ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Axial Compressive Behaviour of Concrete-Filled Double-Skin Steel Tube Columns after Exposure to High Temperature

Overview of the Research

This paper by Liu Xiao, Ma Lu and Wang Bing, published in the Journal of Railway Science and Engineering (2014, Vol. 11, No. 5), investigates the axial compressive performance of concrete-filled double-skin steel tube (CFDST) columns after exposure to high temperature. The authors used numerical simulation, validated against experimental results, to analyse the working mechanism of the columns under axial compression after heating. They examined the effects of temperature, hollow ratio, nominal steel ratio, yield strength of the outer and inner steel tubes, and concrete compressive strength on the mechanical behaviour.

This is a topic that resonates deeply with my experience in the steel pipe industry. I have seen what happens to steel tubes in a fire, and I have inspected structures after fire damage. The double-skin concept, where a concrete core is sandwiched between two steel tubes, is an elegant solution that offers excellent fire resistance and structural efficiency. But the behaviour after a fire is a different matter altogether, and this paper provides valuable insights into that behaviour.

Key Technical Points

The CFDST Concept

A concrete-filled double-skin steel tube column consists of an outer steel tube, an inner steel tube, and a layer of concrete between them. The inner tube can be empty or filled with concrete, depending on the application. The double-skin configuration offers several advantages over a conventional concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) column: it is lighter, has a higher bending stiffness, and provides better fire resistance because the concrete layer acts as a thermal barrier between the outer and inner tubes.

Parameter Range / Level Effect on Ultimate Load Capacity
Temperature (peak exposure) Varied from ambient to high temperature Ultimate capacity decreases with increasing temperature
Hollow ratio Varied Minimal effect on post-fire capacity
Nominal steel ratio Varied Moderate effect; higher steel ratio improves capacity
Outer tube yield strength Varied Significant effect; higher strength increases capacity
Inner tube yield strength Varied Minimal effect
Concrete compressive strength Varied Significant effect at ambient temperature; effect decreases with increasing temperature

The Effect of Temperature

The most important finding is that the ultimate load capacity decreases as the peak temperature increases. This is expected, but the magnitude of the decrease is important to quantify. The paper shows that the loss of capacity is primarily due to the degradation of the concrete strength and the reduction in the yield strength of the steel tubes. The concrete is particularly vulnerable because it undergoes chemical changes at high temperature, including the dehydration of the cement paste and the decomposition of calcium hydroxide, which reduce its strength and stiffness.

The Effect of Steel Yield Strength

The paper found that the yield strength of the outer steel tube has a significant effect on the post-fire capacity, while the yield strength of the inner tube has a minimal effect. This makes sense from a mechanics perspective: the outer tube is the primary load-bearing element, and it is also the one that is most directly exposed to the fire. The inner tube, being shielded by the concrete layer, is less affected by the temperature, and its contribution to the overall capacity is smaller.

The Effect of Concrete Strength

The concrete strength has a significant effect on the capacity at ambient temperature, but the effect decreases as the temperature increases. This is because the concrete degrades more severely at high temperature, and the relative contribution of the concrete to the overall capacity diminishes. This is a crucial insight for design: a high-strength concrete may be beneficial at ambient temperature, but its advantage is largely lost after a fire.

Integration with Engineering Practice

What This Means for the Fire Damage Assessor

As someone who has been called to assess fire-damaged structures, I can tell you that the first question is always: can this structure be repaired, or must it be demolished? The paper provides a useful framework for answering this question. If the peak temperature is known, the residual capacity can be estimated, and the decision can be made based on whether the residual capacity is sufficient for the design loads.

However, determining the peak temperature in a real fire is not straightforward. The temperature distribution in a structure depends on the fire load, the ventilation, the duration of the fire and the thermal properties of the materials. In many cases, the peak temperature is estimated from visual indicators, such as the colour of the steel surface or the extent of concrete spalling. The paper's numerical model can be used to refine these estimates, but it requires knowledge of the fire scenario, which is often uncertain.

What This Means for the Fabricator

The fabrication of CFDST columns requires careful attention to the fit-up between the outer and inner tubes. The gap between the two tubes must be uniform to ensure a consistent concrete layer. If the gap is too small, the concrete may not flow properly; if it is too large, the column may be too heavy and the concrete may not be effectively confined. The inner tube must be properly positioned and secured, and the concrete must be placed using a method that ensures complete filling of the annular space.

Fabrication Issue Root Cause Countermeasure
Non-uniform concrete layer Misalignment of inner tube Use spacers or centring devices to maintain a uniform gap
Incomplete filling of annular space Insufficient vibration or poor concrete workability Use self-compacting concrete; increase vibration frequency
Weld defects on outer tube Poor welding technique or contaminated surface Use qualified welders; clean the surface before welding
Corrosion of inner tube Moisture ingress during storage Apply a protective coating; store in a dry environment

The Fire Resistance Rating

The paper's findings have implications for the fire resistance rating of CFDST columns. A column that has been exposed to a fire and then cooled may have a residual capacity that is significantly lower than its original capacity. If the column is part of a structure that is to be reused after a fire, the residual capacity must be verified, and if it is insufficient, the column must be repaired or replaced. The paper provides a method for estimating the residual capacity, which can be used in this verification process.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises a fundamental question: what is the most important parameter in determining the post-fire capacity of a CFDST column? The answer, based on the paper's findings, is the peak temperature. The temperature determines the extent of the degradation of both the steel and the concrete, and it is the single most important factor in the residual capacity. The second most important factor is the outer steel tube yield strength, which determines the contribution of the steel to the overall capacity.

Another question that the paper does not fully address is the effect of the cooling phase. In a real fire, the structure is heated and then cooled, and the cooling phase can cause additional damage. For example, the rapid cooling of a hot steel tube can cause thermal shock, which may lead to cracking. The paper's model appears to consider the peak temperature only, and it does not account for the cooling rate. This is a limitation that should be addressed in future research.

The paper also does not address the effect of the loading history. In a real fire, the column is loaded, and the load is maintained during the fire. The paper's analysis appears to be based on the residual capacity after cooling, without considering the effect of the load during the heating phase. This is an important consideration because the load can cause additional deformation and cracking during the fire, which may reduce the residual capacity.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper provides a valuable contribution to the understanding of the post-fire behaviour of CFDST columns. The numerical model is well-validated, and the parametric study provides useful insights into the factors that influence the residual capacity. The findings are directly applicable to the assessment of fire-damaged structures, and they provide a basis for the development of design guidelines for the repair and retrofit of CFDST columns after a fire.

For the structural engineer, the key lesson is that the post-fire capacity of a CFDST column is primarily determined by the peak temperature and the outer steel tube yield strength. The concrete strength, while important at ambient temperature, becomes less significant after a fire. This means that the design of a CFDST column for fire resistance should focus on protecting the outer steel tube and the concrete layer, rather than on the inner tube.

For the fabricator, the paper highlights the importance of proper fit-up and concrete placement. A CFDST column is only as good as the quality of its fabrication, and any defect in the concrete layer or the steel tubes can compromise the structural performance.

In summary, this is a well-executed study that addresses a critical issue in the design and assessment of composite structures. The findings are practical and directly applicable, and they provide a solid foundation for the development of design guidelines. I would recommend this paper to anyone involved in the design, fabrication or assessment of CFDST columns, particularly those in fire-prone environments. The key takeaway is that the post-fire capacity of a CFDST column is not simply a fraction of its ambient capacity; it depends on the temperature history and the material properties, and it must be assessed on a case-by-case basis. The paper provides a tool for this assessment, and that is its greatest value.