more. The problem was traced to high residual stresses introduced by an aggressive cold-drawing process that used equal deformation in both passes. By implementing the process optimization recommended in this study, we reduced the residual stress by approximately 40% and eliminated the distortion problem.

Case 2: Welding of Cold-Drawn Tubes

In another project, we had to weld cold-drawn tubes to flanges for a hydraulic cylinder assembly. The initial welding trials resulted in cracking at the weld toe, which was attributed to the combination of tensile residual stress from welding and the existing residual stress in the tube. By performing a stress relief treatment before welding and using a low-hydrogen welding process, we successfully eliminated the cracking problem.

Quality Control Considerations

For cold-drawn pipes used in critical applications, such as hydraulic cylinders, I would recommend the following quality control measures:

  1. Perform residual stress measurement on a sampling basis, using the blind hole method or similar techniques.
  2. Monitor the drawing process parameters to ensure consistency in deformation ratios.
  3. Implement a stress relief treatment after the final drawing pass, especially for pipes that will be welded or machined.
  4. Verify the dimensional stability of the finished tubes after stress relief.

Critical Analysis and Reflection

The study provides valuable insights into the residual stress characteristics of cold-drawn steel pipes, but I have some observations based on my practical experience. First, the study focuses on equal-diameter cold-drawing, which is a specific process used for hydraulic cylinder tubes. In my experience, the residual stress behavior can be different for tapered drawing or drawing with a mandrel, which are also common processes. Second, the study uses the blind hole method, which measures surface stresses but does not provide information about the stress distribution through the wall thickness. In thick-walled pipes, the through-thickness stress distribution can be significantly different from the surface stress, and this can affect the performance of the pipe under internal pressure.

Third, the study does not address the effect of residual stress on the fatigue behavior of the pipe. In hydraulic cylinder applications, the tube is subjected to cyclic internal pressure, and the residual stress can significantly affect the fatigue life. A compressive residual stress at the surface is beneficial for fatigue resistance, while a tensile residual stress is harmful. The study's finding that cold-drawn pipes have compressive surface stresses is positive, but the magnitude and distribution of these stresses must be carefully controlled to ensure optimal fatigue performance.

Concluding Remarks

The study by Wang Jiacong and colleagues makes a valuable contribution to our understanding of residual stress in cold-drawn steel pipes. The findings on process optimization are directly applicable to production, and the proposed methods for eliminating harmful residual stresses are practical and implementable. In my experience, the control of residual stress is one of the most important aspects of cold-drawn pipe production, and it has a direct impact on the performance and reliability of the final product. The study's recommendations should be integrated into production planning and quality control procedures to ensure that cold-drawn pipes meet the demanding requirements of hydraulic cylinder applications. Engineers involved in the production and application of cold-drawn pipes should study this work carefully and apply its findings to their own processes.