ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Creep Prediction Model for Concrete-Filled Steel Tubes: A Practical Assessment

What the Paper Really Says

Cao Guohui and his colleagues from Hunan City University and Changsha University of Science and Technology have taken on the thorny problem of predicting the creep of concrete-filled steel tubes (CFST). They conducted a long-term test on eight cylindrical specimens over 870 days in a controlled indoor environment. Based on the results, they proposed a new prediction model that divides the total creep strain into three components: recoverable delayed elastic deformation, irrecoverable initial rapid plastic deformation, and irrecoverable viscous flow. This is based on the principle of superposition and the theory of viscoelasticity, adapted for the multiaxial stress state that exists in a CFST under axial compression.

Core Findings and Their Engineering Significance

The most important finding is that the creep deformation of CFST stabilizes after about 100 days, which is much earlier than the stabilization time for ordinary concrete. This is a significant practical advantage. The steel tube provides confinement, which restricts the lateral expansion of the concrete core, and it also carries a portion of the axial load, which reduces the stress level in the concrete. Both effects contribute to the reduced creep. The proposed model is simple and has a good fit with the test data, which makes it suitable for design use. The authors divide the creep into three components, which is a more physically meaningful approach than a simple power-law curve fit.

Creep Component Physical Meaning Time Dependency Practical Implication
Recoverable delayed elastic Viscoelastic recovery Short-term (days to weeks) Contributes to initial deformation, partially recoverable
Irrecoverable initial rapid plastic Immediate plastic flow Very short-term (hours to days) Occurs during initial loading, must be accounted for in prestress
Irrecoverable viscous flow Long-term viscous creep Long-term (months to years) Dominant component after 100 days, affects long-term deflection

Plant Floor and Site Reality

This is a topic that has a direct impact on the construction of long-span CFST bridges and high-rise buildings. I have been involved in several projects where the creep of the concrete core caused significant issues. In a tied-arch bridge, the creep of the concrete in the arch ribs leads to an increase in the arch deflection and a redistribution of the internal forces between the steel tube and the concrete. This can cause the steel tube to yield prematurely if the creep is underestimated. The paper's finding that creep stabilizes after 100 days is very useful for construction scheduling. It means that if you can delay the application of the secondary dead load (such as the bridge deck) until after 100 days, you can avoid a significant portion of the creep-induced deformation. In practice, this is not always possible, so the engineer must use a prediction model that is accurate for the entire time history.

Standards and Judgment

The paper proposes a new model, but it does not compare it directly to the models in existing codes, such as the ACI 209 model or the CEB-FIP model. This is a gap. In my experience, the existing code models are calibrated for ordinary reinforced concrete, and they tend to overestimate the creep of CFST because they do not account for the confinement effect and the load sharing between the steel and concrete. The proposed model is a step in the right direction, but it needs to be validated against a wider range of test data, including different concrete strengths, different steel tube dimensions, and different environmental conditions. The test in the paper was conducted in a controlled indoor environment, which is not representative of outdoor conditions where temperature and humidity variations can have a significant effect on creep.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper's model is based on the principle of superposition, which assumes that the creep is linear with respect to the applied stress. This is a reasonable assumption for stress levels below about 40 percent of the concrete's ultimate strength, which is the typical range for CFST in practice. However, for high stress levels, the creep becomes nonlinear, and the model would need to be modified. The paper also does not address the effect of shrinkage, which is a separate phenomenon but is often coupled with creep in practice. In a CFST, the shrinkage of the concrete is largely prevented by the steel tube, which is a benefit, but it can also lead to a loss of bond at the interface if the concrete pulls away from the steel. The paper's model is a valuable contribution, but it should be used with caution for high-stress applications.

Lessons and Outlook

This study provides a practical tool for predicting the long-term deformation of CFST members. For the design engineer, the key takeaway is that the creep of CFST is significantly less than that of ordinary concrete, and it stabilizes much earlier. This means that the long-term deflection of a CFST bridge or building is less of a concern than for a conventional concrete structure. However, the engineer must still account for the redistribution of internal forces between the steel and concrete over time. The proposed model is simple enough for design office use, but it should be validated against more experimental data. I would recommend that the research community develop a standardized database of CFST creep tests, which would allow for the calibration and verification of different models. This would be a significant contribution to the field.