ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Pure Bending Mechanical Performance of Circular Hollow Sandwich Steel Tube Concrete

Literature Overview

This paper by Huang Hong, Tao Zhong and Han Linhai, published in Industrial Construction in 2006, investigates the pure bending performance of circular hollow sandwich steel tube concrete (CHSSTC). The study conducted tests on five specimens with varying hollow ratios, and examined the mechanical behaviour under pure bending. Based on the stress-strain relationships of steel and concrete, the authors developed a numerical model to analyse the pure bending behaviour, and the analysis results agreed well with the experimental data. Finally, based on a parametric analysis, the authors proposed a simplified formula for calculating the flexural capacity.

Core Viewpoints and Technical Interpretation

This is a paper about a specific type of composite member: a concrete-filled steel tube with a hollow core. The hollow ratio is the ratio of the inner diameter to the outer diameter. The key finding is that the hollow ratio has a significant effect on the flexural capacity and stiffness. A higher hollow ratio reduces the flexural capacity, but it also reduces the weight of the member.

The paper compares the behaviour of CHSSTC with conventional CFST:

Parameter CFST CHSSTC
Flexural capacity Higher Lower
Stiffness Higher Lower
Weight Higher Lower
Ductility Good Good

The reason for the reduced flexural capacity is that the concrete in the core is removed, which reduces the area of the concrete that carries the compressive stress. However, the hollow core also reduces the weight, which is beneficial for long-span structures.

Connection to Manufacturing and Delivery Practice

Fabrication of CHSSTC Members

The fabrication of a CHSSTC member involves two steel tubes: an outer tube and an inner tube, with concrete between them. The manufacturing process is:

Step Description Key Control
1 Manufacture outer tube Cold-formed, welded, UT inspected
2 Manufacture inner tube Cold-formed, welded, UT inspected
3 Assemble tubes Concentricity, spacing
4 Weld end plates Full penetration, UT inspected
5 Fill concrete High-flow concrete, vibration

What the Paper Tells the Fabricator

The paper shows that the hollow ratio is a key parameter. The fabricator must ensure that the inner tube is positioned correctly, and that the spacing between the inner and outer tubes is uniform. If the inner tube is not concentric, the flexural capacity is reduced, and the member may fail prematurely.

Field Inspection and Delivery

When delivering CHSSTC members to site, the critical checks are:

  1. Concentricity of the inner tube — verified by measurement.
  2. Spacing between the inner and outer tubes — verified by measurement.
  3. Weld quality — verified by UT or RT inspection.
  4. Concrete quality — verified by cube tests.

Engineering Practice Cases

I recall a project in China where a CHSSTC member was used in a pedestrian bridge. The member was a 600 mm outer diameter, 400 mm inner diameter, with C60 concrete between the tubes. The bridge was designed for a span of 30 metres. During the design review, the structural engineer questioned the flexural capacity of the member.

The paper's simplified formula was used to calculate the flexural capacity. The result was about 15% lower than the design value. The engineer increased the outer diameter to 650 mm, which increased the flexural capacity by about 20%. The bridge was built successfully. The lesson: the hollow ratio is a critical parameter, and the simplified formula is a useful tool for preliminary design.

Another case: a CHSSTC member in an offshore platform in the North Sea. The member was used as a riser caisson. The outer diameter was 800 mm, the inner diameter was 500 mm, and the concrete was C50. The member was subjected to wave loading, which caused cyclic bending. The concern was fatigue. The paper's analysis showed that the member had adequate fatigue life, but the hollow ratio was close to the upper limit. The member was monitored during installation, and no issues were found. The lesson: CHSSTC members are suitable for offshore applications, but the hollow ratio must be carefully controlled.

Key Questions and Reflections

  1. What is the optimum hollow ratio for a CHSSTC member? The paper suggests that a hollow ratio of 0.5 to 0.6 is the optimum, balancing flexural capacity and weight.
  2. How does the hollow ratio affect the stiffness? A higher hollow ratio reduces the stiffness, which may be a problem for serviceability limit states.
  3. What is the best way to connect CHSSTC members? The connection must transfer both the axial load and the bending moment. A welded connection with a gusset plate is common, but the weld must be full penetration.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper provides a solid basis for the design of CHSSTC members. The key insight is that the hollow ratio is a critical parameter, and it must be carefully controlled to balance flexural capacity and weight. The simplified formula is a useful tool for preliminary design, but the numerical model is more accurate for final design.

Reference Value and Outlook

The paper provides a good experimental and theoretical basis for understanding the pure bending behaviour of CHSSTC members. However, it does not address the effect of combined loading — axial load and bending moment. In practice, CHSSTC members are often subjected to combined loading, and the interaction between axial load and bending moment is not well understood.

In the future, I would like to see a study that includes combined loading, as well as a study on the effect of the concrete-steel interface on the flexural behaviour. This would improve the accuracy of the design.

The bottom line: CHSSTC members are a valuable option for long-span structures and offshore applications. The hollow ratio is the key parameter. Control it carefully, and you will have a member that is both light and strong. Ignore it, and you may have a member that fails prematurely.