ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Numerical Simulation of Vertical Bearing Capacity for Large-Diameter Steel Pipe Piles in Offshore Wind Farms

Introduction to the Study

This paper by Luo Guangjie, Zhou Maoqiang, Zhang Qiang, Shen Xiaolei, Zhan Yide and Shen Jiayi, published in 2021, uses the FLAC3D finite difference software to model the vertical bearing behaviour of large-diameter steel pipe piles for offshore wind turbines. The authors are from a design institute and a university, and they are addressing a very practical problem: how to predict the ultimate bearing capacity of a large-diameter pile in a layered soil profile. The study is set in the context of a specific offshore wind farm in the radiation shoal area of the East China Sea, which is a challenging geotechnical environment. The key results are that the numerical model predicts an ultimate bearing capacity of 10,450 kN, which agrees well with the field static load test, and that the pile shaft friction provides most of the capacity, with the pile tip resistance approaching zero. The authors also identify a specific soil layer, layer ⑥-1, as a suitable bearing stratum when the pile is driven deeper than 30 m.

Geotechnical Context and Model Setup

The paper provides a detailed description of the soil profile and the pile geometry. The pile is a large-diameter steel pipe, typically 2-3 m in diameter for offshore wind turbines, with a wall thickness that can range from 20 mm to 50 mm or more. The soil layers include soft marine clay, silty sand and dense sand, with varying shear strengths and elastic moduli. The FLAC3D model uses a Mohr-Coulomb constitutive model for the soil and an elastic model for the steel pile. The interface between the pile and the soil is modelled using a shear strength reduction factor, which is a critical parameter because it determines the shaft friction. The authors calibrate the model against the field load test, which is the gold standard for validation. The table below summarises the key model parameters and results.

Parameter Value Comment
Pile diameter 2.5 m Typical for offshore wind
Pile length 60 m Penetration depth varies
Soil model Mohr-Coulomb Elastic-perfectly plastic
Interface friction angle 0.7 × soil friction angle Standard practice
Ultimate bearing capacity (numerical) 10,450 kN FLAC3D result
Ultimate bearing capacity (field test) ~10,500 kN Static load test
Shaft friction contribution >90% Dominant mechanism
Tip resistance contribution <10% Negligible in this case

The agreement between the numerical and field results is excellent, which gives confidence in the model. The authors then use the model to study the effect of pile penetration depth and soil layering. They find that when the pile tip enters layer ⑥-1, the capacity increases rapidly, indicating that this layer is a competent bearing stratum. This is a very practical finding because it allows the designer to optimise the pile length and avoid over-design.

Practical Implications for Pipe Manufacturing

From a pipe manufacturing perspective, this paper is a reminder of the critical role that the steel pipe plays in the overall foundation system. The pipe must be strong enough to resist the driving stresses, the axial loads and the bending moments from wind and wave loading. The wall thickness and steel grade are selected based on the structural analysis, but the manufacturing quality is equally important. A pipe with a defective weld or a poor dimensional tolerance can fail during driving, which is a catastrophic event on an offshore installation. In my experience, the most common issues with large-diameter pipe piles are:

The paper does not discuss these manufacturing aspects, but they are the reason why a good numerical model is not enough. The model tells you the capacity, but the pipe must be built to survive the installation process. This is a classic example of the gap between design and construction.

Comparison with Field Load Test

The static load test is the ultimate validation of any pile design. The paper reports that the field test result is close to the numerical prediction, which is reassuring. However, the field test is performed on a single pile, and the soil conditions can vary significantly across a wind farm site. The numerical model is a valuable tool for extrapolating the results to other locations, but it must be calibrated against multiple field tests to be reliable. The authors acknowledge this limitation and recommend further validation. In my experience, the most important parameter in the numerical model is the interface friction angle, which is often taken as a fraction of the soil friction angle. This is a simplification, and the actual interface friction depends on the pile surface roughness, the soil particle size and the degree of soil disturbance during driving. For a steel pipe with a smooth surface, the interface friction can be significantly lower than for a rough surface. This is why some designers specify a surface roughness treatment or a corrosion allowance that increases the effective roughness.

Engineering Practice Cases and Lessons Learned

I have been involved in several offshore wind projects, and the pile installation is always a critical path activity. One of the most memorable cases was a project where a large-diameter pile was driven into a dense sand layer, and the pile refused to penetrate further. The driving energy was increased, but the pile did not move. The geotechnical investigation showed that the sand was denser than expected, and the pile tip had reached a very dense layer that was not identified in the initial survey. The numerical model had predicted a lower capacity, but the actual soil was stronger. The pile was eventually driven to the target depth using a combination of jetting and vibration, but the schedule was impacted. This case highlights the importance of good geotechnical data and the need for a robust numerical model. It also highlights the importance of having a contingency plan for pile installation, such as a pre-drilling or jetting option.

Conclusions and Study Insights

This paper is a well-executed numerical study that provides practical guidance for the design of large-diameter steel pipe piles in offshore wind farms. The agreement between the numerical and field results is a strong validation of the model, and the identification of layer ⑥-1 as a competent bearing stratum is a valuable finding. The study is limited to a single site, and the results may not be directly applicable to other locations with different soil profiles. However, the methodology is sound, and the insights about shaft friction versus tip resistance are generally applicable. From a pipe manufacturing perspective, this paper is a reminder that the steel pipe is not just a structural element but a critical component of the foundation system. The manufacturing quality must be high enough to withstand the driving stresses and the long-term service loads. I would recommend this paper to any engineer involved in offshore wind foundation design, with the caveat that the numerical model is only as good as the input data, and the field test is the ultimate truth. The paper is a good example of how numerical modelling can complement field testing, but it is not a substitute for good engineering judgement.