Investigation and Analysis of Concrete-Filled Steel Tube Arch Bridges: A Veteran's Reading of the Chinese Practice
Literature Overview and What the Survey Tells Us
This paper by Chen Baochun and Yang Yalin, published in World Bridges in 2006, is one of the most cited and most useful survey papers in the Chinese CFST bridge literature. The authors collected basic data on a large number of built and planned concrete-filled steel tube arch bridges in China, and analysed them by quantity, span, structural form, construction method, and material. The result is a snapshot of a rapidly developing technology at a critical point in its evolution, and it is a paper that every engineer involved in CFST bridges should read, not once but twice.
What the survey shows is that China had, by 2006, already become the world leader in CFST arch bridges in terms of both number and span. The technology had moved from the laboratory to the field in a remarkably short time, and the survey documents the range of structural forms that were being used. The dominant form is the through arch, where the deck is suspended from the arch rib by hangers, and the rib is a CFST truss. The second most common form is the deck arch, where the deck is supported on top of the rib. The survey also shows a clear trend towards longer spans, with the largest spans at that time approaching 400 metres.
The construction methods documented in the survey are the part that I find most interesting. The authors describe the use of the swing method, the cable-stayed cantilever method, and the incremental launching method for erecting the arch ribs. These are not trivial operations. A CFST arch rib is a large, heavy, flexible structure, and the erection sequence determines the stress state of the rib during construction. The survey shows that the swing method, where the rib is rotated into position about a hinge at the base, was the most commonly used method for medium spans, while the cable-stayed cantilever method was used for the longer spans.
Technical Parameters and Structural Forms
| Structural Form | Typical Span Range | Construction Method | Practical Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Through arch with CFST truss rib | 100 to 400 m | Swing method or cable-stayed cantilever | The most common form; the truss rib provides good stiffness and allows the concrete to be pumped after the steel is erected. |
| Deck arch with CFST rib | 60 to 200 m | Swing method or scaffolding | The deck is supported on the rib; the rib is more accessible for concrete filling. |
| Half-through arch with CFST rib | 80 to 300 m | Cable-stayed cantilever | A compromise between the through and deck arch forms; the deck is partly suspended and partly supported. |
| Basket-handle arch | 100 to 350 m | Swing method | The two ribs are inclined towards each other; the form is aesthetically pleasing and structurally efficient. |
| Vierendeel arch | 60 to 150 m | Scaffolding or incremental launching | The rib is a Vierendeel frame rather than a truss; used for shorter spans where the truss would be too complex. |
The material data in the survey are also instructive. The steel used for the tubes is typically Q345 or Q390, with a yield strength of 345 to 390 MPa, and the concrete is typically C40 to C60. The tube diameter is usually in the range of 700 to 1200 mm for the main ribs, with a wall thickness of 12 to 20 mm. The diameter-to-thickness ratio is kept below 60 to ensure that the tube is compact and that local buckling does not occur before the concrete reaches its full strength. These are the parameters that a fabricator needs to know when quoting on a CFST arch rib.
Integration With Manufacturing and Delivery Practice
Now let me talk about what this survey means for the plant floor and the delivery site. A CFST arch rib is one of the most demanding steel structures to fabricate. The rib is a curved truss, and the chords are large-diameter steel tubes that must be bent to the required radius. The bending is usually done by induction bending or by cold bending in a press, and the tolerance is tight. A deviation of 10 mm in the chord alignment can cause a significant change in the stress distribution in the rib, and it can make the erection sequence much more difficult.
The welding of the chords to the webs is the second critical fabrication issue. The chords are welded to the web members with full penetration welds, and the weld quality is checked by ultrasonic testing. The weld detail must be designed to avoid a large stress concentration at the chord-web intersection, because the intersection is a hot spot for fatigue under repeated loading. I have seen a CFST arch rib where the weld at the chord-web intersection was undercut, and the undercut initiated a fatigue crack after a few years of service. The repair was expensive and the bridge had to be closed for a month.
The concrete filling is the third issue, and it is the one that the survey does not cover but that is the most important for the performance of the bridge. The concrete is pumped into the tube from the bottom, and the pumping pressure must be controlled to avoid bursting the tube. The concrete must be a self-compacting mix with a high flowability and a low shrinkage. If the concrete shrinks away from the tube wall, the composite action is lost, and the rib will not carry the design load. I have seen a CFST arch rib where the concrete did not reach the top of the tube because the pump pressure was too low, and the top 2 metres of the tube were empty. The defect was detected by ultrasonic testing, but only after the bridge was already in service. The repair involved drilling holes in the tube and injecting grout, which was a difficult and expensive operation.
Key Questions and Reflections
The survey raises a question that I would put to any bridge owner: what is the inspection and maintenance strategy for a CFST arch bridge? The steel tubes are filled with concrete, and the concrete is not visible from the outside. The only way to check the condition of the concrete is to use non-destructive testing methods such as ultrasonic testing, impact echo, or radiography. These methods are expensive and time-consuming, and they are not always reliable for detecting voids or debonding. A bridge owner who does not have a maintenance plan for the concrete filling is taking a significant risk.
The second question is about the fire performance of CFST arch bridges. The steel tubes are protected by the concrete filling, but the concrete is not a perfect insulator. In a fire, the steel tube will heat up, and the concrete will also heat up, but at a slower rate. The differential heating will cause a differential expansion, which can lead to a debonding of the concrete from the tube wall. The survey does not cover fire performance, and I would want to see more research on this topic before I would recommend a CFST arch bridge for a location where a fire is a credible risk.
Study Insights and Implications
This survey is a valuable reference for anyone involved in the design, construction, or maintenance of CFST arch bridges. It documents the state of the art in China at a critical point in the development of the technology, and it provides a clear picture of the structural forms, construction methods, and materials that are used in practice. For the practising engineer, the key takeaways are clear. First, the CFST arch bridge is a mature technology in China, with a proven track record across a wide range of spans and structural forms. Second, the construction methods are well established, but they require careful planning and execution to ensure that the rib is erected safely and that the stress state during construction is controlled. Third, the concrete filling is the critical operation that determines the performance of the bridge, and it requires a high-quality self-compacting mix and a controlled pumping procedure.
I would recommend this survey to any engineer who is considering a CFST arch bridge for a new project. It is a good starting point for understanding the technology, and it provides a useful benchmark for comparing different structural forms and construction methods. But I would also remind the reader that the survey is a snapshot from 2006, and that the technology has moved on. The largest CFST arch bridge in the world, the Pingnan Third Bridge with a span of 575 metres, was completed in 2020, and it uses a higher strength concrete and a more sophisticated construction method than anything documented in the survey. The survey is a foundation, not a final word.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd