ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Hydration Heat in Winter CFST Arch Ribs: Managing Thermal Stress

The Problem as I Have Seen It

Xuan, Xiang and Lu's paper from 2010 addresses a problem that I have personally dealt with on several winter construction projects: the hydration heat of the concrete inside a CFST arch rib creates a temperature field that can cause cracking, both in the concrete and in the steel tube. The paper focuses on the Changshan Nanmenxi Bridge, a CFST basket-handle arch bridge where the arch ribs are constructed as bundled CFST sections. Because the concrete occupies a large proportion of the cross-section and the steel tube is relatively thin, the heat generated by the cement hydration cannot dissipate quickly, leading to a significant temperature rise and a corresponding thermal gradient.

The paper uses LUSAS finite element software to model the temperature field and the resulting thermal stresses. The key finding is that during winter construction, the temperature gradient is large, and the thermal stresses are significant enough to cause concern. The paper recommends that the effects be considered in both the construction and monitoring processes.

From my experience, this is not just a theoretical concern. I have seen CFST arch ribs develop longitudinal cracks in the concrete during the first 24 hours after pouring, simply because the temperature differential between the core and the surface exceeded the tensile strength of the young concrete. I have also seen the steel tube develop local buckling at the top of the arch, where the thermal expansion of the concrete pushed the tube outward while the surrounding air temperature was below freezing. The combination of hydration heat and cold ambient temperature is a recipe for trouble.

What the Shop Floor and the Delivery Site Actually Care About

The paper's analysis is useful, but the practical implications are what matter to me. First, the concrete mix design must be adjusted for winter construction. That means using a low-heat cement, or a cement with a lower tricalcium aluminate content, to reduce the total heat of hydration. It also means using a lower water-cement ratio to reduce the amount of cement needed, and adding a retarder to slow the hydration reaction. I have specified these measures on every winter CFST pour I have supervised, and they have prevented cracking in most cases.

Second, the pour sequence must be carefully planned. If you pour the concrete in a single lift, the heat builds up in the center of the section, and the temperature gradient is maximized. If you pour in multiple lifts, with a time delay between each, the heat from the first lift can dissipate before the second lift is placed. However, multiple lifts create cold joints, which are a different problem. The solution is to use a single lift but to control the temperature rise by adding ice to the mix, or by using a cooling pipe system inside the concrete. I have used both methods, and the cooling pipe system is more reliable, although it is more expensive.

Third, the monitoring system must be in place before the pour. The paper mentions this, and I cannot emphasize it enough. We install thermocouples at multiple depths in the concrete, and we log the temperature every 15 minutes for the first 72 hours after the pour. If the temperature differential between the core and the surface exceeds 20 degrees Celsius, we activate a cooling system or apply insulation to the tube surface. The tube itself is a good heat sink, but it is also a good conductor, so the heat can escape through the tube and create a steep gradient at the steel-concrete interface.

Practical Lessons and My Own Judgment

One thing the paper does not address is the effect of the hydration heat on the steel tube's residual stress. When the concrete heats up, it expands and pushes against the tube, creating a tensile hoop stress in the tube. When the concrete cools, it contracts and pulls away from the tube, leaving a residual tensile stress in the concrete and a residual compressive stress in the tube. This residual stress state can affect the tube's buckling behavior and its fatigue performance. I have seen tubes that were perfectly straight when they left the fabrication shop, but after the concrete pour and the subsequent cooling, they had a visible bow because the thermal expansion had deformed the tube.

Another issue is the effect of the hydration heat on the weld seams of the tube. If the tube is welded from multiple plates, the weld seams are the weakest points. The thermal expansion of the concrete can create a stress concentration at the weld, and if the weld has any defects, such as lack of fusion or porosity, the stress can cause a crack. I have inspected CFST arch ribs after a winter pour and found cracks in the weld seams that were not present before the pour. The cracks were small, but they were enough to require repair, and the repair was expensive because the tube was already filled with concrete.

The paper's recommendation to consider the hydration heat in the construction and monitoring processes is correct, but I would add that the design should also account for the thermal stresses. The design codes typically assume a uniform temperature distribution, which is not realistic for a CFST section. The thermal gradient can create a bending moment in the tube, and that bending moment should be included in the design. I have seen designs where the thermal stress was not considered, and the tube was under-designed by 10% or more.

Study Insights and Implications for Practice

The paper's use of finite element analysis is appropriate, but the model should be calibrated with field data. I have seen models that predicted a maximum temperature rise of 30 degrees Celsius, but the actual measured temperature rise was 45 degrees Celsius. The difference was due to the ambient temperature being lower than assumed, and the concrete mix having a higher cement content than specified. The lesson is that you cannot rely on the model alone; you need to measure the actual temperature and adjust the construction procedures accordingly.

For the steel pipe industry, this paper highlights the importance of the tube's thermal properties. The tube's wall thickness, its thermal conductivity, and its surface condition all affect the heat transfer. A thicker tube will absorb more heat and create a larger temperature gradient. A tube with a rough surface will dissipate heat more slowly than a smooth tube. These factors should be considered when specifying the tube for a CFST application.

I would also note that the paper's focus on winter construction is important, but the same issues arise in summer construction, just in the opposite direction. In summer, the ambient temperature is high, and the concrete may not cool down quickly enough, leading to a different set of problems. The thermal stress management strategy should be tailored to the specific climate and season.

Reference Value and Outlook

This paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in the construction of CFST arch bridges, particularly in cold climates. It provides a methodology for analyzing the temperature field and the resulting stresses, and it highlights the need for careful monitoring during construction. The paper is limited to a single bridge, but the findings are generalizable to other CFST structures.

The industry needs to develop standard procedures for managing hydration heat in CFST sections. These procedures should include mix design requirements, pour sequence specifications, monitoring protocols, and contingency plans for when the temperature exceeds the allowable limit. The paper provides a starting point, but it is not a complete solution.

My final thought is this: hydration heat is a real problem, and it is often underestimated. I have seen it cause cracks, buckling, and weld failures. The paper gives you the tools to analyze it, but you also need the experience to know when to stop pouring and when to start cooling. That experience comes from the shop floor and the construction site, not from the textbook. If you are planning a winter CFST pour, make sure you have someone on your team who has done it before, and make sure you have a monitoring system that works.