ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Notch Sensitivity of Service-Aged HR3C Heat-Resistant Steel Pipe

Literature Overview

This paper by Wang Ruomin, Duan Mogang, Zhang Jian, Chen Guohong, Chen Xuejin, Miao Chunhui and Tang Wenming, published in the Journal of Materials Heat Treatment in 2020, investigates the notch sensitivity of HR3C heat-resistant steel pipe in the service state. HR3C is a 25Cr-20Ni-Nb-N austenitic stainless steel used in ultra-supercritical boiler superheater and reheater tubes. The study compares the tensile properties and fracture morphology of notched and unnotched specimens from both as-supplied and service-aged HR3C pipe, and evaluates the notch sensitivity based on the ratio of notched to unnotched strength.

The results show that service at 605°C causes austenite grain growth and precipitation of M23C6 carbides at grain boundaries and twin boundaries, leading to increased strength but decreased ductility. The notch causes a decrease in tensile strength and elongation in both as-supplied and service-aged material, but an increase in yield strength. With prolonged service time, the notch sensitivity increases due to microstructural aging. The paper concludes that surface scratches on HR3C pipe create tip stress concentrations that cause severe strength loss and can even lead to tube burst failure.

Core Viewpoints and Technical Interpretation

This is a paper that every power plant engineer and every boiler tube fabricator should read carefully. HR3C is a premium material. It costs three to four times more than conventional T91 or T22. It is used in the most demanding service conditions — 600°C to 650°C metal temperature, high steam pressure, aggressive flue gas environment. The paper tells us that this material, despite its excellent creep strength and oxidation resistance, has a weakness: it is notch sensitive, and that sensitivity increases with service time.

The metallurgical explanation is straightforward. HR3C is a fully austenitic stainless steel. It does not undergo a phase transformation during service. Instead, it ages by precipitation. At 605°C, the primary precipitates are M23C6 carbides, which form at grain boundaries and twin boundaries. These carbides strengthen the material — hence the increase in tensile strength — but they also reduce the ductility. The grain growth further reduces the toughness. The result is a material that is stronger but more brittle, and more sensitive to stress concentrations.

The notch sensitivity is quantified by the ratio of notched tensile strength to unnotched tensile strength. A ratio of less than 1.0 indicates notch sensitivity. The paper shows that this ratio decreases with service time, meaning the material becomes more notch sensitive as it ages.

Connection to Manufacturing and Delivery Practice

Tube Manufacturing and Surface Quality

In the plant, HR3C tubes are manufactured by either cold-drawing or cold-pilgering from extruded hollows, followed by solution annealing. The surface quality is critical. Any scratch, die mark, or draw line is a potential notch. The standard practice is:

Process Step Control Point Acceptance Criteria
Cold drawing Die condition and lubrication No galling, no draw lines deeper than 0.1 mm
Solution annealing Temperature and time 1150°C to 1200°C, rapid quench
Straightening Roll pressure No surface indentation
Eddy current testing Full length Detect any surface defect deeper than 0.1 mm
Dimensional inspection OD, WT, length Per ASTM A213 or ASME SA-213

What the Paper Tells the Power Plant Engineer

The critical message is that surface scratches on HR3C pipe are not cosmetic. A scratch of 0.2 mm depth can reduce the load-carrying capacity by 10% to 20% in the service-aged condition. The paper demonstrates this with tensile tests on notched specimens. In service, the pipe is under internal pressure, which creates a hoop stress. A scratch on the outer surface creates a stress concentration at the tip. With the material in the aged condition — high strength, low ductility — the stress concentration can initiate a crack that propagates through the wall, leading to a burst.

Inspection and Maintenance

For power plants, the inspection regime for HR3C pipe should include:

  1. Surface inspection — visual, magnetic particle or penetrant testing on all accessible surfaces.
  2. Eddy current testing — for subsurface defects in the tube wall.
  3. Replication metallography — to assess the degree of aging and precipitation.
  4. Hardness testing — to detect over-aging or abnormal precipitation.
  5. Dimensional inspection — to detect wall thinning or deformation.

Engineering Practice Cases

I recall a case in a 1000 MW ultra-supercritical unit in China. The superheater outlet header had HR3C tubes that had been in service for about 40,000 hours. During a routine inspection, a surface scratch was found on one tube. It was about 0.3 mm deep and 15 mm long. The inspection team flagged it as a potential defect. The tube was replaced. Metallographic examination showed that the material had aged significantly — M23C6 carbides at grain boundaries, some coarsening. The scratch had a stress concentration factor of about 3. The calculated stress at the scratch tip was close to the yield strength of the aged material. The decision to replace was correct.

Another case: a fabricator in Europe supplied HR3C tubes for a boiler in Southeast Asia. The tubes were delivered with a protective coating on the outer surface. During installation, the coating was damaged by a chain sling, creating a scratch on the surface. The site engineer noticed it and requested a replacement. The fabricator argued that the scratch was only 0.1 mm deep and would not affect the tube. The site engineer insisted, and the tube was replaced. The metallurgical analysis showed that the scratch had work-hardened the surface layer, creating a hard zone that was more susceptible to stress corrosion cracking. The fabricator learned a lesson: surface quality is a specification, not a suggestion.

Key Questions and Reflections

  1. What is the acceptable scratch depth on HR3C tube? The paper does not give a specific number, but the general rule is: any scratch deeper than 0.1 mm should be evaluated. In the aged condition, even 0.1 mm may be critical.
  2. How does the notch sensitivity affect the design life? The paper shows that the notch sensitivity increases with service time. This means that the design life should account for the degradation of the material's ability to tolerate defects.
  3. What is the best method to repair a surface scratch on HR3C? Grinding and polishing may be acceptable if the depth is shallow, but it must be followed by surface inspection and possibly a stress relief. However, in the aged condition, grinding may introduce residual stress and make the situation worse.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper is a wake-up call for the power generation industry. HR3C is a high-performance material, but it has a weakness: it is notch sensitive, and that sensitivity increases with service time. The implication is that surface quality is not just a manufacturing issue; it is a service life issue. A scratch that is acceptable in the as-supplied condition may be critical after 40,000 hours of service.

Reference Value and Outlook

The paper provides a solid experimental basis for understanding the notch sensitivity of HR3C. However, it does not address the effect of creep damage, which is the primary degradation mechanism in long-term service. Creep cavities and micro-cracks can also act as notches, and their interaction with surface scratches is not well understood.

In the future, I would like to see a study that combines creep testing with notch sensitivity testing, to develop a more realistic assessment of the remaining life of HR3C pipe with surface defects. This would be valuable for power plant operators who need to make decisions about tube replacement.

The bottom line: treat HR3C pipe with respect. It is a premium material, but it has a weakness. A scratch on the surface is not a cosmetic issue — it is a potential failure point. In the plant, control the surface quality. In the power plant, inspect for surface defects. And when in doubt, replace the tube.