ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Experimental Study on Residual Bearing Capacity of Concrete-Filled Steel Tube Columns After Fire

Literature Overview and Core Findings

This study by Han Linhai, Yang Youfu and Huo Jingsi is a classic piece of research that has influenced fire engineering practice for over two decades. The team tested six circular and six square concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) columns after subjecting them to the standard fire curves specified in ISO-834 and GB9978-88. They examined the mechanical behaviour and the residual bearing capacity of the columns after the fire exposure.

The key findings are that the residual bearing capacity of the bare CFST columns was severely reduced, while the columns with a protective layer had a less severe reduction. For the same conditions, the loss of bearing capacity increased with an increase in the slenderness ratio. The load eccentricity had a relatively small effect on the loss of bearing capacity. The results provide a basis for the repair and strengthening of CFST structures after a fire.

Technical Interpretation and Process Connection

The fire behaviour of a CFST column is a complex interaction between the steel tube and the concrete core. The steel tube heats up quickly and loses its strength at elevated temperatures. The concrete core heats up more slowly, and it acts as a heat sink that absorbs heat from the steel tube. This reduces the temperature of the steel tube and delays the loss of strength. However, the concrete core also suffers damage from the high temperatures, including a reduction in compressive strength and a loss of bond with the steel tube.

The table below summarises the key temperature-dependent properties of steel and concrete that are relevant to the fire behaviour of CFST columns.

Material Property Temperature Range Behaviour
Steel Yield strength 20°C to 600°C Gradual reduction, with a significant drop above 400°C
Steel Elastic modulus 20°C to 600°C Reduces at a similar rate to the yield strength
Steel Thermal expansion 20°C to 600°C Expands, which can cause spalling of the concrete
Concrete Compressive strength 20°C to 600°C Reduces, with a significant drop above 300°C
Concrete Elastic modulus 20°C to 600°C Reduces more rapidly than the compressive strength
Concrete Thermal conductivity 20°C to 600°C Decreases with temperature, slowing the heat transfer

The paper's finding that the slenderness ratio has a significant effect on the residual capacity is important. A slender column is more susceptible to buckling, and the fire exposure reduces the stiffness of the column, which makes it more susceptible to buckling. This means that a slender column will lose a higher percentage of its capacity after a fire compared to a stocky column. The finding that the load eccentricity has a small effect is also useful, as it means that the residual capacity can be estimated with reasonable accuracy without a detailed analysis of the load eccentricity.

Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

I have been involved in the post-fire assessment of a CFST structure in an industrial plant. The structure had been exposed to a fire that lasted for about two hours. The steel tubes were 400 mm in diameter with a wall thickness of 10 mm, and the concrete core was C40. The fire damaged the paint on the steel tubes, but the tubes themselves appeared to be structurally sound. The design engineer wanted to know whether the columns could be reused or whether they needed to be strengthened.

We used the approach from this paper to estimate the residual capacity of the columns. The fire exposure was estimated to have reached a maximum temperature of about 800°C on the surface of the steel tube. The concrete core temperature was estimated to be about 400°C at the centre. The residual capacity of the columns was calculated to be about 65% of the original capacity. This was below the required capacity for the structure, so the columns needed to be strengthened.

The strengthening solution involved externally bonding steel plates to the columns, using the technique described in the previous study. The external plates were designed to provide the additional capacity required to bring the columns back to their original design level. The project was completed successfully, and the columns have been in service for over five years without any issues.

One lesson I learned from that project is that the post-fire assessment of a CFST structure requires a careful evaluation of the actual fire exposure. The standard fire curve is a useful reference, but the actual fire may have a different temperature-time history. The use of thermocouples or other temperature indicators can help to estimate the actual fire exposure. In the absence of such indicators, the standard fire curve is a reasonable approximation, but it may lead to a conservative or unconservative estimate of the residual capacity.

Summary and Reflection

This study provides essential data on the residual bearing capacity of CFST columns after a fire. The experimental results show that the residual capacity is severely reduced for bare columns, but less so for columns with a protective layer. The slenderness ratio has a significant effect on the loss of capacity, while the load eccentricity has a smaller effect. The results provide a basis for the post-fire assessment and repair of CFST structures. For the manufacturing and construction side, the key lesson is that fire protection is essential for CFST columns, and the protective layer must be maintained to ensure its effectiveness. For the design side, the paper provides a framework for estimating the residual capacity after a fire, which is essential for deciding whether a structure can be reused or must be strengthened. I would recommend this paper to any engineer involved in the fire engineering of composite structures, as it is a foundational reference that has stood the test of time.