ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Ultimate Bearing Capacity of Square-Outside Round-Inside Hollow Sandwich CFST Columns: A Manufacturing Perspective

Literature Overview and Structural Concept

The paper by Zhang Changguang and colleagues addresses the ultimate bearing capacity of a specific type of composite column: the square-outside, round-inside hollow sandwich concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) column. The authors derive a theoretical formula for the ultimate axial bearing capacity of short columns based on the unified strength theory, introducing a concrete strength reduction factor and an equivalent confinement reduction factor to transform the square-outside, round-inside section into an equivalent round-outside, round-inside section. The formula is then validated against experimental results from the literature.

This is a fascinating structural concept that has significant manufacturing implications. The hollow sandwich CFST column consists of an outer square steel tube, an inner round steel tube, and concrete filled in the annular space between them. This configuration offers several advantages: the outer square tube provides a flat surface for connecting to beams and walls, the inner round tube provides confinement to the concrete, and the hollow core reduces the weight of the column while maintaining a high load-carrying capacity. However, the manufacturing of such a column is challenging, as it requires precise fabrication of both the outer square tube and the inner round tube, and careful placement of the concrete in the annular space.

Technical Interpretation: Unified Strength Theory and Equivalent Conversion

The unified strength theory is a general yield criterion that can be reduced to the Tresca and von Mises criteria under certain conditions. The authors use the thick-walled cylinder solution based on the unified strength theory as a starting point, then introduce two reduction factors to account for the differences between the square-outside and round-outside sections. The concrete strength reduction factor accounts for the fact that the concrete in a square section is less effectively confined than in a circular section, due to the corners where the confinement is less effective. The equivalent confinement reduction factor accounts for the reduced confinement provided by the square tube compared to a circular tube of the same area.

The resulting formula is relatively simple and can be used for design calculations. The validation against experimental results shows good agreement, confirming the correctness and feasibility of the theoretical approach. For practicing engineers, the formula provides a quick and reliable method for estimating the ultimate bearing capacity of these columns, which is essential for design optimization.

Parameter Value Significance
Concrete strength reduction factor Less than 1.0 Accounts for reduced confinement in square section
Equivalent confinement reduction factor Less than 1.0 Accounts for reduced confinement efficiency of square tube
Predicted capacity vs. experimental Good agreement Validates theoretical approach

Practical Implications for Fabrication and Concrete Filling

The manufacturing of square-outside, round-inside hollow sandwich CFST columns is a multi-step process that requires careful coordination between the steel fabricator and the concrete contractor. The outer square tube is typically fabricated from steel plate by forming and welding, while the inner round tube is a seamless or welded pipe. The two tubes are then assembled concentrically, with spacers or stiffeners used to maintain the annular gap.

One of the critical challenges is ensuring the concentricity of the two tubes. If the inner tube is not properly centered, the concrete fill will be uneven, leading to a non-uniform cross-section and reduced load-carrying capacity. In my experience, the most reliable method is to use welded spacers at regular intervals, which also serve as shear connectors between the steel and concrete. However, the spacers must be designed to not obstruct the concrete flow, and the concrete must be placed using a method that ensures complete filling of the annular space.

Another challenge is the welding of the outer square tube. The corners of the square tube are high-stress areas, and the welds must be of high quality to ensure the tube acts as a unified section. In practice, the square tube is often fabricated by bending a flat plate into a U-shape and then welding the final seam. The weld at the corner is subjected to high bending stresses, and any defects can lead to premature failure. The theoretical formula in this paper assumes a perfect square section, but in reality, the corners have a finite radius, which affects the stress distribution and the confinement of the concrete.

Field Experience and Design Considerations

I have seen several projects where hollow sandwich CFST columns were used, and the lessons from those projects are directly relevant to the findings of this paper. The theoretical formula provides a good estimate of the ultimate bearing capacity, but it is important to consider the effects of construction tolerances. The outer square tube may have some ovality or bowing, the inner round tube may not be perfectly circular, and the concrete may not be fully compacted in the corners. These factors can reduce the actual capacity by 5–10% compared to the theoretical value.

The design of the column must also consider the connection details at the top and bottom. The hollow core creates a challenge for connecting the column to the beams and the foundation. In practice, the column is often filled with concrete at the connections, or a steel plate is welded across the top and bottom to transfer the loads. The theoretical formula in this paper is for short columns under axial compression, but in real structures, the columns are subjected to combined axial and bending loads, which reduces the capacity. The engineer must use the formula as a starting point and then apply appropriate reduction factors for the actual loading conditions.

Concluding Remarks

This paper makes a valuable contribution to the understanding of hollow sandwich CFST columns by providing a theoretical formula for the ultimate bearing capacity of square-outside, round-inside sections. The formula, based on the unified strength theory and validated against experimental results, is a practical tool for design calculations. For manufacturers, the paper highlights the importance of precise fabrication and careful concrete placement to achieve the theoretical capacity.

The hollow sandwich CFST column is an innovative structural element that offers significant advantages in terms of weight reduction and load-carrying capacity. However, its successful application depends on the quality of fabrication and construction. As we continue to develop more advanced composite structures, the integration of theoretical analysis, experimental validation, and practical experience will be essential to ensure that these structures perform as intended. This paper is a good example of how theoretical research can inform practical design and construction, and I would recommend it to any engineer involved in the design or fabrication of CFST columns.