ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Axial Compression Behaviour of Recycled Concrete-Filled Rectangular Steel Tube Short Columns

Literature Overview and Core Findings

This study by Yang Youfu and Huang Xiangyu addresses a topic that is becoming increasingly important as the construction industry seeks to reduce its environmental footprint: the use of recycled concrete in composite steel-concrete columns. The team tested six specimens under axial compression, varying the recycled coarse aggregate replacement ratio and the section aspect ratio. They examined the failure modes, load-deformation curves and bearing capacity.

The key findings are that as the recycled coarse aggregate replacement ratio increases, the axial bearing capacity, the composite elastic modulus and the relative bearing capacity coefficient decrease, while the post-peak bearing capacity coefficient increases. The section aspect ratio has a small influence on the relative bearing capacity coefficient, but a larger aspect ratio leads to a smaller post-peak bearing capacity coefficient. The finite element model, built with appropriate material constitutive models, showed good agreement with the test results.

Technical Interpretation and Process Connection

The use of recycled concrete aggregate introduces a level of variability that is not present with natural aggregate. The recycled aggregate has a higher porosity, a lower density and a higher water absorption. This affects the concrete's compressive strength, elastic modulus and shrinkage behaviour. For a composite column, the concrete core is confined by the steel tube, and the confinement effect depends on the lateral expansion of the concrete. A recycled concrete with a lower elastic modulus will expand more laterally under axial load, which can actually improve the confinement effect, but it also reduces the axial stiffness of the composite section.

The table below summarises the key differences between natural and recycled aggregate concrete that are relevant to composite column behaviour.

Property Natural Aggregate Concrete Recycled Aggregate Concrete Practical Implication
Compressive strength Higher for a given cement content Lower, typically 10% to 20% reduction Requires a higher cement content or a lower water-cement ratio
Elastic modulus Higher Lower, typically 10% to 30% reduction Reduces the composite stiffness and the initial stiffness of the column
Water absorption Low, 0.5% to 1% High, 3% to 8% Affects the workability and the shrinkage of the concrete
Shrinkage Moderate Higher, due to the porous aggregate Increases the risk of shrinkage cracking and reduces the bond with the steel tube
Density 2300 to 2400 kg/m3 2100 to 2300 kg/m3 Reduces the self-weight of the column

The paper's finding that the post-peak bearing capacity coefficient increases with the recycled aggregate replacement ratio is interesting. This means that the recycled concrete column has a more ductile post-peak behaviour, which is a positive attribute in a seismic context. The reason is that the recycled aggregate concrete is more compressible, so the steel tube is able to mobilise its confinement effect more gradually, leading to a softer and more gradual post-peak load decay.

Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

I have been involved in several projects where recycled concrete was specified for environmental certification purposes. The main challenge is always the variability of the recycled aggregate. If the recycled aggregate comes from a demolition site, it may contain contaminants such as brick, mortar and glass. The quality of the recycled aggregate must be carefully controlled, and the concrete mix design must be adjusted accordingly. The paper's finite element model provides a way to assess the impact of the recycled aggregate on the column's performance, but the practical reality is that the concrete supplier must be able to guarantee a consistent quality of recycled aggregate.

On one project, we used a 50% recycled aggregate replacement ratio in the concrete for a composite column. The concrete supplier was able to achieve the required compressive strength, but the elastic modulus was about 15% lower than the design value. This affected the initial stiffness of the column, and the designer had to increase the steel ratio to compensate. The cost increase was about 8% of the column cost, which was acceptable given the environmental benefits. The key lesson is that the design engineer must be informed of the actual properties of the recycled concrete, not just the compressive strength, because the elastic modulus and the post-peak behaviour are equally important for a composite column.

Summary and Reflection

This study provides valuable data on the axial compression behaviour of recycled concrete-filled rectangular steel tube short columns. The experimental results show that the recycled aggregate replacement ratio has a significant effect on the bearing capacity and the stiffness, but a positive effect on the post-peak ductility. The section aspect ratio has a smaller effect. The finite element model is a useful tool for extending the experimental findings to a wider range of parameters. For the manufacturing and supply side, the key challenge is the quality control of the recycled aggregate and the concrete mix design. For the design side, the paper provides a framework for assessing the impact of recycled concrete on the structural performance. I would recommend this paper to any engineer involved in the design of sustainable composite structures, as it provides the technical justification for using recycled concrete in steel-concrete composite columns.