Deformation and Spallation of Steel Tubes Under Internal Explosive Loading: Lessons for Dynamic Design
Overview of the Study
This paper by Li Xuemei, Jin Xiaogang, Li Dahong and Hu Shisheng from the University of Science and Technology of China and the China Academy of Engineering Physics investigates the deformation and spallation behavior of 20 steel tubes under a sliding internal detonation loading using liquid explosive. The study is part of a broader research effort to understand the response of cylindrical structures to internal blast loading, which is relevant to a wide range of applications, including pressure vessels, pipelines, and protective structures. The experiments used different explosive thicknesses and different confinement conditions, and the results were analyzed in terms of the radial strain, the deformation uniformity, and the presence of spallation damage.
Experimental Findings and Deformation Characteristics
The experimental results show that the 20 steel tubes underwent significant radial strain, with the strain magnitude increasing approximately linearly with the explosive thickness. For explosive thicknesses of 3 mm and above, the deformation was uniform and axisymmetric, which indicates that the loading was evenly distributed around the circumference. However, for explosive thicknesses below 3 mm, the deformation was no longer axisymmetric, and the tube surface exhibited torsional wrinkles. This transition from uniform to non-uniform deformation is a key finding, as it suggests that the loading mechanism changes at a critical explosive thickness.
The most surprising result is that no spallation damage was observed in any of the tests, despite the expectation that the high strain rate and the reflection of the stress wave from the inner surface would cause spallation. The authors provide a preliminary analysis of the reasons for the absence of spallation, which I will discuss in the next section.
Material Behavior Under High Strain Rates
Spallation is a dynamic fracture phenomenon that occurs when a tensile stress wave is generated by the reflection of a compressive stress wave from a free surface. The tensile stress must exceed the dynamic tensile strength of the material, which is typically higher than the static tensile strength due to the strain rate effect. In the case of a steel tube under internal explosive loading, the compressive stress wave travels from the inner surface to the outer surface, and upon reflection, it becomes a tensile wave that can cause spallation near the outer surface.
The absence of spallation in these tests can be attributed to several factors:
- The explosive loading was a sliding detonation, which means that the detonation front travels along the length of the tube rather than detonating simultaneously along the entire circumference. This creates a complex stress wave pattern that may not produce a sufficiently high tensile stress at the outer surface.
- The steel tube had a relatively thick wall, which may have attenuated the stress wave before it reached the outer surface. The stress wave amplitude decreases with distance due to geometric spreading and material damping.
- The 20 steel is a ductile material with a high fracture toughness, which makes it resistant to spallation. The dynamic tensile strength of 20 steel is significantly higher than the static value, but the material can still absorb a significant amount of energy before fracture.
The transition from axisymmetric to non-axisymmetric deformation at explosive thicknesses below 3 mm is also worth noting. This suggests that at low explosive thicknesses, the detonation front does not produce a uniform pressure distribution, and the tube deforms in a more complex manner. The torsional wrinkles observed on the tube surface indicate that the loading had a significant shear component, which is consistent with a sliding detonation front that produces a helical stress wave pattern.
Practical Implications for Dynamic Design
From a practical standpoint, this study provides valuable data on the response of steel tubes to internal blast loading, which is relevant to the design of blast-resistant structures and the assessment of damaged pipelines. The key lessons are:
- The deformation of a steel tube under internal blast loading is primarily governed by the explosive charge weight and the tube wall thickness. The linear relationship between explosive thickness and radial strain provides a simple design tool for estimating the deformation of similar tubes.
- The absence of spallation in these tests suggests that spallation may not be the governing failure mode for steel tubes with moderate wall thickness under sliding detonation loading. However, this does not mean that spallation cannot occur under different loading conditions, such as a simultaneous detonation along the entire length of the tube.
- The transition from axisymmetric to non-axisymmetric deformation at low explosive thicknesses is a warning that the loading uniformity cannot be assumed for all charge weights. Designers must consider the possibility of non-uniform deformation and the resulting stress concentrations.
- The 20 steel tube, despite being a relatively low-strength material, showed good deformation capacity without fracture. This is a testament to the ductility of carbon steel, which allows it to absorb significant energy before failure.
For the inspection and repair of blast-damaged steel tubes, the following points are important:
- Visual inspection should focus on the deformation pattern, particularly the presence of wrinkles, which indicate non-uniform loading and potential local stress concentrations.
- Ultrasonic thickness measurement should be performed to detect any wall thinning due to the deformation. The thinning is typically most pronounced at the mid-span of the tube, where the radial strain is highest.
- Hardness testing can be used to assess the strain hardening of the steel. The deformed region will have a higher hardness than the undeformed material, which indicates that the material has been work-hardened and may have reduced ductility.
- If the deformation is severe, the tube may need to be replaced rather than repaired. The repair of a blast-damaged tube is challenging because the deformed geometry may not be suitable for welding, and the residual stresses from the deformation can cause distortion during repair.
Summary
This study provides a detailed experimental investigation of the deformation and spallation behavior of 20 steel tubes under internal explosive loading. The key findings are the linear relationship between explosive thickness and radial strain, the transition from axisymmetric to non-axisymmetric deformation at low explosive thicknesses, and the absence of spallation in all tests. The practical implications for dynamic design are significant, particularly for the design of blast-resistant structures and the assessment of damaged pipelines. The absence of spallation is a reassuring result, but it should not be generalized to all loading conditions. The material behavior of 20 steel under high strain rates is well characterized by this study, and the data can be used to validate numerical models for predicting the response of similar structures. For engineers involved in the design or assessment of blast-resistant structures, this paper is a valuable reference, but it should be complemented with additional tests for different tube materials and wall thicknesses to establish a broader design database. In my experience, the most important lesson from this type of study is that the loading mechanism is critical to the failure mode, and the assumption of uniform loading is not always valid. The design must account for the actual loading conditions, including the possibility of non-uniform deformation and the resulting stress concentrations.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd