ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Blast Pressure Distribution on Concrete-Filled Steel Tube Pier Columns

Literature Overview and Research Context

This paper from Chang'an University, published in Blasting (2018), presents the results of static explosion tests on large-scale concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) pier columns. The authors, Sun Shanshan, Zhao Junhai and Zhang Changguang, conducted two tests with TNT charges of 3 kg and 50 kg on CFST pier columns, and one free-field test with a 50 kg charge, to measure the pressure distribution on the column surface. They then compared the experimental results with predictions from several empirical formulas, including those from TM5-1300, Henrych, and Chengqing Wu.

This is a topic that is close to my heart, because I have supplied steel pipe for blast-resistant structures in the oil and gas industry, and I have seen what happens when the design pressure is underestimated. The blast load is not a simple uniform pressure; it is a complex transient load that varies in both space and time. The pressure on the front face of a structure is different from the pressure on the side faces, and the pressure on the back face is different again. The empirical formulas that are used in design are based on a limited number of tests, and they often do not account for the shape of the structure.

Key Technical Points and Test Observations

The test programme involved three static explosion tests: two on CFST pier columns (with 3 kg and 50 kg TNT) and one free-field test (with 50 kg TNT). The key findings are summarised below.

Test Configuration TNT Charge Key Observation
CFST pier column, front face 3 kg and 50 kg Negative pressure zone on the front face was small and could be neglected.
CFST pier column, back face 3 kg and 50 kg Pressure on the back face was small and could be neglected.
Free field 50 kg Reflected pressure to incident pressure ratio averaged about 2.5 at scaled distance z > 3 m/kg^(1/3).
CFST pier column, front face 50 kg The CFST column had some influence on the reflected pressure, but little influence on the positive pressure impulse.

The most significant finding is that the CFST pier column has a relatively small influence on the reflected pressure, but it has a significant influence on the pressure distribution. The front face of the column experiences a high reflected pressure, but this pressure is not uniform across the face. The pressure is highest at the centre of the face and decreases towards the edges. This is because the blast wave is reflected from the column surface, and the reflection is strongest where the wave is perpendicular to the surface.

The authors also compared the experimental results with several empirical formulas. They found that the Henrych formula and the Chengqing Wu formula predicted lower reflected pressures than the experimental values, while the TM5-1300 formula gave a more reasonable prediction. This is an important finding, because it means that if a designer uses the Henrych formula, they may underestimate the blast load and the structure may be under-designed.

Formula Reflected Pressure Prediction Assessment
TM5-1300 Reasonable prediction Recommended for design.
Henrych Under-predicts Not recommended for CFST columns.
Chengqing Wu Under-predicts Not recommended for CFST columns.

Practical Implications for Manufacturing and Delivery

From a manufacturing standpoint, the CFST pier column is a relatively simple structure: a steel tube filled with concrete. The steel tube is usually a large-diameter pipe, and it is filled with concrete on site. The main challenge is not the fabrication of the tube, but the quality of the concrete filling. If the concrete is not fully compacted, there may be voids at the top of the column, and these voids can reduce the blast resistance of the column.

Manufacturing Issue Root Cause Countermeasure
Voids in concrete at the top of the column Incomplete filling, poor compaction Use a tremie pipe to place the concrete from the bottom, and vibrate the column during filling.
Poor bond between steel tube and concrete Surface contamination, lack of roughness Clean the inside of the tube thoroughly, and consider using shear studs or a roughened surface.
Weld defects in the steel tube Poor welding procedure, lack of inspection Use a qualified welding procedure, and perform 100% UT on the longitudinal welds.

The steel tube for a CFST pier column is usually a large-diameter pipe, and it is often made from plate that is formed and welded. The weld is a critical element, because it must be able to resist the blast load without failing. In my experience, the weld is often the weakest link in the structure, and it is important to ensure that the weld is full penetration and that it is inspected thoroughly.

The authors note that the pressure on the back face of the column is small and can be neglected. This is an important simplification, because it means that the design engineer only needs to consider the pressure on the front face. However, this is only valid for a column that is isolated and not connected to other structures. If the column is part of a frame, the blast wave may be transmitted through the frame and cause additional loads on the back face.

Study Insights and Reflections

The paper provides valuable experimental data on the blast pressure distribution on CFST pier columns, and it highlights the importance of using the correct empirical formula for design. The TM5-1300 formula is recommended for design, but the designer should be aware that the Henrych and Chengqing Wu formulas may underestimate the blast load.

From a practical standpoint, I would like to see more attention paid to the effect of the column shape on the blast pressure distribution. The CFST pier column in this study is a circular column, but many pier columns are rectangular or square. The pressure distribution on a rectangular column is different from that on a circular column, and the empirical formulas may not be applicable.

Another point that is often overlooked is the effect of the blast wave on the steel tube itself. The blast wave can cause the steel tube to deform, and this deformation can reduce the confinement of the concrete core. If the steel tube deforms significantly, the concrete may fail in compression, and the column may lose its load-carrying capacity. This is a complex interaction that is not fully understood, and it warrants further research.

Conclusion

The blast pressure distribution on CFST pier columns is a critical design parameter, and this paper provides valuable experimental data that can be used to validate design formulas. The TM5-1300 formula is recommended for design, but the designer should be aware of the limitations of other formulas. From a manufacturing standpoint, the CFST pier column is a relatively simple structure, but the quality of the concrete filling and the integrity of the steel tube welds are critical for blast resistance. The paper is a valuable contribution to the literature, and it provides a solid foundation for future research on the blast resistance of CFST structures.