Literature Study Note on Creep Analysis of Axially Loaded Concrete-Filled Steel Tube Members
1. Literature Overview and Core Viewpoint
This paper by Wang Yuanfeng and Han Bing from Northern Jiaotong University, published in the China Journal of Highway and Transport (Vol. 13, No. 2, 2000), addresses a critical issue in concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) arch bridges: time-dependent deformation due to concrete creep. The authors derive a creep calculation formula for axially loaded CFST members based on the age-adjusted effective modulus method and the multi-axial stress creep theory, combined with the specific stress characteristics of CFST members. The formula accounts for the unique features of CFST creep — the interaction between the steel tube and the concrete core — and can reflect the effects of different factors including steel ratio, material strength, and stress level on member creep. The calculated creep values from iterative computation agree well with experimental data from the literature.
The core insight is that CFST creep is fundamentally different from plain concrete creep because the steel tube provides confinement and shares the axial load. The steel tube carries a portion of the load, reducing the stress on the concrete core, which in turn reduces creep. However, as creep progresses, the concrete core sheds load to the steel tube, increasing the steel stress and potentially causing yielding. This load transfer mechanism is the key to understanding CFST creep behavior.
2. Technical Points Interpretation
2.1 Theoretical Basis: Age-Adjusted Effective Modulus Method
The paper uses the age-adjusted effective modulus method, which is a refinement of the effective modulus method that accounts for the aging of concrete. The method introduces an aging coefficient that reflects the effect of concrete age on creep. For CFST members, the method is applied to the concrete core, while the steel tube is modeled as an elastic material with no creep.
The basic creep equation for concrete under constant stress is:
| Parameter | Symbol | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Creep strain | ε_cr(t) | Time-dependent strain due to creep |
| Creep coefficient | φ(t, τ) | Ratio of creep strain to elastic strain |
| Aging coefficient | χ(t, τ) | Correction factor for aging effects |
| Effective modulus | E_c,eff | Age-adjusted modulus of concrete |
The effective modulus is calculated as E_c,eff = E_c / (1 + φ(t, τ)), where E_c is the elastic modulus of concrete at the age of loading.
2.2 Multi-Axial Stress Creep Theory
For CFST members, the concrete core is under triaxial stress due to the confinement from the steel tube. The paper incorporates the multi-axial stress creep theory, which accounts for the effect of lateral confinement on creep. Under triaxial compression, the creep strain is reduced compared to uniaxial compression because the lateral confinement restricts the lateral expansion that accompanies creep.
The paper derives the creep formula considering both the axial stress and the lateral confinement stress from the steel tube. The lateral confinement stress is calculated based on the steel tube's hoop stress, which is determined by the axial load sharing between the steel and concrete.
2.3 Factors Affecting CFST Creep
The paper identifies several key factors that influence CFST creep:
| Factor | Effect on Creep | Physical Mechanism |
|---|---|---|
| Steel ratio (α) | Decreases creep | Higher steel ratio means more load carried by steel, less stress on concrete |
| Concrete strength | Decreases creep | Higher strength concrete has lower creep coefficient |
| Stress level (σ/f_c) | Increases creep | Higher stress level leads to more creep strain |
| Confinement | Decreases creep | Lateral confinement restricts creep deformation |
| Age at loading | Decreases creep | Older concrete has lower creep potential |
The steel ratio is particularly important. As the steel ratio increases, the steel tube carries a larger portion of the axial load, reducing the stress on the concrete core. This reduces the creep strain. However, the steel tube also provides confinement, which further reduces creep. The combined effect is a significant reduction in creep for high steel ratios.
2.4 Load Transfer Mechanism
The paper's most valuable contribution is the explicit treatment of the load transfer mechanism. Initially, the axial load is shared between the steel tube and the concrete core based on their respective stiffness. As creep progresses, the concrete core deforms more, and the load is gradually transferred to the steel tube. This load transfer increases the steel stress, which may cause the steel to yield if the load is high enough.
The iterative calculation procedure accounts for this load transfer. At each time step, the creep strain is calculated, the load redistribution is determined, and the new stress state is computed. This iteration continues until convergence is achieved.
3. Integration with Engineering Practice
3.1 Application to CFST Arch Bridges
CFST arch bridges are particularly sensitive to creep because the arch is a statically indeterminate structure. Creep causes the arch to deform, which changes the internal forces and may cause cracking in the concrete core. The paper's formula can be used to predict the long-term deformation of CFST arch bridges and to determine the appropriate construction camber.
In my experience with CFST arch bridges, the construction camber is typically set to compensate for the elastic deformation under dead load plus the creep deformation over time. The creep deformation is often 20–30% of the elastic deformation, which is significant for long-span arches.
3.2 Design Considerations for High-Rise Buildings
For high-rise buildings with CFST columns, creep causes the columns to shorten over time. This differential shortening between CFST columns and other structural elements can cause problems with floor leveling and may induce secondary stresses in the structure. The paper's formula can be used to predict the long-term shortening of CFST columns and to set appropriate compensation.
3.3 Material Selection and Mix Design
The paper's finding that concrete strength affects creep has practical implications for material selection. Higher strength concrete has lower creep, which is beneficial for CFST members. However, higher strength concrete also has higher stiffness, which may increase the initial load share on the concrete core. The design should balance these effects.
4. Key Questions and Reflections
4.1 Is the Age-Adjusted Effective Modulus Method Accurate Enough?
The age-adjusted effective modulus method is a simplification of the more rigorous viscoelastic theory. It assumes that the stress history can be represented by a single effective modulus, which may not capture the full complexity of the creep behavior. However, the method is widely used in practice and has been validated against experimental data. For design purposes, the method is sufficiently accurate.
4.2 What About Long-Term Creep?
The paper's formula is based on the creep coefficient, which is typically defined for a reference period of 50 years. However, CFST structures may have a design life of 100 years or more. The creep coefficient beyond 50 years is not well defined, and the paper's formula may underestimate long-term creep.
4.3 How Does Confinement Affect Creep?
The paper includes the effect of confinement through the multi-axial stress creep theory. However, the confinement stress from the steel tube is not constant — it changes as the load transfers from the concrete to the steel. The paper's iterative procedure accounts for this, but the accuracy depends on the confinement model.
5. Study Insights and Implications
This paper provides a solid theoretical foundation for understanding CFST creep. The key insight is that the steel tube and concrete core work together to resist axial load, and the load transfer mechanism is the dominant factor in creep behavior. The steel ratio is the most important design parameter for controlling creep.
In practice, I have seen CFST columns in high-rise buildings where the steel ratio was too low, leading to excessive creep and differential shortening. The paper's formula would have predicted this problem and allowed the designer to increase the steel ratio.
6. Reference Value and Outlook
This paper is a valuable reference for engineers designing CFST structures, particularly arch bridges and high-rise buildings. The formula is practical and can be implemented in spreadsheet calculations. Future research should extend the formula to include the effects of temperature, humidity, and loading history, which are not fully accounted for in the current model.
The paper's contribution is particularly important for the design of long-span CFST arch bridges, where creep is a critical design parameter. The formula allows designers to predict the long-term deformation and set appropriate construction camber.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd